View more on these topics

Blog: Where are all the contrarian investment calls?

Bright purple pink party balloon emerging from a crowd of dark, gray anonymous balloons. Being special, standing out from the crowd, focusing on own individuality. Front view, looking up. Copy space on dark side of image, gray background.Fund managers like to trade off having a unique style. There thousands of funds out there to choose from – the question I often hear from advisers is: what makes this person different?

Sometimes this can be a really tough one to answer. “We invest for the long term” is all fine and good, but so does the competition. “Our research is highly rigorous” is another one I hear often, but to the uninitiated this can sound like the bare minimum a manager should be doing when investors trust them with their money.

There should be obvious differences in allocations between, say, a value fund and a growth fund. But, as Schroders equity value manager Nick Kirrage argued at the firm’s investment conference in Edinburgh this week, the vast majority of growth managers have ended up investing in the same limited basket of stocks, and very few value managers genuinely target value stocks in the purest sense.

According to Kirrage, 90 per cent of all equity managers have a bias towards growth stocks.

“Everyone seems happy to put all their eggs in one basket: growth,” he says.

What about diversifiers? Ways to get genuinely non-correlated assets packed into a portfolio? As multi-asset manager Philip Chandler argued, we have settled into group-think here as well.

When you drill down into a lot of the calls, all the trades end up being made off the same fundamentals. Being long American equities and short Chinese are two sides of exactly the same coin when it comes to predicting the outcome of trade negotiations.

Say you are short US 10-year Treasuries, with a pessimistic outlook for the bond market based on inflation rising and interest rates needing to go up. Being long US banks compared with large cap equities, which one might reasonably hold as an equity position at the same time, is highly correlated, according to Schroders data.

Take ethical, sustainable and governance filters. I’ve seen plenty of these that don’t exclude companies such as Sports Direct and BP, making them little different from regular growth propositions. I appreciate many firms will apply some sort of ESG filter across all propositions, but if you’re going to take ESG seriously, at least narrow the field significantly when it comes to actual asset allocation.

Oddly, I still don’t see too many managers trying to differentiate their calls or proposition based on the cost it takes to execute them. Maybe this is the next frontier for a sector almost certainly set to consolidate.

Justin Cash is editor of Money Marketing. Follow him on Twitter @Justin_Cash_1



When will ESG take off with advisers?

The buzz around sustainable and ethical investing has been growing in recent years as more people become environmentally and socially aware. In response, asset managers such as Schroders, Investec and Aegon have all jumped on the bandwagon and are pushing a vast array of funds with an ethical dimension as the appetite for responsible investment […]

How to… navigate the bond market

Advisers are facing tough choices when it comes to picking bond funds for their clients’ portfolios. Three top investors talk to Money Marketing to shed light on the recent market sell-off and how bonds have reacted to it. They also explain which features bonds need to have to survive a new environment of rising interest […]


Bill McQuaker: Equities aren’t dangerous; the world is

Trump’s announcements of tariffs on steel and aluminium have led to a much greater focus on the risks posed by his presidency We have had a rollercoaster start to 2018. January saw a rapid rise in global equities before markets succumbed to a technically driven sell-off, recovered a little, and sold off again on the […]

Danby Bloch: Batten down the hatches for IHT review

Office of Tax Simplification report could trigger the biggest upset in estate planning for years If you think the biggest threat to inheritance tax planning is posed by Jeremy Corbyn and a possible Labour government, think again. The Conservatives are taking a long hard look at IHT and their aim is simplification. The Office of […]

Show me the money – earnings are central to performance in Europe

Equity markets globally currently remain vulnerable to sharp shifts in sentiment caused by either unexpected or unwelcome outcomes in key upcoming political events (the US and German elections, Brexit and the Italian referendum). These top-down influences, combined with the current low global growth environment, will likely lead to broadly directionless markets, and prolong the current low beta return environment. We do, though, […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There are 2 comments at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. Contrarian is possibly defined as going where no one else goes. In which case Pictet picks up some Laurels. Who else has a Security Fund,or Timber,or Water?

    In general fund managers are too timid. They consider themselves contrarian when buying a FTSE stock that might be currently out of favour. No one in the UK has the guts to launch (for example) a Vice fund (which exists in the US and has consistently outperformed the S&P 500).

    Too many managers just launch ‘me too’ funds and imagination and thinking outside the box just doesn’t figure. Probably because the adviser community also doesn’t have the courage to be adventurous. I do recall Schroder launching a very innovative fund (I can’t recall the name) but they had to close it for lack of support. I bought into it from launch and made good money as it did really well. But that is a long time ago.

  2. Julian Stevens 18th May 2018 at 7:11 pm


Leave a comment