Clive Waller: Investment values – calling out the lies

Old wives’ tales persist in the face of uncomfortable truths about the value of investments

Myths tend to linger in the face of uncomfortable truths about the value of investments.

Prior to the FSA’s creation in 1986, most investment sales were in the form of bonds. Very few intermediaries sold funds directly to the public. One of the old wives’ tales (or old asset managers’ tales) that persists from that era is: you don’t lose money unless you sell. The tale emanates from efforts to stop investors selling when markets fell. The sentiment is legitimate but that doesn’t justify porky pies.

Had your client invested at the high point of 2018, their initial portfolio of £100,000 would, at the time of writing, be worth just £96,592. This does not allow for charges, I should add. If you follow the old wives’ tale, you would argue that it is a loss only if you sell, implying that it is worth £100,000 still. Sorry – not true.

So let’s look at other periods. If you had invested that same £100,000 at the 1999 high (lots did), the current value would be £110,114. Had you invested at the low of 2002 (few did), the current value would be £190,384. Move forward to 2007 and the figure drops to £115,456.

So, how do you value portfolios if you argue that you lose only if you sell? At the level when invested? At their high point? Or at the current valuation? Being sensible, we’d accept the current value is the best indication of worth – acknowledging that it can change quickly, both up and down. This may be uncomfortable for a client after a fall but cannot be overcome by deceit. It is the nature of real asset investment.

Clive Waller: Building relationships with experts

The upside-down nature of markets over the past 25 years makes planning hard. Recognition of capacity for loss creates the need for certainty of income in the early years of decumulation, be it via partial annuitisation or a cash/short bond bucket. When a company valuation drops, does the chief executive say ‘Not to worry, it matters only if you sell’? He may, but his chair, his shareholders and the financial press will mock him. Business and commerce could not survive on such a ludicrous mantra. Neither can retail investment.

Naturally, there is justification in educating clients to ignore the daily ups and downs of markets. This means one should treat highs with the same contempt as lows. The market is not a one-way valve where you can lock in gains and continue to participate.

The answer, of course, is diversification, but it is not a doddle. And bonds are no longer seen as defensive stock for when equities tumble. Short government bonds return little or nothing today. Long bonds look expensive and risky with low levels of liquidity. Most market-insensitive investments are regarded as high risk and unsuitable for non-professional investors.

Most of the time, the right advice is ‘Don’t sell.’ However, if you gave that advice in 1973, when the market had fallen 15 per cent, you wouldn’t have looked too clever to your client when it continued to tumble until it had lost nearly three-quarters of its value.

Ultimately, there’s no easy answer. However, I’m a great believer in taking some money off the table when markets appear high and good profits have been made, especially as one gets older and will need to decumulate.

Clive Waller is managing director of CWC Research

Follow him on Twitter @clivewaller


Cyber Security

Financial advisers risk underestimating cyber security

Advisers risk underestimating the threat of cyber crimes, analysis from NextWealth, on behalf of FundsNetwork has suggested. The survey of 206 advisers showed that planners are primarily concerned with the challenges presented by compliance and changing regulation – with only a small percentage worried about attacks on their systems or managing clients’ concerns about cyber […]

Ex-Coutts banker launches robo-advice offering

A former Coutts private banker has launched a digital wealth manager which aims to create bespoke investment solutions which combine artificial intelligence with top-tier human advice. Qiojia Li, who also formerly worked at Credit Suisse, met her co-founder, Gustavo Silva through Entrepreneur First, a talent investor which matches entrepreneurs to build their technology ideas from […]


Asset manager launches white-labelled platform

Clifton Asset Management has launched a white-labelled platform to manage cover funds, equities, ETFs, investment trusts and bonds. Viewpoint Portfolio will be available to external advisers, and will include a range of product wrappers including Sipp, Isa, junior Isa, offshore bond and general investment account. It will be managed by Clifton subsidiary pension provider Morgan […]


Standard Life Aberdeen advice arm acquires Grant Thornton planning business

Standard Life Aberdeen’s national advice arm 1825 has confirmed its acquisition of auditor Grant Thornton’s wealth advisory business in its largest deal to date. The acquisition brings 34 planners under the 1825 umbrella along with assets under advice of £1.7bn. This brings the SLA arm’s total assets to £5.8bn and is the first acquisition since […]

Modi: not out?

Investing in India over the past 18 months has been somewhat turbulent. In general, India has outperformed wider emerging markets in recent years, but in the last few months it has been a bumpy ride, with performance being driven by a combination of external macro drivers and domestic political considerations. Ewan Thompson, Head of Emerging […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There is one comment at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. Although I do agree that there can be too much glib talk around investments, I think perhaps the criticism of the mantra “you don’t lose money unless you sell” is a little disingenuous. This sentence could also be taken as shorthand for “don’t crystallise you loss by selling now”.

    For example in October 2002 the FTSE All share had dropped over 12% between 11th Sept and 24th Sept. By 1st Nov it had recovered by 8% and by mid November it had reached new peaks. So I guess the phrase that Clive objects to has a certain resonance in this instance.

Leave a comment


Why register with Money Marketing ?

Providing trusted insight for professional advisers. Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and thought leadership.

News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

Money Marketing Events
Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

Research and insight
Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

Have your say
Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

Register now

Having problems?

Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm