View more on these topics

Changes to state benefits highlight the need for protection

Most people in financial services read trade publications such as Money Marketing to keep on top of what is happening in the industry.

However, there are wider issues that we all keep a watching eye on but rarely have the hours in the day to delve into too deeply unless questioned.

For many, state benefits fall into that category but recent legislation and changes on the horizon mean that group risk intermediaries need to understand the developments, as there are opportunities to be explored.

Back in 1995, when incapacity benefit was introduced. If you were still unable to work after 28 weeks when statutory sick pay finished, you were entitled to short-term incapacity benefit. If you were still incapacitated after 52 weeks, you then became entitled to the higher rate of long-term incapacity benefit.

There were additional benefits for dependants and only these were means tested.

Medical tests to qualify for the benefits were not very objective and reassessments were rare, so once a person qualified for these benefits, things did not change much.

With the increased cost of meeting incapacity benefits, a more objective medical test, the personal capability assessment, or PCA, was introduced. This made it more difficult to qualify for benefits, unless an individual was genuinely incapacitated.

In 2008, the employment and support allowance was introduced.

In this two-tier system, those who have limited capability for work receive the Work Related Activity Component, a lower benefit than those with severe limitations, who receive the support component.

The work capability assessment was introduced from late 2009 to replace the PCA to determine an individual’s status and, with ongoing reassessments, existing incapacity benefit claimants will not remain on benefits if their state of health improves.

The initial outcome of the WCAs for new ESA claims (March to May 2011) shows that 38 per cent of claimants had their claim closed before even having a face to face assessment.

Where the WCA was completed, 57 per cent of claimants were assessed as fit for work and therefore not eligible for the ESA. Of those that were eligible for the ESA, 21 per cent received just the WRAC and only 22 per cent also qualified for the support component.

The next significant change to hit state benefits is the introduction of Work and Pensions Sectretary of State Ian Duncan Smith’s single benefit payment, the Universal Credit, designed to replace the fragmented systems currently in place.

In April 2013, a trial of the Universal Credit will begin which will see one payment brought in to replace all the following:

  • Income related ESA

  • Income related jobseeker’s allowance (JSA)

  • Income support

  • Working tax credits

  • Child tax credits

  • Housing benefit

The DWP’s current timetable will see all new claims able to be processed under the new system, with new applications under the old system faded out.

All new claims are due to be under the new Universal Credit from April 2014 and existing claimants will be gradually transferred to the new system by 2017.

The contributory versions of both the ESA and Jobseeker’s Allowance will be retained.

Although not means tested, there are time limits on their payment. Once the time limit is met the benefit stops, so claimants will have to apply for other benefits and will not necessarily qualify for them.

If we look back to what group income protection benefits looked like in 1995, it was fairly common to provide some level of ‘integration’ with state benefits. This was to make sure that:

  1. Employees were not better off if they were receiving both a GIP benefit and state benefits, retaining an incentive for the employee to return to work.

  2. The cover was as affordable as possible, as there was no point in duplicating benefits provided by the State.

The level of integration ranged from a fixed offset (equivalent to the long term incapacity benefit) through to the rather complex ‘net pay’ arrangements, where the benefit was expressed as a percentage of net pre-incapacity earnings.

When incapacity benefits became taxable, the advantages of net pay benefits largely disappeared as they lost their cost advantage.

The introduction by insurers of claims management and rehabilitation services, helping incapacitated employees to make a successful return to work, has also been an important development.

GIP benefits are often based on an own occupation definition of disability so, now that it is far more difficult for individuals to qualify for the ESA, fewer and fewer employees receiving GIP benefits are likely to qualify for state benefits too.

In addition, the amount an individual will receive in state benefits is likely to change more often, not only because some payments are time limited, but also because their state of health will be checked more frequently.

With these factors in mind, finding a suitable method for determining an appropriate deductor for state benefits on GIP schemes, especially for integrated benefits, becomes quite difficult.

With benefits changing over time, finding a fair method of calculating fully integrated GIP benefits looks rather messy. Surely this demonstrates that the link between GIP benefits and state benefits has broken once and for all, so that the only sensible solution is to provide GIP benefits that are a straight proportion of salary?

There is a clear opportunity here for advisers, not just to review the benefits clients are providing under GIP arrangements but also to encourage clients to set up new GIP arrangements.

If any employer is genuinely concerned for the welfare of its staff, the provision of a GIP scheme is hugely important as the support available from the state when a person is incapacitated is being significantly eroded.

Paul Avis is sales and marketing director at Canada Life Group Insurance



Industry raises concerns over RDR unintended consequences

Advisers and providers have warned that unintended consequences of the RDR could undermine the whole project. At a Perspective Financial Group RDR roundtable, Financial Connection managing director and chartered financial planner Jackie Lee-Lis said the inability to advise lower-income clients was the biggest concern with the RDR. Lee-Lis said: “There is a sector of our […]

Vaight takes on M&G funds as Godfrey departs

M&G Investments has announced fund manager Matthew Vaight will take sole responsibility for the M&G Global Emerging Markets and Asian funds after confirming the departure of Michael Godfrey. Vaight will continue to be supported by the M&G global equity team following the departure of Godfrey, who has left for another opportunity in the industry. M&G […]


Lighthouse hires recruitment team as adviser numbers fall

Lighthouse has hired seven recruitment managers to try and boost adviser numbers as its membership is expected to fall 23 per cent from 713 in January to 550 at the end of the year. The group’s interim accounts, published this week, show the firm made a £59,000 pre-tax profit for the six months ending 30 […]

‘Pragmatic’ Aifa rebrand risks blurring indy/restricted advice

Advisers say Aifa’s planned rebrand to the Association of Professional Financial Advisers is logical but fear the move will further blur the distinction between independent and restricted advice. Last week, the trade body announced plans to change its name following its decision to open up membership to restricted advisers in July 2011. The new name […]

Directors, limited liability partners and auto-enrolment

By Jim Grant, Senior Product Insight & Technical Support Analyst 6 April 2016 brought in changes to employer duties for directors and partners in limited liability partnerships. Here we explain exactly what’s changed. Before 6 April 2016… Directors of limited liability companies where there were no other directors or employees were exempt from the employer […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm