View more on these topics

Claim firm says Pearl Promise not worth paper it’s printed on

Claim-chaser Brunel Franklin says the Pearl Group should scrap its Pearl Promise to endowment policyholders as it says it is “not worth the paper it’s printed on”.

Pearl introduced the guarantee in April 2001, pledging to pay the mortgage in full if the endowment policy grows an average of 6 per cent a year from that time to maturity.

The company also says it will reduce a shortfall by a given amount if the policy grows at 4 per cent per year.

But Brunel Franklin claims director Ian Allison says the promise is meaningless as he claims that Pearl policies have never grown by 6 per cent a year in any of the last 10 years.

But Pearl has responded by saying that performance over the last 10 years is irrelevant. It admits it failed to meet the 6 per cent threshold in 2003 and 2004 but says the with-profits fund made 11.32 per cent in 2005 and 7.75 per cent in 2004 before taxation and expenses.

Allison also claims that Pearl is “railroading” customers into dropping the Pearl Promise or surrendering the policy if they accept compensation.

He says: “The Pearl Promise is a complete waste of time and is not worth the paper it is printed on.”

A Pearl spokesman says: “This is the most generous offer on the market. If people get compensation and also get this guarantee, then they get compensated twice, which is unfair to other policyholders.”

Recommended

Structured products recommended by 4 in 5 IFAs

Skandia says 80 per cent of advisers are recommending structured products to their clients, saying capital protection is one of the building blocks of a sensibly diversified portfolio.The recent survey of nearly 500 advisers also asked which features are most likely to influence them to recommend structured products to their clients. The most popular features […]

Too alternative for Aunt Agatha?

So, here we are, Christmas at last. The last chance I have to share with you my view of the investment scene before we all become immersed in turkey, mince pies and wrapping paper. My next column after this will be in 2007. How should I mark the ending of the old year, I wonder? […]

Protest letter aims to shame Brown

An IFA has written to Chancellor Gordon Brown protesting about the U-turn on pension term assurance and calling his pre-Budget announcement “morally indefensible”.BFS Co IFA Richard Boddie says the U-turn on PTA discriminates against the ill and impaired and has written to the Chancellor, Shadow Tory Chancellor George Osborne and his local Conservative MP for […]

Newsletter

News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up

Comments

    Leave a comment