View more on these topics

Brian Tora: Which way for emerging markets and commodities?


One of the problems of being in the investment game is what I can only describe as information overload.

When I was an investment manager, working for one of the big independent houses, I felt buried under all the brokers’ circulars and economic reports that rained down on people like me with the intention, I imagine, of persuading me to buy or sell some shares and keep the salesman who’s task it was to telephone on a daily basis fed with commission.

When, some 30 years ago, I returned to my stockbroking roots and joined the great house of James Capel, I fully expected to find my in tray devoid of sales literature. How naive can you be? There was just as much material, even if it did come from a different source. And once Big Bang took place and the barriers between disciplines were dismantled, I felt I was back to life as an investment manager, which I suppose I was.

Today it is my computer screen that fills with research and opinion, reports and exhortations to act. The principal task of anyone engaged in the investment business these days must be to sift through the cornucopia of material despatched electronically and endeavour to cut it down to a concise, manageable and hopefully valuable selection which will add value to the process of deciding what action will achieve the desired results.

Where this becomes difficult and, I have to confess, more interesting, is when conflicting views arrive at pretty much the same time. My view has been that it takes two to make a market and disagreements over potential outcomes are an encouraging sign. Indeed, it is when all those commenting on a possible turn of events agree on what is likely to happen that an investor should start to be concerned.

So it has been with both commodities and emerging markets recently. There are bulls and bears in what seems like equal measure for both these sectors recently.

In the case of emerging markets, the bulls point to the undemanding valuation levels that have now been established. The bears underline the risks inherent from rising debt levels, the ending of cheap money, uncertainty over the strength of the global economy and potential political instability in a number of areas.

It is the economic argument that weighs most heavily in the debate over the likely direction of resource stocks. Earlier strength in demand for natural resources, brought about in no small measure by the rapid growth in China and other emerging nations, triggered the biggest surge in investment in mining industries ever. The economic slowdown reduced demand and led to a period of disappointing returns for investors. The crucial question is whether this is a setback in a bull market or the start of a major reversal of fortunes.

Much has been written of the so-called super cycle in commodities. According to Craton Capital, an investment manager which specialises in mining shares, there have been three super cycles in the past 120 years. They believe the recent boom in commodity prices, which has admittedly peaked, has all the characteristics of a super cycle which may have further to run.

The problem, though, is what is likely to happen in the short term. The investment cycle came to an end in 2012. The costs associated with bringing on extra capacity, which inevitably depressed mining profits, peaked a year ago. While this reduction in the cost burden should be beneficial, new capacity is coming on stream against a background of sluggish demand, so a supply glut is expected.

This will not continue indefinitely, of course, but the extent to which the market will look through this short term difficulty could be crucial for the performance of the FTSE 100 Index, given the importance of resource stocks in its makeup. I am looking for new high ground this year, so I hope Craton’s bullish take turns out to be right. There are plenty of an opposite persuasion, though.

Brian Tora is an associate with investment managers JM Finn & Co



PSigma’s Becket: Complacent investors could be “severely punished”

PSigma has warned an “extreme level” of optimism among investors could see many burned by undershooting corporates or faltering economies. Chief investment officer Thomas Becket says while this year is likely to deliver greater growth than in past years in terms of global output, valuations have soared in the last two years to “uncomfortable” levels. […]


Webb declares no ‘screeching’ charge cap U-turn but admits timing challenge

Pensions minister Steve Webb says there will be no “screeching U-turns” over the Government’s pension charge cap plans but admits its original timetable may have been unrealistic. It emerged last week the Government was likely to delay the introduction of its charge cap, originally due this April, by at least a year.  Speaking at a Headlinemoney dinner […]

Ex-HBOS mortgage chief appointed Govt housing adviser

The Government has appointed former HBOS head of intermediary business Grenville Turner as an adviser on housing policy. Communities secretary Eric Pickles hired Turner, who left HBOS in February 2006 after 30 years with the bank and is currently Countrywide Group chief executive, as non-executive director to the Department for Communities and Local Government on […]


Alistair Cunningham: Network woes present huge opportunity

Networks and nationals are struggling, with no apparent end to the suffering. Record fines, management team departures, falling adviser numbers and a furious backlash against the inevitable conversion to a restricted advice model summarises a horrendous 2013. In the historic environment of the “solutions led” adviser, networks once offered valuable services, particularly their ability to […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm