View more on these topics

Broker contests Paymentshield slashing ‘dormant’ trail commission

A broker is taking legal action against Paymentshield, alleging that its decision to cut his trail commission from 27 per cent to 5 per cent is a breach of contract.

In October, Paymentshield told a number of brokers that their commission would fall to 5 per cent from November as they had not submitted any business in the past 12 months.

The insurance provider said at the time that such firms had become dormant and were therefore subject to a dormancy clause in its terms and conditions.

But D&D Consultants director David Nicholson alleges the contract is unfair and would have no standing in court because it fails to define the term dormant agency or to publish dormant agency rates. He says: “This clause has no defined terms and is therefore open to interpretation and as such constitutes an unfair contract. I am informed by my solicitor that it would not stand up in court.”

Nicholson has been in correspondence with Paymentshield for some weeks and after his latest letter threatening legal action went unanswered for more than seven days he instructed his solicitor to begin legal proceedings last week.

A Paymentshield spokeswoman says: “Since Mr Nicholson has decided to seek legal advice, we are unfortunately unable to comment on his specific situation.”

Paymentshield has told brokers that they can reinstate their commission to its original rate if they submit one policy per month for six months to the firm, as that would mean they would no longer be classed as dormant.

Recommended

‘Warning notices will treat firms like would-be criminals’

The Financial Conduct Authority’s powers to publicise early warning notices will treat firms and individuals like “would-be criminals”, says City of London Conservative MP Mark Field. The Financial Services Bill will give the FCA the power to publicise the details of firms and individuals it is investigating at the warning notice stage. The bill also […]

FE Adviser Fund Index

Over the past three years, the FE Adviser Fund Index benchmark portfolios have weathered challenging market conditions. One striking feature has been the shift away from absolute return vehicles that look to offer steady positive returns, irrespective of market conditions. In the gloom of late 2008, many of these products were seized upon by investors […]

2

In financial services we trust

The progressive are now looking beyond the retail distribution review and towards shaping the future of financial planning. There is evidence of progress as more buy into the need for higher standards, an improved client experience and a desire to engage more widely with consumers. Shane Mullins is managing director of accredited financial planning firm […]

Research highlights ‘unacceptable’ cautious fund underperformance

The number of underperforming funds on Chelsea Financial Service’s RedZone list has fallen dramatically at the start of the new year. However, the research also shows some of the industry’s most consistent underperformers hail from the former IMA cautious managed sector – which was the most popular sector with investors last year. The total number […]

Newsletter

News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up

Comments

    Leave a comment