View more on these topics

Derek lines up dominoes

I am about to sell a substantial investment but am concerned about the tax implications. Is there anything I can do to offset the capital gains tax liability?

Derek came to us with an interesting problem at the end of the last tax year.

He had invested in a property investment syndicate and the property had then been sold, resulting in a substantial capital gain. He was keen to do something about this if possible.

At the same time, the investment had thrown up a large income loss, which cannot be set against the capital gain. Part of this was through the writing down allowances available from the property and part from various penalties and charges arising on the redemption of the loans on the property. HM Revenue & Customs had said these could not be set against the gain – which is debateable.

Rental losses can only be set against rental income and it may be that the client will not have rental income in the future. Certainly, it would take some time to offset the level of losses. It therefore made sense to take advantage of the ability to carry the writing down allowances sideways against other income in the year.

Sadly, Derek did not have enough income so the first bit of the exercise was to create income by selling various offshore funds that would generate income gains.

On the capital gains front, it was decided to invest in an enterprise investment scheme that had been put to him that was particularly interesting as an investment opportunity. There were two decisions to make. How much offshore investment should be sold to create income and how much should be invested in the EIS to maximise relief but without being too risky?

Looking at the previous year’s figures, we were able to get a pretty good picture of his pensions and interest. We were then able to calculate how much should be sold to raise the required income, against which we would set the writing down allowances. This brought the income down to the right level so as not to lose personal allowances.

But we needed to factor in the capital gains tax. The first problem here was that the gain was so large that we decided to limit the chargeable gain to basic-rate tax. It was simply unfeasible to defer the full gain and the investment risk of the EIS did not make it worthwhile.

There are two tax elements to EIS investment – deferral of the capital gain and income tax relief. One important feature of the deferral rules is that EIS relief is given before taper relief, so we had to start with the gross gain. This was made just that little bit more difficult because some of the gain was a business asset so the taper rates were different.

Taking the various rates of tax and exemptions into account, we calculated the amount of untapered gain that we would want to shelter and thereby the amount to invest in the EIS.

However, there was also the income tax relief to be considered at 20 per cent of the investment. The problem was that EIS relief is a deduction against the tax payable rather than being a charge against income.

Having already reduced the taxable income to zero, there was no scope for relief. We could have created more income to soak up the EIS relief but that would have meant more of the capital gain (that we had brought below the higher-rate threshold) getting taxed at 40 per cent. The situation would be that Derek could have deferred some of the gains but lost out on income tax relief – clearly not ideal.

But there was one last opportunity. EIS investments can be made up to three years after the date of disposal to allow for deferral of capital gain. So Derek could hold off the EIS investment until after April 5. He would still be able to defer the gain and take advantage of the income tax relief.

We did not know what income he would have next year but at worst we could create more income gain by selling further offshore funds, in which there is a fair amount of profit. We knew that the EIS investment remained open for some time so there was that flexibility.

Mark Bolland is a director at Chamberlain de Broe


Canada Life reduces policy fee

Canada Life Group Insurance has announced its policy fee for business written through the eQuotes module of Class will reduce to £100.Canada Life says following the extension of eQuotes in April 2007, to allow intermediaries to complete the ‘on risk’ process online, this 66 per cent reduction in the policy fee reflects a sharing in […]

PFS and IFP must work together

The nonsense being spouted by Tim Eadon cannot go unchallenged. The PFS needs to adopt an honest, descriptive title for chartered members before it can begin to be taken seriously and gain respect. The title chartered financial planner is a misnomer for many holding it. There is nothing in the syllabus which calls upon an […]

Iain Chadwick

The Budget 2015: a brief overview

Following George Osborne’s delivery of his sixth Budget as chancellor and the last of this current parliament, we have provided a brief overview of the initiatives put forward in his statement, focusing on the topics that have an impact upon the pensions landscape, savings, personal taxation and businesses.


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers. Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm