View more on these topics

Does Osborne’s ‘guidance guarantee’ need a mass awareness campaign?

Experts are calling for a mass awareness campaign for pensions guidance next year after Legal & General saw just 2.5 per cent take-up in its initial pilot earlier this year.

Legal & General’s pilot of pensions guidance, carried out with The Pensions Advisory Service and LEBC, saw take-up of just 2.5 per cent

The pilot scheme wrote to 9,000 customers between April and May but just 225 retirees accepted the offer of guidance. Experts say the unwillingness of savers to engage with the guidance presents a significant policy challenge to the Treasury.

JLT Employee Benefits Trustee Solutions executive Margaret Snowden says: “We need a major pensions publicity and advertising campaign to encourage people to go for guidance. If there is then I would expect take-up to be closer to 30 per cent, which is probably not high enough. It depends on how it is promoted and how accessible it is. If it is low key, take-up will be poor as people are reluctant to put themselves forward.”

Labour shadow pensions minister Gregg Mclymont says the L&G pilot should act as a “warning” to policymakers.

Fidelity retirement director Alan Higham adds: “Without any changes to provider communication it simply leaves all the same problems the FCA found in its annuities review on engagement.”

Chartered Insurance Institute research into guidance, conducted in August, found 92 per cent of those surveyed said they would probably or definitely use guidance.

The study surveyed 1,000 “target users” who are within five years of retirement with a DC pot and other assets each of less than £100,000 and who did not have a financial adviser. 

CII head of policy and research Lawrence Baxter says: “Many [consumers] came round to the concept that an impartial guidance service could provide meaningful help.

“Not surprisingly, they need to be satisfied that the guidance really is impartial and is delivered by people who can demonstrate expertise in the issues. 

“Get those right – as well as the communication and promotion of this between the Government and the sector – and you might well see the sort of optimistic take-up that our respondents suggested.”

Expert view


This could be the start of a new industry of retirement guides, rather than advice. It will be more like an education, conversation or seminar, or it could be one-on-one. The guides could help you identify the right questions to ask and consider.

There needs to be a qualification. People want to know the person they are talking to is properly equipped and knows what they are doing. It could be basic guidance but at an approved standard with an approved qualification.

The retirement guides could come from private firms. Is this going to be a Government contract or a Government approved service? I think the latter. I don’t see the Government hiring the guides.

Ros Altmann is an independent pensions expert



Interest rate swap redress hits £1.5bn

The total amount paid out in redress for interest rate swap misselling by major banks has hit £1.5bn. The latest FCA data shows that as of the end of September, £1.5bn has been paid out and around 10,000 customers have accepted a redress offer. The regulator says that all nine banks involved in the scheme […]

Retirement plan-pension-report

Danby Bloch: Advisers must save clients from themselves

Advisers should be emphasising to clients just how much the proposed new rules for drawing retirement benefits have made registered pensions easily the most attractive vehicles for long-term savings. The  effective abolition of inheritance tax on death benefits have significantly added to their attractions. Most objections to investing in registered pensions have revolved around their […]

Handcuffs Justice Guilty 480

Fake property developer jailed for £30m mortgage fraud

A former Virgin Atlantic pilot has been jailed for 14 years after posing as a property developer in a £30m mortgage fraud. The BBC reports Mark Entwistle, 47, Iived a lavish lifestyle spending money at casinos in Las Vegas and on a luxury boat. Southwark Crown Court heard Entwistle used corrupt solicitors and accountants to […]

Where next for the price of oil?

Having stabilised at around $65 a barrel, many investors are questioning if the price of oil will rise, and when. Richard Hulf provides his view. Richard Hulf, manager of the Artemis Global Energy Fund, sets out his thoughts about how the oil price may move through the next six months. At the start of the […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There are 3 comments at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. Let me just get my extra large cheque book…

  2. How do you explain that the Money ADVICE service and The Pensions ADVISORY service won’t give you advice – for that you have to go elsewhere. That will be a tricky one to get across to the general public.

  3. Ros, I agree with what you say as a qualified adviser and I will deliver the service for the right price.
    However there are not enough advisers for the public to get the service promised by Osborne.
    The MAS and TPAS are mainly non qualified people so that will not work.
    We are a few months away from D Day now and still chaos reigns.

Leave a comment