View more on these topics

Corporation street

The Inland Revenue is seeking to consult with a view to modernising corporation tax to:

•Improve business competitiveness. Of interest to advisers is the intention to look closely at the removal of tax distortions that affect commercial decision-making. The expressed aim is that business decisions should be made on commercial rather than tax grounds.

•Maintain fairness in taxation, especially ensuring that individual businesses pay their fair share of tax in relation to commercial profits.

One of the key drivers of tax change is the Revenue&#39s apparent desire to tax all types of income and gains in the same way. Another is continuing the move to align taxable profits with accounting profits. The Revenue focuses on the fact that, for companies, the indexation allowance is available to reduce taxable capital gains whereas commercial accounts are generally not inflation-adjusted and are usually prepared on an historic cost basis.

The proposals would probably not have been put forward in this official consultative document if they did not have some appeal or reasonableness. But should financial advisers and product providers spend time becoming familiar with its terms since there is no guarantee that any will make it beyond proposal status?

My view is that investing time in acquiring an awareness of potential changes and developments in the market will prove worthwhile.

Relationships with corporate clients, potential clients and their other professional advisers are founded on the trust they have in you. Your demonstrated understanding and competence is a key foundation for that trust. I do not think that any of us would disagree that becoming familiar with the contents of a consultative document on the taxation of a potentially profitable sector of your client base makes sense.

Perhaps most worrying for corporate advisers is that paragraphs 2.11 and 2.12 state that: “The current regime in which only corporate gains are adjusted for inflation for tax purposes [companies do not qualify for taper relief though – my words, not the Revenue&#39s] is likely to increase rather than reduce distortions – the deferral of taxation until realisation favours investment in assets which generate gains and indexation allowance reinforces this effect” and “It is therefore the Government&#39s view that following a company&#39s commercial profits for tax purposes should reduce some of the distortions arising from the present regime.”

Following the accounting principles could well mean that no indexation allowance will be given and tax on gains or losses will be assessed on a year-by-year basis where assets themselves are already dealt with on a mark-to-market basis – which is often the case where there is a ready market in the assets but less so where there is not a ready market.

The possibility of moving to a system where capital allowances are no longer given is also put forward for discussion. It is relatively well known that it is common accountancy practice to depreciate capital assets acquired by a business. Simply put, this means the value of a capital asset is reduced each year in the balance sheet. This is so even if the real or market value is increasing. An obvious example occurs with property, where the value may be written down by, say, 4 per cent a year whereas its market value may be increasing by 20 per cent a year.

What is going on? It is probably best explained after noting that there is a correlating impact on the profit and loss account. Where the depreciation reduces profits, this is the accountant&#39s way of setting aside a reasonable amount out of profits to provide for a replacement property, it being assumed that capital equipment goes down in value at a particular rate and then has to be replaced, so it is necessary to save up out of profits each year to buy a replacement.

This is not to say that the amount deducted from profits for depreciation is actually put in a replacement property fund, just that deducting an amount for depreciation leaves less stated accounting profit for distribution. Depreciation is allowed for at different rates for different capital assets

But there is no tax relief for depreciation so, when calculating taxable profits, it is necessary to add back depreciation. One then has to consult the capital allowances legislation to determine whether the expenditure incurred qualifies for writing down allowances. It is here that we see a difference in what is allowed for under taxation and what is allowed under accounting principles.

So, financial advisers and product providers should be concerned about the:

•Potential abolition of the indexation allowance.

•Possible taxation of capital gains and losses accruing but not yet realised on a year-by-year basis.

•Possible loss of capital allowances for tax as we move towards a system that seeks to align tax principles with accounting principles.

Designers of investment products for companies will need to carry out some modelling to determine what outcomes could emerge if the changes materialise.

Parts of this article have previously appeared in Money Marketing

Recommended

The with-profits debate

FORDAVID HAREHead of with-profits marketing, Standard LifeI was glad to see the words “remains a good option” in the motion because it seems all too easy to forget just what a good choice with-profits has been for many investors.It is over 200 years since with-profits policies were introduced as a way of dealing with uncertain […]

Coventry BS appoints new general manager for marketing

Coventry Building Society has appointed Mark Murphy to its executive team as general manager, marketing. Murphy, 36, joins from Abbey National where he worked for 12 years in a number of management positions, most recently as business development director of First National Bank. He will be responsible for all Coventry&#39s marketing activities.

Protection boosted with cap on units

The new FSA regulations mean fund managers will be able to cap the number of units in funds giving them greater ability to move their holdings and provide more protection to investors.The regulations, aimed at reforming the structure of unit trusts and Oeics, published last week offer up a substantial number of new changes to […]

L&G tracking fund offers links to 100 global companies

Legal & General has set up a tracking fund, the global 100 index trust, giving investors exposure to 100 of the biggest international companies.It says with forecasters, including the G7 economic intelligence unit, predicting growth in some of the world&#39s major markets over the next five years, global companies could be the right sector to […]

Newsletter

News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up

Comments

    Leave a comment