View more on these topics

Costs and benefits of transfer

My employer is in the process of closing down the contracted-out money-purchase scheme of which I am a member. It is being replaced with a group personal pension. It has been suggested that I transfer the fund that I have built up into the new scheme. I have been in the old scheme since January 1988. Please advise as to the options.>

Your options are as follows:

1. Refund of your contributions if you have been a member for less than two years. This can be imposed on you by your employer. You would suffer a tax charge of 15 per cent on the refund.

2. Leave the benefits where you are.

3. Transfer to a section 3buyout.

4. Transfer to the new group personal pension or an alternative personal pension.

The first option would make you forfeit your employer&#39s contributions and should be effectively disregarded.

At first glance, the last three options would suggest that the principal considerations are the effect of charges and the performance of the pension funds. Important as these considerations are, attention should also be devoted to the impact of any possible change in the maximum benefits resulting from the transfer.

If you leave the benefits where they are or transfer them to a section 32 buyout they will be subject to Inland Revenue limits on maximum benefits when you retire. You will be entitled to a pension at your normal retirement age which is the greater of one-sixtieth of your final salary per year of service, or one thirtieth of your final salary per year of service less any retained benefits. Your final salary is restricted to £100,000 if you earn more than this or are a controlling director.

Alternatively, you could draw a tax-free cash sum three-eightieths of your final salary. If you draw a higher rate than one-sixtieth per year of service your tax-free cash can be increased proportionately. Based on 10 years service your maximum tax-free cash sum can be lifted to 36/80ths of your final salary, provided that your maximum allowable pension before commutation is 10/30ths of your final salary. Retained benefits would need to be taken into account if the higher figure is to be used and your final salary would be restricted to £100,000. If you draw the tax-free cash sum, your maximum pension would be reduced by a factor specified by the Inland Revenue.

The maximum benefits are worked out at the date when you cease to be a member of the old scheme. They can be increased in deferment by up to RPI.

You can retire early from age 50 onwards and receive a pension and tax-free cash sum based on 1/60ths and 3/80ths respectively without any reduction. Alternatively, the higher accrual rate can be used but the benefits would need to be proprtionately reduced according to the formula:

N/NS times P(or LS), where

N = Actual years of service in the scheme

NS = Prospective years of service to normal retirement

P = Maximum allowable pension

LS = Maximum allowable tax-free cash

Final salary is given a number of definitions by the Inland Revenue depending on your status – it is also specified in the scheme documents.

Benefits can be transferred to a personal pension without needing to certify that they do not exceed the Inland Revenue maxima. For controlling directors, employees aged over 45 at the date of transfer and those earning in excess of the earnings cap (in 1997/98, £84,000), the ceding scheme is required to certify the benefits.

The maximum pension that can be certified is calculated by escalating the present value of the fund to the member&#39s normal retirement date by 3 per cent per annum. The maximum pension is the amount that could be secured by an annuity rate of £83.33 per £1,000 of pension fund less the value of any retained benefits at the date of transfer. The maximum tax-free cash sum is 2.25 times the maximum pension. These amounts can be increased in deferment by RPI.

Within a personal pension the maximum tax-free cash, even for non-certified members, is 25 per cent of the fund on retirement. This could be less than the entitlement under the original scheme. For certified members the maximum tax-free cash sum is the lesser of the certified tax-free cash or 25 per cent of the value of the fund.

This outline of the options illustrates the complexity of the choices available to you. In order to advise in more detail further information would be needed both about the scheme and your personal financial objectives.


Pru venture capital arm touted as Cunard buyer

Prudential&#39s venture capital arm PPM Ventures is staying tightlipped over reports that it is negotiating to buy the cruise liner company Cunard. PPM Ventures, which specialises in management buyouts of unquoted companies, is rumoured to be looking to buy the company which has been losing money since its owner Trafalgar House was taken over by […]

ASA slams Direct Line ad

The Advertising Standards Authority has upheld complaints against Direct Line over its claim to offer an instant-access savings account. A national press ad was headlined, Direct Line Instant Access Account….Up to 5.75 per cent gross. But complainants argued that the account was not instant access because investors had to phone Direct Line to have the […]

M&S is looking at execution-only GPPs

Marks & Spencer Financial Services is considering a move into the group personal pension market on an execution-only basis pledging to undercut rivals&#39 charges. The retailer, which already offers personal pensions, unit trusts, Peps and term insurance, is in the middle of a feasibility study on whether the market will fit its strategy. The proposal […]

Sipp mates

Eagle Star&#39s Flexible Drawdown Plan, in conjunction with James Hay Pension Trustees, aims to offer a flexible charging structure to meet the needs both of commission and fee-based IFAs. Our panel look first at how it fits into the market. Tinslay says: “The plan offers a good self-invested facility and is simple in structure. Eagle […]

Healthcare regulation amalgamation predicted for Gulf states

While Dubai is leading the way in terms of legislating for expat healthcare in the Gulf, Qatar, Abu Dhabi and others are watching and learning – that’s according to Jelf International’s director of international services, Doug Rice. He believes the pace of change in the Gulf states will continue and that some level of unified healthcare system will be introduced across the region.


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers. Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and thought leadership.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm