View more on these topics

Compulsory purchase

The Government&#39s flagship pension project has finally been launched after a lengthy and controversial development process. The introduction of price capping amounts to arguably the biggest intervention in the free market of this Government&#39s administration and the price-capping features will doubtless be noted by other professions across the economy.

The launch comes just as IFAs are pausing for breath after the close of the Isa season, and the two-stage introduction of stakeholder means the industry and the Government has two distinct opportunities to heighten public awareness of the product.

Most IFAs are seeing little change in the first days of the stakeholder era as they have been talking to clients about stakeholder products for some weeks now. But IFAs believe the real take-up of stakeholder will begin when the threat of a £50,000 fine looms over employers&#39 heads.

IFAs are finding, not surprisingly, that the public response to stakeholder varies according to local demographics and the make-up of their client base.

Rural IFAs are reporting low interest levels as the majority in their communities are self-employed or work in very small businesses.

But even in urban areas with higher concentrations of workers employed in large concerns, some IFAs are saying interest has not been what the Government will have hoped for.

IFA Financial Dimensions principal Fari Serajian says: “Employers seem interested in it but from what I&#39ve seen employees are just not interested if there is not going to be any contribution from employers. The companies seem happy to set up a scheme, but as soon as you ask whether employees want to pay, they don&#39t want to know.”

Serajian says: “Eventually, the Government will realise you have to force people to make it work. After the election the Government will make payment into a personal pension compulsory. There is no other choice.”

Featherstone Independent Financial Services partner Jean Featherstone agrees, and the notion of compulsion as the driving force for any change seems to be a view a lot of IFAs take.

Featherstone says: “So far it has been a bit of a damp squib. We haven&#39t had any enquiries from the general public. Some employers have enquired, but those who know they can wait until October will do so.”

But this apathy has not been the experience of all IFAs. John Carmichael Financial Services principal John Carmichael says: “I thought employees would be less interested than they have been. I have found that employers are less interested than employees. I have given seven presentations from which I have got four schemes signed up. About 50 per cent of the employees from those four businesses have shown an interest in making contributions themselves.”

If the Government&#39s goal is to make all workers provide for their own retirement through stakeholder pensions, then it seems compulsion is going to be required all the way down the line. If many employers are only going to set up stakeholder schemes when they have to next October, then it follows that making employees take out stakeholder pensions will require compulsion.

Bankhall member C&J Independent Financial Advisers partner Barrie Jeffery says: “People are putting it off until after the election, and then after the summer holidays. Come September there will be a mad rush. But compulsion will require someone brave enough to stand up and say &#39you&#39ve got to save for your retirement&#39. It will be an extra tax of around 15 per cent, which is going to be a problem for any Government.”

Whether stakeholder will be taken up before the threat of the October deadline will reflect the success of the media campaigns of both the Government and the pension providers.

The sheepdog TV commercials seem like a distant memory and there has been little publicity since.

IFA Chambers Morgan James director Marlene Shalton says: “I don&#39t think the stakeholder advertising campaign has been successful. There were just a few adverts about dogs. Many of my clients had not heard about it. If they want the product to succeed, the Government and the product providers will have to do a lot more advertising, given the apathy of the general public.”

Some IFAs believe the interim period between introduction in April and compulsion in October will lead to a period where customers will buy stakeholder pensions and then want to change out of them if their employer sets up a scheme.

E Farley & Son (Life & Pensions) director Maurice Dowcra says: “If an individual asks me about a stakeholder pension, the first thing I will ask is how many people work for his employer. If he says five or more, I will tell him to hold on.

“I am not going to set up a pension where the employer might later set up a scheme where he makes a contribution. The industry is in a muddle and every IFA should be nervous about setting up a stakeholder pension for an individual.

&#39I would advise doing nothing until you know what your employer is doing, apart from trying to get to the employer and sell them a scheme.”

Morgan Nevill managing director Mike Nevill says: “Some clients are asking why they should pay our fees for advice when the banks will set it up for nothing. That is fine. I will just go back to them in two years time when the Government brings in compulsion and you have to put money in, and compare performance. I will then get them to transfer to a new company. As the funds will have some money in, it will be worth doing.”

But Torquil Clark pensions development director Tom McPhail does not see a problem. He says: “The employee can stop or transfer the stakeholder pension without penalty. He might not like what the employer puts in front of him. If he has enthusiasm to set up a stakeholder pension now, he should do it, but the IFA should certainly consider whether an employer&#39s scheme is going to be set up.

McPhail is positive about the opportunities for stakeholder. He says: “Stakeholder is one of the best things to happen to IFAs. Any IFA wanting to get into the employer market has the best introduction they are going to get. I like stakeholder.”


Give Nationwide credit for daily interest

I read with interest the article, IFAs&#39 anger over Nationwide Cat on mortgages (Money Marketing, April 5). I do think that this is being unfair to Nationwide because although it has applied a Cat standard across the range of products (and what&#39s wrong with that?), Nationwide – unlike the Halifax – gives daily interest automatically […]

Pavilion moves into hedge funds

Pavilion Asset Management is making its first foray into the hedge fund market with the introduction of the multimanager fund of hedge funds.The fund is aimed at high net worth investors who are looking for a medium risk fund. Listed on the Dublin stock exchange and domiciled in the Cayman Islands, the fund is an […]


With the end of tax business rush safely out of the way, now is a good time for IFAs to spend investigating some of the new technology products and services that have emerged over the last few months. None of these can be more important than the electronic new business services that are now available […]

Rationalisation of provision is key to pensions

As a party, we are fundamentally more likely to allow the financially independent to make their own provision for retirement rather than the present Government which is telling people what to do with their own money. We want to create a climate of change in people&#39s attitudes to retirement provision in the same way that […]

'Feeling the Squeeze'

Royal London carried out a UK wide survey with 2,500 consumers age 35-44 over the summer. The survey found that over a third, 34 per cent, said their finances felt Squeezed and so were struggling to meet day-to-day expenses, despite 87 per cent being aware that they need to save more. However, the survey did […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers. Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and thought leadership.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm