View more on these topics

CA wants Govt probe of Axa orphan assets case

The Consumers&#39 Association is calling on Chancellor Gor don Brown to take the FSA to task over its handling of the Axa orphan assets case.

Axa won its High Court battle against policyholders who had demanded a higher proportion of its inherited estate. The CA is waiting for an explanation of the ruling before deciding whether to lodge an appeal.

It is asking the Gov ern ment to set up a formal inq uiry into with-profits funds and says other life offices will be “lining up to do an Axa”.

Prudential policyholders have already started a legal challenge.

But analysts warn that life offices do not have huge res erves of cash and policyholders should take heed from Equitable Life which closed because it did not have sufficient reserves.

Ned Cazalet of Cazalet Financial Consulting says: “If Axa had been forced to give away 90 per cent of its orphan assets it would have been in a worse situation than Equitable. “This £20bn of inherited estate in the life industry is a myth.”

CA spokeswoman says Jenny Driscoll says: “It is a symptom of the process which is not working for policyholders. Axa sat with the FSA for two years working out this deal and no one was there to represent consumers.”

Informed Choice managing director Nick Bamford says: “I was not surprised by the decision. These companies are bearing huge costs because of lower charges and this kind of money is necessary. The wider issue coming out of this is what is a with-profits fund and who owns it?” Axa media relations manager Phil Hickley says: “We have maintained that the only surplus in the fund was £250m, as identified by the independent actuary, and it is being distributed 90/10 following industry convention. To distribute more than £250m would have made the fund unnecessarily fragile.”

Recommended

Mutiny on the bounty

Where a person going into local authority care currently owns assets of more than £16,000, the local authority can make a claim on those assets to pay towards the care costs. For this reason, people sometimes consider making gifts of assets prior to going into care. This would bring the question of deliberate deprivation into […]

Last year &#39lacklustre&#39 for UK pension funds

UK pension funds posted a lacklustre negative return of -1.8 per cent in 2000, according to estimates from performance measurement consultancy The WM Company. Although the return is disappointing, there have been larger negative of -11 per cent and -4 per cent in 1991 and 1994 respectively. WM executive director Peter Warrington says: “Over 10 […]

Equitable puts question mark over stakeholder

The insurance industry fears that the Equitable Life debacle will bring public confidence plunging to depths not seen since the height of the pension misselling scandal. The fact that the UK&#39s fourth-biggest insurer and the oldest mutual insurer should close to new business is serious enough in its own right. Now potential investors are going […]

Legal & General lump together carry forward clients

With less than four months to go until the introduction of stakeholder pensions, Legal & General has introduced the single charge pre-stakeholder individual personal pension plan. Legal & General has introduced the pension in order to take advantage of the carry forward rules before they are abolished on April 5, 2001. Carry forward allows people […]

Certification guide

Guide: how to… certify your pension scheme

Certification is highly complex and surrounded by a minefield of information and auto-enrolment jargon, which can make it very difficult to understand. However, for many employers it is a necessary process that must be executed successfully.

Newsletter

News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up

Comments

    Leave a comment