View more on these topics

Chris Gilchrist: Investors, shoot your inner sheep

In the 1970s, an investor couldn’t diversify an equity portfolio unless they had around £100,000 in today’s money, because there were no index funds. Instead, we had paper share certificates, stamp duty and high dealing costs. And buying actively managed funds was more costly than buying shares.

Risk in that era meant not the geeky volatility of modern portfolio theory, but the possibility of a permanent loss of capital. The bankruptcy of the original Rolls-Royce business in March 1971 reminded everyone of that.  Because the FT Index, composed of 30 blue-chips including RR, was a geometric index (multiply the prices of all constituents and take the 30th root), the index plunged as RR shares tanked. Any zero in the multiplication series would result in zero for the FT Index, and if the FT had not briskly removed RR from the index, it would have gone to zero.

Able to buy only a few individual shares with a small capital sum in the 1970s, investors had to regard sudden share price falls as harbingers of doom – even if, in most cases, they weren’t. Their best policy was to sell to avoid the possibility of total capital loss.

Today, cheap index funds mean you can have a world-diversified equity portfolio with hundreds of individual shares within it for £1,000. Investors don’t have to think about volatility of share prices in individual companies. Instead, they look at market trends, which makes some sense, and economic forecasts, which makes no sense.

First, the forecasts are always wrong – it’s just a question of how wrong. Second, there is no relationship between economic performance as measured by GDP and equity market performance.

Watching market trends has turned most investors into trend followers or momentum investors, both of which are grandiose names for sheep. I encourage you to watch sheep. One takes a step or two this way, then another goes the other way, so the rest stop. Then one or two follow the first sheep, which speeds up when it knows it has followers. That encourages more to join in until most of the flock are running towards… what?

Small factors have big effects on the movement of sheep. They are sensitive to flock behaviour. They don’t want to be out on their own.

Investors today are over-sensitive to random short-term changes. The wide diversification of their equity investments means this volatility has no meaningful implications regarding future returns: the messenger carries no message. Yet investors buy and sell merely on the basis of this volatility.

In today’s farmworld, behaving sheepily has no adverse consequences. For investors, though, buying and selling in response to random volatility does have bad results: the data shows average self-directed investors’ returns are below the market average, because of their trend-following behaviour. And don’t think for a minute that professional investors and advisers are immune from sheepiness. Shoot your inner sheep.

Chris Gilchrist is director of Fiveways Financial Planning



Yvonne Goodwin: If you enjoy planning, why retire?

Over the last few weeks we’ve had a couple of approaches from potential clients saying “I want someone to look after my pensions” or “I need someone to do better with my Isas”. I don’t know about you but once I’m hit with a sentence like that, my response is: “I don’t think I’m the […]

Wells Street Journal: Pensions Regulator lobs a rotten Nest egg

Much has been made of the Government’s taxpayer funded campaign encouraging voters to back remaining in the EU. The Leave side predictably went ballastic when details emerged of the 14-page booklet sent to every household in the UK at a cost of £9m. Leading Brexiteers Boris Johnson and Nigel Farage also presumably received the handy […]

UK advisers in firing line as JP Morgan eyes staff cuts

JP Morgan is set to axe hundreds of workers across its wealth and asset management divisions after a review of its staffing. Bloomberg reports that the New York City-headquartered investment bank is “laying off wealth management workers” as part of what a spokesman terms a “normal course of business review”. In the UK, JP Morgan […]


FCA confirms ban on binary options sales to retail customers

The FCA has confirmed that binary options products can no longer be sold, marketed or distributed to retail customers. In a statement today, the FCA says that binary options – which often involve the investor either taking a fixed return if a strike price is reached or losing their original investment entirely – are “gambling […]

State of the markets: global growth

In conversation with journalist Alexis Xydias, Artemis Global Growth Fund manager Peter Saacke discusses the state of global markets and how he is positioning his fund. Peter gives his views on the growth potential of US, Europe and emerging markets, each of which is on a different stage of the road to recovery. And with a […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm