View more on these topics

Dean Mirfin: Pension tax relief reform must retain saving incentive


The most significant point addressed in the consultation on the future of pensions tax relief, which closed last month, is that the current system is simply too complicated. Even the most astute individual will struggle to evaluate the most constructive method of saving for retirement.

The truth of any system – be that state provision, company or personal – is that the landscape pretty much never stops changing. We are asked to plan for our retirement but, regardless of the rate of tax we pay, the numbers are always moving. If our tax rate changes, so does the level of relief we receive.

The state pension is, in theory, about to become simpler. However, pensions minister Ros Altmann has had to explain many will not get anything like a single rate, which is complex enough in itself. Just to make things even more difficult, we also have the never-ending changes to the lifetime allowance and annual contribution limits.

So, what is the answer? Is there a simpler and fairer way? One of the more radical proposals is to tax pensions like Isas, which would involve moving from the current exempt-exempt-taxed model to a taxed-exempt-exempt one. But transparency and consistency are key. The only way to ensure some certainty for savers is in the form of what they are given at the point of contribution.

A promise of something at retirement is the one thing consumers will not have faith in. With the potential change of government every five years, younger savers in particular need an “at point of contribution” incentive. Why would they lock money away for no immediate incentive and the promise of something decades away that may not exist when they get there?

There are two potential solutions the Treasury could introduce to simplify the process, as well as retain the incentive to save into a pension.

The first is a single level of tax relief. A rate in the region of 30 per cent, which has been discussed by many as a fixed rate of government contribution, has to be seen as a huge positive from both an administrative perspective, as well as from a marketing perspective in helping take this level of incentive seriously.

The other option would be to completely remove the lifetime allowance and to have an annual contribution limit that will attract the Government contribution. If you exceed this limit, you can still fund to a higher level but you will not receive further contribution from the government in that tax year on the excess. Those funds can still grow within the tax efficient environment of the pension, however.

Ultimately, whether the Treasury likes it or not you cannot expect individuals to save for their retirement if there is no incentive to do so, and that will come at a price. However, if that price is an ongoing reduction in the benefit burden supporting pensioners with low incomes, the maths cannot be too difficult to do.

I hope responses to the consultation have focused on keeping tax relief simple and transparent, as well as proving that paying into something that locks money away for many years is a good thing. The only way to achieve that is through a simple, financially robust system with a clear incentive to save in a way that is stable and tax-efficient.

The Treasury has a great opportunity to keep those with pensions already onside and even more incentivised, as well as encourage those who are disenfranchised to engage with retirement planning. In the end, this can only be good for the UK population, the Government and for those providing the advice.

Dean Mirfin is technical director at Key Retirement



Is DWP’s ‘Workie’ really a colossal waste of money?

What is 10 feet tall, has two horns and is covered in multi-coloured fur? Well, if you believe some members of the advice community, the answer is a complete waste of money. It is fair to say the reveal of “Workie” and the Department for Work and Pensions’ new marketing campaign to promote workplace pensions […]


Osborne defends tougher accountability rules for advisers

Chancellor George Osborne has promised tough new rules which shift responsibility from the FCA to firms’ senior managers will be applied proportionality to advisers. Last week, the Treasury announced the senior managers regime will be extended to all regulated firms at some stage during 2018. This means individual businesses, rather than the FCA, will be […]


Opinion poll

The report (Money Marketing, October 25) that Marlborough Stirling&#39s research has found that 53 per cent of people prefer not to meet their financial adviser in person flies in the face of general perceptions. It also contradicts other (perhaps more disinterested) research studies as well. Typically, you would expect to find that some 70 per […]


Standard Life ‘sailing close to wind’ on investment advice

Standard Life has been accused of overstepping the line between advice and guidance in a letter that suggests clients switch to a higher-charging fund. The provider has written to thousands of customers urging them to review whether its Annuity Purchase fund is still suitable for them. The letter says the fund is designed for customers […]

The FCA’s five fixes for retirement information

The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) has started to change the way that people will be told about their pension options. In a recent market study paper, they lay out their final proposals on the information that should be delivered to people approaching retirement and how it should look and feel. During 2015, there will be […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm