View more on these topics

Chris Gilchrist: Bad start for FCA over competition rules

Converting the FSA to the FCA should amount to more than changing a letter and shuffling who sits where. MPs agree and so does Lord Turner. But they do not agree on what the objectives of the FCA should be. And if they cannot be clear about that, there is little hope we will end up with better regulation. At the moment, we look likely to end up with a confused and conflicted regulator.

Lord Turner was right in his evidence to MPs to say that the draft objective of the FCA, protecting and enhancing confidence in the UK financial system, is wrong.

That should be one of the outcomes of good regulation, not its purpose. Adopting it as an aim will validate the use of propaganda and black arts by the regulator and could even justify the position that causing or precipitating a lack of confidence – something journalists are often accused of doing – should be subject to discipline and enforcement.

Anyway, why should the regulator promote confidence in a system containing lots of rotten stuff? Its job should be to get out there with the mop and disinfectant. A bit more of the lavatory cleaner, please, and less grandiosity.

Rightly, Lord Turner said the objectives should be about efficiency, fairness and consumer protection. Notably, he did not include competition in this list and he was right about that too.

The FSA apparatchiks who failed to prevent PPI misselling are now claiming it was the “regulatory gap” between competition law and FSA rules that prevented them from acting. This is self-serving piffle. It was obvious the FSA did not have a clue about the scale or nature of the misselling until it was far advanced and the OFT had stepped in. The OFT took too long to investigate but this is a fault of competition law, which urgently needs reform to speed up both investigations and
Of course, the guys at the FCA want to add competition in financial services to their responsibilities. A bigger job means more power, more people, bigger salaries. But this is a terrible idea.

Competition rules should be applied consistently across all sectors of the economy and competition law should ensure that this is possible. If competition law is written for the financial sector by the FCA – which is effectively what it would do by making the kind of rules the FSMA permits – then we would go further down the route of having one law for financial services and another law for everything else.

Worse still, because of the FSA/FCA’s immunity to oversight by the courts, it would remove the ultimate safeguard of freedoms and rights that constrains regulators in other fields – the right to take a case to the High Court. You may think that the way the banks took the OFT to court over bank charges was a cynical manoeuvre to protect their profits but the way to prevent delaying tactics of that kind is to reform competition law, not to give more ironmongery to a wimpish and weak-kneed regulator which has never yet banned or disciplined any senior executive at any big company responsible for any misselling scandal.

As I have said before, if someone has never shown the courage to use a revolver, why would you give them a bazooka?

Chris Gilchrist is the joint author of The Process of Financial Planning and editor of The IRS Report


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There are 5 comments at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. The PPI debacle was more to do with the lack of supervision, when I asked the FSA (face to face) how many FSA staff were deployed to watch the sales practices of the banks I was told they only had six supervising one of the BIG four and even then they were only doing the prudential bit so the answer must have been NONE.

    I’m sure readers can write a book on what they have seen the banks doing since 1987, completely unhindered. Was it because they ticked all the ‘systems and controls’ boxes on the annual return?

    Do we really need thousands of regulatory ‘geeks’ as they call themselves poring over computer models and spreadsheets compiled from the mountain of information firms supply on a regular basis? If the information isn’t requested or presented in a way that will provide a full picture of what firms are doing on a daily basis will we see bigger and bigger crises? More ‘scandals’, more ‘consumer detriment’?

    Only time will tell, but can society afford to waste time on these ‘collective intellectual failures’.

    On the subject of PPI, why oh why are the banks not compensating people on the basis that all their policies were missild if they cannot demonstrate they were suitable sales? The large IFA firms including networks have been told to do just that.

    One bank is employing contractors on the night shift, 7pm to 7am, at £350 per shift, just to deal with the customers who had the courage to complain about PPI. If they pay out the ambulance chasers take up to half the money!!

    What has regulation done for society?

  2. And we’re still awaiting an explanation as to just how the transition from FSA to FCA is going to cost the estimated £50m quoted by Hector Sants. The same people in the same office doing much the same jobs under nothing but a different logo. If this isn’t profligacy on the grandest and most deplorable of scales, then it’s hard to imagine a worse example.

    I’d like to think that, somehow or other, Mr Sants was unfortunately misquoted and that the figure he really stated was “just” £5m, which would still be stretching things somewhat, but 10 TIMES that!!?? Only at Canary Wharf.

  3. Somebody has got to change the labels on all of those packets of biscuits.

  4. Talking of biscuits, Victor. – let’s get the “ball rolling” with J***** “Cream Crackers !

    Any further offers ?

Leave a comment


Why register with Money Marketing ?

Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

Money Marketing Events
Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

Research and insight
Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

Have your say
Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

Register now

Having problems?

Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm