View more on these topics

Create a savings culture to close the widest gap

It has become fashionable to say that only way to close the £27bn savings gap is to compel people to save. But the “compulsion” argument misses the point. The real issue is where that gap is widest.

Of course, it is of great concern that there is a huge gap between what people need to save and what they actually save to provide for a comfortable retirement. But even with compulsion, the only solution is through universal participation that makes saving as ingrained in the British culture as afternoon tea.

Some segments of the population are already sophisticated savers. Remember that Wealthy Britain embraced stakeholder pensions, buying them for tiny tots and non-working wives from day one. It is a different story among the wider population, many who are low-earners or unwaged, and it is here that the savings gap is acutely worrying. It is principally because of concern over this group that we have the myriad regulatory reviews now under way.

Put simply, there are no mechanisms that can compel the country&#39s less affluent to save without exchanging the risk of poverty in retirement for actual hardship now.

There are some big obstacles that could easily be eradicated. For starters, people should have one, portable pension pot that they take with them throughout their life whether they change jobs or become self-employed.

Next, we should scrap the state retirement age. It no longer reflects the population&#39s ability and inclination to work beyond 65. Instead, we could have a more flexible requirement for individuals to work for a given number of years and then choose to retire at whatever age they wanted.

Then there is reform of our complex benefits&#39 system. It involves means-testing, which is unpopular, costly to run and acts as a disincentive to saving. Moreover, in its rush to make savers of us all, the Government risks making society&#39s most needy waste money by contributing to a pension that will provide an income equivalent to that available through the benefits&#39 system.

It is easy to see how the system could become more user-friendly. The basic state pension could be raised to the level of the minimum income guarantee, making the pension credit redundant. Serps and the state second pension could be phased out, confining the confusing concept of contracting to the rubbish bin.

The regulatory system also needs simplification. This burdensome regime has hindered take-up of stakeholder. A lighter regulatory touch could easily be applied to these simple products without any threat to consumers. For example, the qualifications for those delivering worksite presentations could be reduced to the same level as for non-regulated pensions. This would ease the process of choosing a stakeholder, with revamped decision trees being used by second tier advisers.

Such reforms depend on overhaul of the benefits&#39 system – particularly contracting-out advice – which arguably deters advisers from selling stakeholders to low-earners for fear of misselling charges.

Finally, there have been plenty of calls for the rule compelling the purchase of an annuity at 75 to be scrapped. Of course, alternatives to annuities would allow greater freedom for those retiring with very large funds, without reducing the Treasury&#39s tax take. But it would make more sense to improve the situation for the majority of the population before turning to the wealthier. We need sensible ways of helping people understand annuities and get the right products at a good rate.

It is time for the debate to move away from compulsion and on to creating a savings culture where the savings gap is widest.

Tom Fraser Managing director,

AMP UK Financial


Equitable slashes maturity and surrender values again

Equitable Life has again been forced to slash maturity and surrender values to maintain solvency after recent market falls.The maturity value will now be reduced by 10 per cent from 4 per cent before. Early surrenders will incur a penalty of 20 per cent up from 14 per cent.The society describes the move as “most […]

Top lenders disagree with CML call for rate rise

Some of the UK&#39s biggest lenders have washed their hands of the CML&#39s unprecedented call to increase interest rates after it made the move without consulting members.HBOS, the biggest lender with a 24.8 per cent market share, says it was “very surprised” by the call to increase rates now to avoid bigger rises in the […]

FSA says depolarisation rules will be out by Christmas

The FSA has set itself a deadline of Christmas to publish its consultations the new post polarisation regime.It says it has been deluged by responses to CP121 from the industry and consumers, some of which are large in size and require time to process. The regulator also says it will have to take the reviews […]

ABI calls on MPs for £500m tax breaks to fund advice

The Government should fund financial advice in the workplace to the tune of £500m a year by providing tax incentives to employers which offer their staff access to IFAs, says the ABI.In a speech to the all-party Parliamentary group on insurance and financial services this week, ABI director general Mary Francis outlined an action plan […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers. Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and thought leadership.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm