View more on these topics

Danby Bloch: Why clients should hang on to their pensions

Danby Bloch white

The ideal inheritance plan allows you to pass an asset down to the next generation tax-free on death but be able to access it for your own use beforehand if needed. Defined contribution pensions enable you to do just that.

The default strategy of many advisers now is to recommend their older clients keep their pension funds intact as long as they possibly can, only drawing on them if needed for long-term care or other later-life requirements. The pension fund can then be passed down free of IHT to the next generation, and perhaps even beyond.

It is a win-win situation. Retain the pension for as long as possible and die with it: heads, your family wins. Hold onto the pension as long as you can and spend it on having the best possible end of life long-term care: tails, you win as well. OK, death and dementia do not sound like winning but you see what I am saying. But is it really that straightforward?

Keeping things IHT-free

The elements of pension freedoms that introduced the current position were the lifting of the restrictions on taking benefits before age 75 and the new tax rules on death benefits. An individual does not have to take their pension benefits before reaching the age of 75. They can just leave them undrawn, or partly drawn. And there are no longer any restrictions related to reaching age 75 on the pension commencement lump sum and most other lump sum death benefits.

True, if there are uncrystallised funds at age 75, there is a benefit crystallisation event (BCE5) to test the level of benefits against the lifetime allowance. But that is pretty much it.

Death benefits – lump sum or income – post-age 75 are subject to income tax in the hands of the person who receives them and taxed accordingly. If you are the beneficiary of someone who has died before age 75, you have won a fiscal lottery and your lump sum will be free of income tax. This fiscal “luck-of-the-draw” system will bizarrely continue for death benefits cascading down later generations. At least for now.

Lump sum death benefits are virtually always free of IHT. There is something of a question mark over contributions to pensions or transfers to defined benefit schemes made shortly before the member’s death, especially if they were in poor health at the time. But otherwise the position is pretty safely free of IHT.

So for the minority of people with enough other non-pension capital and income, the natural strategy would be to leave the pension to pass IHT-free to their families, only drawing on it as a last resort.

As mentioned, though, this last resort could arise if they are unfortunate enough to need some expensive long-term care. This could easily end up costing as much as £50,000 a year; possibly much more depending on the degree of luxury they want and where they live.

At that point, the basic strategy of holding onto the pension for as long as possible might not turn out to be the best thing to do in particular circumstances.

Property possibilities

Lots of factors could come into play here and affect the choice between selling a home or drawing on a pension. The existing property might be needed to house a surviving partner or other dependant, or a downturn in the property market could make it hard to sell. It could be that it is better to rent the home and get a yield. There is also the issue of how large the IHT nil-rate band might be at the time, compared with the client’s potential estate at death.

One question is whether to draw the PCLS reasonably early on – say, while the client is in their late-60s or early-70s. Of course, it all depends on circumstances.

The advantage is that the undrawn PCLS will boost the value of the client’s IHT-free fund. But against that, an asset that was once income tax free will almost certainly be taxable in the hands of the person who inherits it. The strategy would save IHT only to end up generating an income tax liability – although possibly at a lower rate depending on the recipient’s circumstances.

So it might be better for some scheme members to draw their PCLSs early on. They might decide to use it for making a lifetime cash gift, setting up a trust or just for buying an investment that qualifies for business property relief. After all, a BPR investment has much the same win-win advantages as a pension, it is just that the underlying investments mostly have to be rather more risky and restricted. Hang on to your pensions.

Danby Bloch is chairman at Helm Godfrey


Danby Bloch

Danby Bloch: The value of cashflow planning

Advisers are not using long-term cashflow planning with enough of their clients at retirement or on a regular basis once clients have retired, acccording to Platforum research conducted over the summer. The findings are rather discouraging. Long-term cash flow planning should be at the heart of retirement and in-retirement advice. It also makes a lot […]

Danby Bloch

Danby Bloch: The next tax scheme HMRC has in its sights

There is an amazing new tax scheme that is said to turn income into capital gains. Better yet, the capital gains are only taxed at 10 per cent because they benefit from entrepreneurs’ relief. The scheme operates like this. You have a company that is currently paying you from its profits and you sell the […]

The Merchants Trust PLC – April 2017

Welcome to the latest update for The Merchants Trust PLC from the Trust’s portfolio manager, Simon Gergel. Portfolio Review The Merchants Trust reported results this month and the directors were pleased to announce a 35th consecutive year of dividend growth (subject to shareholder approval at the AGM). The Company is proud to be highlighted as […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There are 5 comments at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. “There is something of a question mark over contributions to pensions or transfers to defined benefit schemes made shortly before the member’s death….” Should that read transfers FROM defined benefit schemes?

  2. Hello Mark, my understanding is that HMRC would also question the IHT effectiveness of a pension contribution if the member knew they were in serious ill health at the time the contribution was made – otherwise what a great way to get round the issue of Potentially Exempt Transfers.

  3. Danby,

    On the other hand you may have noticed that pension rules have changed a little from time to time. And who knows what they will be in the future? So reducing all other liquid assets (in order to obtain an IHT result that may never happen) may in retrospect look like a poor decision. A future government could easily reverse the pensions freedoms and return to the policy of limiting the maximum drawdown.

    Better to keep a balance of pension and other assets.

  4. Always wise not to soleley rely on any one solution as Mr Etkind points out. However there is another very effective IHT mitigation plan. It’s called an annuity. Yes, hang on to your pension for as long as possible and the older you get the better the rate. (And with interest rates likely to be going up – so much the better). If you take benefits at (say) 70 there is a reasonable chance you (or your spouse) may live to 90. If you have other assets the annuity is a safe risk free and reliable income that can form the cornerstone of your cash flow, augmented by other assets such as ISAs, Bonds, Property and of course the State Pension, which has been inflated as a result of deferral.

  5. I’m increasingly suggesting take the PCLS in late 60’s to fund gifts as a ‘living inheritance’ at a time when the recipients often most need support – eg raising a young family – then leave the rest for the optionality the article explains.

Leave a comment


Why register with Money Marketing ?

Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

Money Marketing Events
Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

Research and insight
Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

Have your say
Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

Register now

Having problems?

Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm