View more on these topics

BoE under fire over ‘fatally flawed’ stress tests


The Bank of England’s stress tests for large financial institutions are “highly unreliable” and “fatally flawed”, a report from an influential think-tank argues.

The Bank uses stress tests to analyse the resilience of the UK banking system in the event of a deterioration in global economic conditions.

However, a report from the Adam Smith Institute argues the “pass” rate for the BoE’s solvency test – a 4.5 per cent minimum ratio of capital to risk-weighted assets – is “very low” and significantly weaker than incoming European Basel III requirements.

It says if the Bank had used the standards set out in Basel III, at best just two of the eight banks and building societies tested would have passed.

In the stress test results published in December, the Bank said only three institutions – Co-operative Bank, Lloyds Banking Group and Royal Bank of Scotland – needed to strengthen their capital position further. In addition, the Co-op was required to submit a revised capital plan.

Professor Kevin Dowd, who authored the report, says: “The Bank’s party line is that the UK banking system is safe. However, it is simply impossible to assess the health of the banking system using a stress test based on a single scenario, which is all that the Bank considers. How do we know that the banking system will be safe under all the other scenarios that the Bank of England didn’t consider? Well, we don’t.

“On the other hand, had the Bank carried out a meaningful stress test, then all sorts of awkward questions would have arisen – such as why the banking system is still in a mess despite the vast amounts of public money that have been thrown at it since the onset of the financial crisis. But no-one – especially not the Bank – wants to face up to the point that Bank’s policy towards the banking system has been a very costly failure and continues to leave the banking system vulnerable.”


Pete Matthew

Pete Matthew: The power of routine

I am hesitant to start off this column with a humble brag but I am going to anyway. Lots of people recently, and particularly those in the financial services world, have told me they do not know how I get so much done. I suppose I understand it. I manage a 13-person practice, as well […]


Intrinsic culls four providers from protection panel

Old Mutual-owned advice network Intrinsic has culled four providers from its protection panel following an independent third party review. The providers who have been removed are Zurich, LV=, Cirencester Friendly and Shepherds Friendly, while Legal & General has been added to the panel. Aegon, Bright Grey, Exeter Family Friendly, Friends Life, Old Mutual Wealth and […]

Aberdeen Gilbert Martin Gilbert 700x450

Aberdeen sells £100m stake for new fund launches

Aberdeen Asset Management is issuing £100m in shares to Japanese bank Mitsubishi UFJ Trust and Banking Corporation in a bid to power new fund launches. The asset manager will issue 200 million shares with a total paid-up amount of 50 pence per share. These will convert to ordinary shares only if Aberdeen’s Common Equity Tier 1 […]


Tony Wickenden: Will Altmann be the pensions industry’s ally?

Along with a Conservative Government we also have a new pensions minister in the shape of Dr Ros Altmann to start getting used to. Altmann’s predecessor Steve Webb made the role his own throughout the last parliament and can take not inconsiderable credit for having overseen one of the most incredible shake-ups to retirement provision […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There is one comment at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. Wow, cover ups by BofE and lack of capital adequacy in most high street banks. Finally, an article which feels intuitively correct!

Leave a comment