View more on these topics

Change of image

Historically, private client stockbrokers have provided specialist investment services to wealthy individuals while IFAs have made general financial planning services available to the mass market. Although stockbrokers have long been perceived as part of the professional elite alongside solicitors and accountants who charge fees for their services, IFAs have struggled to shake off their image as salespeople selling the provider products for the highest commission.

But times are changing. The broker’s image has been tarnished by the use of high-pressure telemarketing sales tactics by a few while the reputation of IFAs has improved, thanks to the improvement in standards and qualifications.

Increasing numbers of IFAs describe their target market as high-net-worth (or ultrahigh-net-worth) individuals – those that traditionally utilised stockbroker services. Brokers offer the opportunity to invest direct into equities on an execution-only, advisory or discretionary basis. IFAs provide financial planning advice, but – as with stockbrokers – the client is likely to ultimately invest in equities. Both sectors are managing their clients’ wealth and are referred to as wealth managers.

Stockbrokers are paying more attention to clients’ long-term financial needs and objectives – just as IFAs do. This focus is integral to the FSA’s TCF requirements, which apply to both sectors.

So, to whom should clients turn to construct an investment portfolio – IFA, stockbroker or both? Rightly or wrongly, most believe a stockbroker’s services represent a higher risk/higher reward option than those of his IFA cousin. The broker is likely to only handle a percentage of the client’s money, leaving the door open to other financial advisers. Brokers are faced with difficult choices – offer HNW clients a “complete” range of services by opening an IFA division, form alliances with IFAs or see clients utilise the services of IFAs with their own broker links.

Rather than develop a separate IFA division, some firms, notably American company Edward Jones, which has a UK subsidiary, have combined the functions of stockbroker and IFA with one individual performing both roles.

For HNW IFA firms, the fact that brokers are developing in-house teams signals increased competition for clients and high-calibre candidates. However, for advisers with the right qualifications and skills, this can present opportunities.

Advisers who can demonstrate experience of developing private client business, usually on a fee basis, and can support this with relevant advanced qualifications such as G10, G20, G60 and G70, often see their natural career path moving towards the management of client portfolios within the HNW arena. Stockbroker organisations with in-house financial planning divisions are increasingly able to offer this opportunity.

For clients, it means they can access a wider range of services under one roof but they will not receive any cross-subsidisation. Individuals using stockbrokers expect unbiased advice for which they pay a fee (or annual management charge). The same applies to those using the services of a stockbroker’s in-house IFA. Clients should view the services as separate and expect to pay for each.

Just as brokers and IFAs worked more closely together a decade ago, so it is apparent that there is, again, increasing synergy between the two. They recognise the need to develop their own strategies and decide how best to work together to develop private client business and funds under management.

Robert Campbell is a consultant at Envision Financial Services Recruitment.


Mortgage firms braced for future base rate rise

The mortgage market has got a breathing space after the Bank of England monetary policy committee voted to hold base rates at 5.25 per cent last week.Many commentators say the decision is only putting off an inevitable rise as inflationary pressures are still in place.The market had been hoping to avoid another rise in February […]

UBS offering multi-asset fund

UBS is launching a multi-asset fund, to be managed by its global investment solutions team. Headed by Jamie Lewin, the fund will be predominantly equities and fixed-income, with both property and private equity excluded at launch.

Shepherds Friendly in sales talks with IFA support firms

Shepherds Friendly Society is in advanced discussions with Sesame and SimplyBiz about making its products available to both companies’ advisers.The Manchester-based mutual first approached the IFA market in November 2006 after declining sales forced it to rethink its strategy and it has so far signed up distribution deals with 30 local IFAs.Chief executive Geoff Spencer, […]

Deal sees society link up with L&G

Nationwide Building Society and Legal & General have entered into a distribution deal that will mean Nationwide selling L&G’s life, investment and pension products.As part of the deal, L&G is buying Nationwide subsidiaries Nationwide Life and Nationwide Unit Trust Managers.The current value of the two subsidiaries is 285m after the extraction of 70m of capital […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm