View more on these topics

Casting off the stigma

The provisions of the Enter-prise Act 2002 and the amended insolvency rules dealing with personal insolvency came into effect on April 1.

First, there has been a reduction in the bankruptcy period. Pre-April 1, once declared bankrupt, the period of bankruptcy generally lasted for three years. During this time, there are various restrictions on what a bankrupt can and cannot do. The Enterprise Act has reduced the period of bankruptcy so that in most cases, the bankrupt will be automatically discharged after 12 months.

In many cases, the discharge may come even earlier because the Official Receiver can file a notice with the court indicating that the investigation of the bankrupt&#39s affairs is unnecessary or concluded, consequently bringing an end to the bankruptcy.

The aim is to encourage enterprise and to lose the stigma which currently attaches to being a bankrupt.

For those made bankrupt before April 1, their bankruptcy will come to an end either on the date that they would, in the ordinary course under the old rules, have been discharged or, if earlier, April 1, 2005.

Additionally, there is now no automatic rules on a second bankruptcy. The old rule that a person who is made bankrupt for a second time within a 15-year period will only be discharged upon application to the court has gone.

Anyone subject to the old rules will be discharged upon application to the court (which may be made at any time after five years for the date of the most recent bankruptcy order) or automatically on April 1, 2009.

The period of bankruptcy can be extended by an application by the Official Receiver or trustee. The bankruptcy can be extended for a period between two years and 15 years.

The Act provides a number of grounds upon which a BRO will be granted. These grounds are generally due to failure to co-operate during the bankruptcy or some misconduct leading up to the bankruptcy, for example, giving a preference or entering into a transaction at an undervalue.

While the rules on second bankruptcy have gone, a second bankruptcy within a period of six years from the previous discharge will now be a good ground for a BRO.

Additionally, it should be remembered that property interest can revert back to the bankrupt. Bankrupts are commonly under the impression that on being discharged, their property belongs to them again. This is not the case. Unless the trustee transfers any interest in that property back to the discharged bankrupt, the interest remains with the trustee.

This has caused much consternation due to the recent increase in house values. Discharged bankrupts who thought themselves homeowners find that this is not the case when they try to sell or remortgage the property or when their trustee shows renewed interest in the property.

But the Enterprise Act will bring an end to this. Unless the trustee in bankruptcy takes steps to realise their interest within three years from the date of the bankruptcy (or by April 1, 2007 for pre-April 2004 bankruptcies), the interest will revert back to the bankrupt.

This may result in trustees in bankruptcy becoming more proactive in realising their share of the asset.

If they are unable to reach an agreement with the bankrupt for the sale back of the interest in the property, the trustee may seek an order for the sale of the property or get a charging order over the property so that the bankrupt will acquire ownership of his interest the property but subject to the charge.

The alternative that many debtors have turned to in the past in an attempt to avoid bankruptcy has been to put a proposal for an IVA to his or her creditors.

The rules introduced by the Enterprise Act do not greatly impact upon the provisions governing the working of an IVA although a new form of fast-track IVA administered by the Insolvency Service has been introduced.

The fast-track IVA will be available to individuals post-bankruptcy and the IVA will be overseen by the Insolvency Service.

The fact that the bankruptcy period has been greatly shortened may well mean that people are less likely to follow the IVA route and that we see more bankruptcies. During the three-month period before the new rules came into effect, the courts saw an increase in the level of bankruptcies.

Will these changes continue the upward trend? Why enter into a three-year arrangement when a bankruptcy could be over in 12 months or less?

Anecdotal evidence would suggest that many individuals have always been prepared to enter into an IVA when bankruptcy would logically be more appropriate. It appears that the stigma of bankruptcy has, in the past, displaced logic. It is entirely possible that this will continue in the future no matters how much the government considers that the new rules will do away with the stigma of bankruptcy.

The new rules embodied in the Act and the amendments to the insolvency rules are based upon the American system. As stated above, the purpose is to encourage business activity by ensuring that failed enterprise does not bring with it a lengthy period of stigmatised bankruptcy.

Entrepreneurs are to be encouraged to take risks without the very significant penalties of the old system if things go wrong. There is concern, however, that the system could be abused to accumulate and then wipe out unsecured debt.

This would, to a degree, depend upon how often the Official Receiver and other trustees will be prepared to resort to BROs and the courts&#39 practice in granting them.


Close Fund Management – The Close Man Hedge Fund

Type: Capital-protected fund of hedge funds Aim: Growth linked to the performance of a portfolio of hedge funds Minimum-maximum investment: Lump sum £10,000 Investment split: 100% in hedge funds Term: Eight years and six months Return: 13%-15% growth a year Guarantee: Original capital returned in full regardless of performance of under- lying investments Place of […]

&#39Liabilities of ex-IFA networks&#39

Mortgage firms looking for a principal firm should steer clear of IFA organisations, mortgage and general insurance network Network Data has warned. Speaking at the Money Marketing Live event, Network Data managing director Richard Griffiths issued a stark warning to firms still deliberating over which mortgage network to join. He thinks firms should be cautious […]

Stop EU inflicting more damage

IFAs must be looking skywards and asking whatever god they worship when the PI nightmare is going to end. The screw is to be turned tighter still by the EU. From 2006, IFAs doing both insurance and investment business will have to have £1m PI coverage to comply with the insurance mediation directive and a […]

Bankhall and e.surv announce partnership

UK market leading firm e.surv Chartered Surveyors and intermediary services provider Bankhall have announced a new partnership to provide valuation services. The arrangement follows Bankhall&#39s acquisition of the Norwich Union Mortgage Club and is the latest in a series of strategic announcements from Bankhall regarding the mortgage market. Managing director of e.surv Paul Latham says: […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm