View more on these topics

Carl Lamb: Why I’m taking on the internet trolls


One of the most important assets for any firm of financial advisers is its reputation.

It is something we build up over time and personally I am very proud of the standing we have in the industry. 

However, it is an asset that is open to attack from malicious individuals who have found that the internet is the perfect place to launch sneaky and nasty campaigns against both firms and individuals.

There has been a lot of talk in the financial industry press about whether or not internet forums and comment streams should allow people to post anonymously.

I feel that if someone has an opinion to view, they should be made to identify themselves, to stand up and be counted. However, it does require a certain degree of courage to set yourself up to be pilloried by the scourge of the internet – the trolls.

Internet trolls are not a new concept. They spread bad feeling around the globe by the use of defamatory, insulting or just plain rude messages on websites all across the web.

They hide behind cryptic user names and feed off the controversy they create. We have all seen their comments and, frankly, the suspicion is that they are sad individuals hiding in darkened rooms, with no real knowledge of our industry.

In most cases, I would not dream of dignifying their posts with any kind of response – to be ignored is more painful to these nasty troublemakers.

However, we sometimes see evidence of a different type of malicious attack that has a double impact – trolls who impersonate real people in the industry and post malicious comments online. The result is damage to the real person’s reputation as well as to the object of the comment.

In such instances, I firmly believe that the perpetrators should be brought to book.

Within Almary Green, we have been the victims of this type of attack on one of the industry news sites. Pensions in divorce specialist Fiona Sharp was appalled to find that comments had been posted in her name putting views that were certainly not hers and using language that was offensive. The imposter had not hacked her account but had simply set up a new user account using “Fiona Sharp” as the user name. When she dug deeper, Fiona found that the other “Fiona Sharp” had been posting derogatory comments for about three months.

There is only one Fiona Sharp in our industry and we have to assume that she – and Almary Green – was being specifically targeted. What is more, another member of our team – one of our administrators – has been targeted in the same way.

While the site has removed the comments and blocked the rogue accounts, it will not divulge the identity of the imposters. It has this information in the imposter’s registration data but says that data protection rules do not permit them to pass the information on to us.

However, this is one time when I am determined to fight back. We are not afraid to take legal action to unmask these people – and will bring the case to the attention of the police if we feel a criminal act has taken place. There is a process using a special court order – a Norwich Pharmacal Order – that will oblige the site to pass on the information we need and we may well go down that route.

So, watch out if you are looking to damage reputations in our industry as we will be looking to name you and shame you.

Carl Lamb is managing director of Almary Green


Kevin Ronaldson Bellpenny 700

Bellpenny acquires two more IFA firms

Bellpenny has acquired IFAs Actuarial and Investment Services and The Hammond Consultancy for undisclosed sums, taking the consolidator’s total assets under advice to £1.45bn. London-based Actuarial and Investment Services brings 500 clients and £75m in assets under advice, while The Hammond Consultancy in Birmingham brings 1000 clients and £112m in assets under advice. It brings the total number […]


Apfa: FCA should compensate advisers after £118m fee overcharging

Apfa is calling on the FCA to pay compensation to advisers who have been overcharged on their fees. In November Money Marketing revealed the FCA fee block containing most advisers, A13, has been overcharged by £118m over the past five years. In a consultation paper on regulatory fees and levies for 2014/15, published in October, the […]


Riding the wave of optimism

Following a remarkably positive year for the mortgage market in 2013, the industry has stepped into the New Year in a confident mood. Lenders and brokers were pleased to see a change in fortunes last year after five years of grappling with a struggling market in the wake of the financial crisis. So, riding the […]


Rathbones’ Coombs shifts UK exposure down market cap scale

Rathbones Unit Trust Management multi-asset manager David Coombs has rebalanced exposure to UK equities after selling a number of existing positions and adding the Axa Framlington Mid Cap fund to the £7.9m Rathbone Multi Asset Enhanced Growth Portfolio. The fund has recently sold out of the Herald Investment Trust after a period of strong performance […]

Reforming India: just the beginning

By Kunal Desai, Neptune India Fund

As global investors continue to scour emerging markets through the lens of reform potential, India shines bright. Indeed, we think it can sparkle even brighter. We anticipate India’s self-imposed 10-year ‘policy holiday’ to turn into one of the most pro-growth and pro-investment policy calendars seen in Asia in years. The Indian electorate has engineered a historic verdict. We now have the strongest Indian government since 1984, with the pro-market Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) achieving an absolute majority for the first time in the party’s history.


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There are 7 comments at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. Well said, Carl. It’s such a shame that the publisher in question (who we continue to have no further dealings with until they resolve these issues) cannot accept the damage they have caused to your reputation by refusing to unmask the malicious troll behind this attack.

  2. Totally agree and I very much hope the culprit is starting to look uncomfortably over their shoulder and that the long arm of the law will soon be firmly around the miscreant’s neck.

    As far as I know data protection rules allow disclosure as part of a published policy. IFAs’ general data protection policy is that they may pass details to third parties for regulatory review or to facilitate intermediation. There seems nothing to stop said publication having a policy that states they will release personal details in the event of fraud or misrepresentation.

  3. How common a practice is this? Aside from the above example, does anyone know of similar instances?

    I would suggest what has happened here borders on identiy theft and should be addressed accordingly (in terms of legal powers).

  4. @ Matthew

    On certain sites in the financial sector its is quite a frequent event. One example we have is of it happening ten times in one thread. The publisher (different to the one in Carl’s example) refused to disclose the culprit as well

    Remember “there is no room for the truth on the internet” (Big Bang Theory)

  5. I have had repeated arguments with a certain “Cromwellian” adviser website who allows anon postings and fails to police them as well as MM seem to.
    I accept that for whistleblowing it is important to be able to post anon AND for some employees where their firm and their personal opinion need clear separation but by being given this privilege, the poster needs to respect the use of this anonymity and not antagonise those willing to be open and frank.
    Some suspect that the Cromwellian website’s Trolls are actually employees and that is why they will not divulge their names. I would be interested in knowing more about the Norwich Pharma order please Carl as I look forward to using it to find out who some of the Troll cowards actually are as I know they wouldn’t say what they do to my face.

  6. Well said! Now I’m going to do the same! There are way to many of these people out there trolling, impersonating, hating and bullying. It’s gone on long enough. If enough good people who care about others join together to rid Fb & Twitter and places all over the web of the nastiness and disrespect I believe it can be done. I happened to come across this post while researching ways to get rid of trolls and impersonators. Thank you for inspiring me further ??

  7. Since this has been bumped, did Carl ever get the trolls in the dock?

Leave a comment


Why register with Money Marketing ?

Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

Money Marketing Events
Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

Research and insight
Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

Have your say
Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

Register now

Having problems?

Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm