View more on these topics

Danby Bloch: Reasons to be hopeful about auto-enrol opt-outs


The automatic enrolment market for advisers is changing rapidly. So if you are in it or contemplating getting into it, your top priority must be to get to grips with how it is changing. I recently chaired one of the Money Marketing auto-enrolment invitationals which was an eye-opener for me, not least because of the high level of adviser interest in the subject – more than earlier in the year and a lot more than in 2013.

Up until now, all auto-enrolment has been with larger employers. Advisers have learned about the key problems with employers who, by and large, were big enough to cope with the changes and introduce the new system. And they were mainly competent enough to either organise their own auto-enrol processes or sufficiently savvy to pay for professional advice.

Of course there were plenty of exceptions. Just because an organisation is big does not mean it is well organised, or even that it approaches such challenges as auto-enrolment in a spirit of integrity and open-mindedness. I distinctly recall some pensions advisers reporting the case (this is a true story) of a high pressure sales oriented employer to whom they had presented their auto-enrolment consultancy solution. The boss of this firm was adamant that none of his employees would join. And on being asked why, he replied with a smiley menace that is not easy to convey on paper: “Well, they wouldn’t if they wanted to keep their jobs, would they?” He then laughed off suggestions that the authorities might become mildly suspicious if several hundred of his employees miraculously decided to opt out of auto-enrolment in unison.

In fact the level of compliance has been remarkably high so far, according to The Pensions Regulator, with remarkably little enforcement activity. Perhaps the threat of enforcement is enough, or maybe it is just that the pensions industry has been engaging with what is naturally the most compliant part of the market. Even so it seems that about a quarter of employers have been staging late. A by-product of good employer compliance has been a low average opt-out rate of about 10 per cent so far.

The next stage – smaller employers

But now we are about to move into very different territory. The staging dates for smaller employers are now fast approaching, with a huge bulge between 2015 and 2018. Will they be as compliant? And will the opt-out rate be as low? One reason to be hopeful about the opt-out rate is there is not much difference in the social and economic profiles of large and small employers. The motivation to pay into the pension and not to opt-out should be about the same.

The difference will be the smaller employer environment – will it be encouraging and efficient or will it turn out to be a shambolic turn-off?

Another reason for optimism is the success of the major revolution to PAYE reporting by employers last year in the form of real time information. Did you hear of any significant complaints or mistakes by employers large or small? No, nor did I. So maybe there is cause for hope.

The main difference between auto-enrolment so far and the approaching years is relatively few smaller employers will want to pay for advice and assistance with auto-enrolment. They will want the slickest job for the least additional cost and preferably no extra cost.

The advice dilemma

Advisers will need to decide whether and how much they want to be involved. And even if they do decide to get involved, they will almost certainly want to choose solutions where they can leave it to the payroll organisation and the product provider to get on with process as seamlessly as possible and wholly automated. The premium will be primarily on the slickness of the relationship between those two components and helping sort out technical problems, like who is an eligible worker. 

Employers will need quick, easy and scaleable solutions. For most SMEs the right choice will not be about fund selection, or bells and whistles. It might not greatly hinge on charges.

When choosing a provider, advisers will need to be clear about who is getting the admin right and who is not. That will be the crucial criterion in SME-land. Ask around in the market about which companies seem able to cope and which are in the wars.

The other issue is ensuring payroll providers are fully up to scratch when it comes to meshing with pension providers. Make sure your employers have one of the relatively few systems that does seem to work, like the up-to-date auto-enrol payroll software from Sage. 

It is important to give good auto-enrolment recommendations. Advisers who get it wrong will lose time and goodwill clearing up the problems, in all likelihood for not much return. Advisers who get auto-enrolment right may move onto higher added value advice and services for senior executives, business owners, and people who have built significant pension savings.

Danby Bloch is editorial director of Taxbriefs Financial Publishing 

The Keys to your marketing

The personalised Key Guides series keeps your clients up to date with planning ideas across a range of life events. An annual subscription to 13 PDFs includes:

  • Pensions flexibility – the new rules
  • You and yours – estate planning
  • Investing for income when you retire
  • Workplace pensions and auto-enrolment
  • Investing for children

Updated quarterly, the Key Guides are a core component of your client marketing. To find out more call Alex Broughton on 020 7970 4196


Annuities cover

Has Osborne’s ‘death tax’ reform dealt fatal blow to annuities?

George Osborne chose to detonate yet another pensions policy bomb at the Conservative Party conference this week. The last time the Chancellor stood up and spoke about pensions he unleashed the most radical reforms for almost a hundred years. The latest announcement – that “death tax” charges on pensions are to be cut from April […]


Should mortgage lenders pay towards the pensions guidance levy?

Money Advice Service non-executive director Laurie Edmans says mortgage lenders should pay towards the guidance guarantee levy in order to reduce costs for regulated advisers. Speaking to a fringe event at the Liberal Democrat conference in Glasgow yesterday, Edmans, who was speaking in a personal capacity, claimed advisers would benefit from the guidance regime. Alongside […]


Wonga to write off 330,000 loans after FCA intervention

Wonga will write off 330,000 customers’ loan balances after the FCA found evidence the payday lender was failing to adequately assess customers’ ability to meet repayments. After taking over regulation of consumer credit in April this year, the FCA requested information about the volume of Wonga’s relending rates. The regulator says the information it received […]

Europe 2017: Value, large-caps & liquidity

Joshua Ausden, Head of Client Investment Strategy, Neptune Read more here Important Information – for Investment Professionals Only. Not for Retail Clients.Investment risksNeptune funds may have a high volatility rating and past performance and forecasts are not a guide to future performance. These are Neptune’s views and as such this document is deemed to be […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm