View more on these topics

Charlie Morris: ETFs leave alpha in their wake


Few doubt that passive investment is a simple and cost effective way to match index performance. ETFs have enabled investors to move money more quickly to far away places that capture the imagination. In a world now overwhelmed by passive money, a raft of opportunities to generate alpha have been created and there are rich pickings for managers that can spot opportunities.

Too much indexation in a given area, can lead to stocks being over or under represented in the indices. For example, the Nikkei Index future trade with approximately 13 times more volume than the Topix future. The Nikkei, like the Dow, is price weighted, whereas the Topix is arithmetically weighted, which is considered the norm.

As Peter Tasker from Arcus points out, Fast Retailing, owner of fashion retailer Uniqlo (if you haven’t heard of it, your teenage children probably have), has a 9.2 per cent weight in the Nikkei simply because it has high price, yet just 0.45 per cent in the Topix. The huge flows into Nikkei ETFs in recent months have driven this stock up 182 per cent between last October and May; 100 per cent more than the index. On the flip side, Toyota has a 1.8 per cent weight in the Nikkei yet 5 per cent in the Topix, inferring that it may be underrepresented.

This sort of distortion is particularly rife in emerging markets where the large stocks benefit from the flows leaving the mid and small caps unloved.

‘Smart beta’ has been designed to take advantage of reoccurring anomalies. Examples include re-balancing; aiming to capture return from excess market volatility and fundamental bias; to steer an index towards value and avoid bubbles. Both of these strategies make good sense over the long term because the former keeps you invested in profitable businesses and the latter buys low and sells high; Simple yet effective.

However, the fastest growing area has been low volatility or variance indices that focus on ‘lower risk’ stocks. US low volatility ETFs gathered $11.4bn of assets at their peak, from a standing start in 2011. The broad thesis is that they own the stocks with the lowest historic volatility. The back tests are stellar, and whilst they failed to keep up during the dotcom era, their performance has been impressive, particularly during the market dips. That is until Bernanke first uttered the word ‘tapering’.

Stocks that have low price volatility have low earnings’ volatility which can come about in two ways.

The right way is demonstrated by steady growth stocks such as Coca Cola or Unilever. To use the S&P staples as a proxy, the annualised earnings growth has been 6.4 per cent since 2008 with no material dip even during the financial crisis. The other way, is to have stable earnings with no growth, and here I would cite the S&P utilities sector, where earnings have been broadly flat.

Whilst the first group are high quality growth stocks, the second are effectively bonds. Low volatility strategies have been dominated by sectors such as utilities, REITs and telecoms whereas their actively managed competitors have focused on staples and healthcare.

The ebullient algorithm that drove billions of dollars into these ‘bond like’ sectors caused overvaluation and what was seemingly low risk, soon became high risk.

While the index business has never been so creative, inevitably the smartest active managers will take advantage of the alpha they leave behind in their slip stream. The most excessive flows will lead to the greatest opportunities.

Charlie Morris is manager of the HSBC Wealth Opportunities Fund



Tokyo Olympics win boosts Japanese markets

The Nikkei jumped 2.48 per cent as Tokyo was named host of the 2020 Olympic and Paralympic Games. The Nikkei 225 index closed at 14,205.23 following the news – an increase from the 13,860.81 posted on Friday. Tokyo has not hosted the games since 1964, and beat Istanbul and Madrid over the weekend in an […]


‘Britain is turning a corner’: Osborne says Plan A is winning

Chancellor George Osborne has argued the UK economy “is turning a corner” thanks to the Government’s commitment to austerity. Speaking before academics, think tanks and businesses in London today, Osborne highlighted the improvement in economic data over recent months and claimed this has “decisively ended” questions over his austerity-based economic policy. Osborne said: “The economic […]

Retirement fund - thumbnail

What price (more) freedoms?

George Osborne will make his last Budget speech of the current parliamentary term this week, and the early media briefings suggest that pensions will again feature heavily in that statement. So what are we able to learn from the weekend’s coverage?


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm