View more on these topics

Charging confusion after HMRC has costs rethink

Confusion over HM Revenue & Custom’s treatment of adviser and consultancy-charging has hit providers’ RDR preparations with just seven months to the December 31 deadline.

Last week, Money Marketing revealed details of HMRC’s redraft of its adviser-charging guidance. It now plans to allow implementation costs to be included in an adviser charge.

However, concerns remain about the effect that providing “wider pension advice” will have on a member’s tax-free cash and how the rules will be applied for consultancy-charging through group schemes.

HMRC expects to make changes to the draft guidance and is also considering producing separate guidelines for consultancy-charging but it is unclear when the final guidelines will be published.

Just Retirement external affairs and customer insight director Steve Lowe is responsible for the firm’s RDR programme. He says the continued uncertainty over HMRC’s treatment of adviser and consultancy-charging threatens to derail preparations.

He says: “This could be a major problem because most providers are already going to be close to the wire in getting systems ready for the RDR. If this issue is not sorted out quickly, then the industry could run into some serious timing problems.”

The problems over adviser-charging coincide with the FSA beginning a series of face-to-face interviews with the UK’s biggest providers, networks and IFA firms as it tries to gauge potential problems ahead.

LV= was recently the subject of an FSA RDR-readiness visit. Head of annuities Matt Trott says the lack of clarity on adviser-charging has stalled the company’s preparations.

He says: “We are hopeful for some sort of resolution on some of the issues around advisercharging. The big problem with all of this is the timing. We need to get clarification and we need to get this issue resolved as quickly as possible. “We as providers need to build this into our systems and we simply cannot do that until the guidelines are finalised. All providers are working against the clock to be ready in time for the RDR and if this drags on for much longer, there is a serious risk that providers will not be ready in time.”

Syndaxi Chartered Financial Planners managing director Robert Reid says: “It is hard to say you are ready for something when you do not know what it is going to look like.

“The situation on advisercharging is becoming ridiculous because advisers and providers are getting less and less time and HMRC keeps coming out with more and more detail.”

AJ Bell marketing director Billy Mackay says while the lack of clarity over adviser-charging is unhelpful, the biggest problem for platforms remains uncertainty over fund rebates.

He says: “How can a firm be clear about whether they are ready for the RDR when there are massive holes in the information that we are required to provide to say we are ready?

“All the platforms are facing the same issues in terms of how the FSA would like rebates and any platform fee that is received from the fund groups to be treated. The reality is we do not know at the moment.

“For us, it is not a massive issue because our business model does not rely on them but if you have got a business model which is built around the rebate structures, then you need an idea of what the FSA is going to do before you can be comfortable in saying whether you are RDR ready or not.”

The FSA declined to comment on the issue.



Dragon-launched Insynergy to close funds

Insynergy Investment Management – the boutique fund manager launched with backing from Dragons Den panelist James Caan – is proposing to close its funds as part of a “re-positioning” of the business. Investor approval will be sought to return monies held in the Insynergy absolute India, Insynergy absolute China and Insynergy New World equity income […]


Price gap widens for direct and intermediary two-year fixes

The price difference between the average direct and intermediary two-year fixed rate has shot up 69 basis points in the past year, according to data from The average intermediary two-year fixed rate is now 73 basis points more expensive than the average direct two-year fix, whereas a year ago the average intermediary product was […]

10 September thumbnail

Johnson Fleming set to hold auto-enrolment support webinar

Two years since the process of auto-enrolment began, the looming re-enrolment deadline provides the perfect opportunity to assess whether the support you have in place, which may well have been hastily selected at the start, is fit for purpose. Johnson Fleming is holding a webinar on 10 September at 11:00 to discover the key issues and concerns you should consider when thinking about your current support options.


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There are 3 comments at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. Disgraceful, absolutely disgraceful. The total mess the FSA has created with this ridiculous theoretical ideology is going to be catestrophic. They say we have had yers to get ready for yet T minus 7 months more and more confusion reigns down on a crippled industry. Well done Hector, really well done you definately are an “outstanding public servant”. I think Lord Turner had been at a liquid lunch before coming out with that one.

  2. Dear lord Marty, it’s like Groundhog day with you. Another day, another anti-RDR rant.

    Look – we get it. You don’t like RDR. You’re not alone, but it’s happening, get with it (or prepare to leave in December).

    And this latest thing – well, it’s an issue, yes, but mostly an immediate problem for Providers.

    Me? I’m just getting on preparing to be RDR ready in 6 months and I presume all the other FSA/provider/HMRC issues will have been resolved by then.

    In any event, I can only control what I can control – so that’s what I shall do. Whinging and moaning won’t help anyone now.

  3. To IFA

    Totally agree!!!

Leave a comment


Why register with Money Marketing ?

Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

Money Marketing Events
Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

Research and insight
Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

Have your say
Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

Register now

Having problems?

Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm