View more on these topics

Blind faith: Treasury under pressure to come clean on Pension Wise


The Treasury is facing mounting pressure from senior politicians, insurers and advisers over its refusal to publish data on the industry-funded guidance service Pension Wise.

The Government’s guidance offering came into being shortly ahead of pension freedom on 6 April.

But requests for basic information from Money Marketing on how the service is performing have repeatedly been blocked by officials.

In February, the Treasury said it would not publish information on forecast numbers for the service, claiming that any benefits of disclosure would be outweighed by “the risk that public exposure when preparing and finalising policy advice would make civil servants less likely to provide full and frank advice or opinions on policy proposals”.

The Treasury again spurned a Freedom of Information request from Money Marketing in early July, saying it was not required to publish information on customer satisfaction with Pension Wise because it can determine its own publication deadlines.

And this week, the FCA rejected a further FoI which asked how many firms it was investigating for impersonating the Pension Wise service, or purporting to offer free pension reviews in the aftermath of the reforms.


The repeated refusal of the Government and the regulator to come clean over Pension Wise has now drawn the ire of influential politicans.

Labour shadow pensions minister Lord Bradley says the issue of transparency needs to be addressed so the guidance service is properly held to account.

Following his own request for information, Bradley was told by the Government that, as of 6 April, Pension Wise had handled more than 3,600 calls on the new freedoms.

Additionally, around 1,400 people had booked a telephone guidance appointment with The Pensions Advisory Service, and nearly 380 people had booked a face-to-face appointment with Citizens Advice.

Bradley criticised the response as “limited”.

He says: “So far the information on Pension Wise is extremely limited and we need to pursue that to make sure that consumers are getting the services that they need.

“The Government assured us that it would be completely transparent with these matters and it has to follow up that commitment, and we will rigorously pursue this on behalf of consumers.”

The Scottish National Party is also planning to ramp up pressure on the Treasury.

SNP pension spokesman Ian Blackford says: “This is very high on my radar. We are all for consumer choice but we need to make sure there is consumer protection and an appropriate level of guidance for all.”

The MPs’ intervention follows criticism from the Association of British Insurers. Speaking at the launch of the All-Party Parliamentary Group on pensions last week, director of long term savings policy Yvonne Braun said: “Why, nearly 100 days into the implementation of the policy, do we have provisional early data on everything except the performance and take-up of Pension Wise?

“The industry wants the service to succeed given that we fund it, and the more people use it, the better equipped they will be to make use of the freedoms.”

Adviser anger

The advice sector, which will have to stump up £4.2m of the £35m costs for running Pension Wise in 2015/16, has also expressed anger at the Government’s failure to publish information on the service.

Apfa director general Chris Hannant says: “People are only going to be able to help improve the service with some data about what’s going on, but how do we find out if we’re flogging a dead horse if we can’t see what is working and what is not working?

“We are already paying too much for it, and if you can tell already that there’s not too much interest in it from the general public then maybe we can rein in the budget and not provide so much.

“From what I have heard anecdotally there doesn’t seem to be advisers overrun with demand coming from Pension Wise, so that would suggest our argument that advisers would benefit less than forecast was right.”

Plan Money director Peter Chadborn says: “Pension Wise has been running for long enough now to see how it has been progressing in the early stages. And if improvements can be made it’s better to put this information out in the open so we can make changes now rather than having a review two years later on.

“But there needs to be enough transparency, and if the Treasury aren’t forthcoming with this information then they can’t be surprised if people get a little bit cynical about the whole process.”

Low take-up

Earlier this month, a Hargreaves Lansdown survey of 300 investors found just 10 per cent of the first cohort following the introduction of the freedoms had used Pension Wise.

And a YouGov survey of 1,649 over-50s – commissioned by Old Mutual Wealth for a forthcoming report – found only 1 per cent of people aware of the pension reforms have spoken to Pension Wise as a result.

However, out of 1,152 people members of workplace schemes run by BlackRock, 61 per cent have accessed Pension Wise.

Standard Life head of pensions strategy Jamie Jenkins believes the Government may be refusing to discuss the performance of its service due to a lack of take-up. In last week’s Summer Budget, Chancellor George Osborne the service would be expanded so that anyone aged 50 or over can use it.

He says: “My sense is the take-up has been lower than expected. If take-up was very high then they wouldn’t have capacity to expand Pension Wise.

“But it’s an important part of the framework and we, just like advisers, are partly funding it, so we do want to know if it’s being successful.”

In numbers


Adviser bill for Pension Wise in 2015/16. The guidance service will cost the financial services industry £35m in total


Number of Freedom of Information requests Money Marketing has so far had rejected from the Government and FCA on Pension Wise


Amount of money savers took from their pension pots as cash between April and May, according to the ABI


Expert view

Tom McPhail, head of pensions research, Hargreaves Lansdown

The Government needs to be more transparent on where Pension Wise is, and is not, working.

They should by now have enough data to give us some first indications of how successful it is proving, and the Government has an obvious responsibility to publish as much information as it can around the successes and failures of the pension freedoms and in particular the Pension Wise service.

It’s fair to say that Pension Wise was always going to build from a low base, because they couldn’t publicise it and because it was a new service. Many people in the early days were only going to be interested in taking their money.

So no-one is going to criticise the Government because Pension Wise falls short of 100 per cent take up but we need to know what those numbers are.

And it is critical they are recording a wide range of data across the pension freedoms because without that information it will be impossible to make good policy in the future.


Adviser view

Colin Low, managing director, Kingsfleet Wealth

It would be interesting to know where our funding is going, because after all we are paying for it. It would be helpful to know how often Pension Wise is being used and a degree of the satisfaction around that, although that might take a while to come out in the wash.

But I suspect 6 to 12 months might be the point at which you can get some early sense of that. In any normal business that’s when you would hope to see what progress you are making.


Pension wise logo

Budget: Govt confirms Pension Wise expansion

The Government has confirmed it will extend the Pension Wise guidance service to those aged 50 and above. In the Budget today, the Government also announced a further marketing drive to promote awareness of the service. Initially the Treasury said only people within six months of their 55th birthday could use Pension Wise. But last […]


Govt blocks data request on ‘under capacity’ Pension Wise

Government officials have again refused to disclose information on how Pension Wise is functioning more than three months after it first launched. A Freedom of Information request submitted by Money Marketing for any findings on customer satisfaction with the service was blocked by the Treasury. It acknowledged it held the information, but argued the Treasury […]


MPs to launch Pension Wise and advice inquiry

The Work and Pensions committee is to launch an inquiry into Pension Wise and the availability of advice in the wake of pension freedoms. MPs will probe both the quality of service available through Pension Wise and the availability and affordability of financial advice. In particular, the committee will look at whether people are adequately […]

US: mid-year review and outlook

By Felix Wintle, Manager of the Neptune US Opportunities Fund H1 2014 Economic data: after last year’s strength, economic data has disappointed. Indeed, the economy contracted 2.9 per cent in the first three months of the year — the US economy’s worst performance for five years. However, rather than a symptom of underlying economic weakness or […]

Apple: a stellar technology story

By Ali Unwin, head of technology sector research

Apple recently announced the highest-ever recorded quarterly net profit ($18bn), with the sale of 74.4 million iPhones helping the company deliver $74.6bn of revenue for the quarter ending December 2014. These sales were largely driven by strong demand for the new iPhone 6 and iPhone 6 Plus. Highlights included Chinese iPhone sales doubling year-on-year and unit growth of 44% in the US — supposedly a well-penetrated market. Apple ended the quarter with $178bn in cash on its balance sheet, having generated a staggering $30bn in free cash flow during the quarter.

At Neptune, we have been long-term believers in the Apple story, and continue to hold the stock in a number of our portfolios based on the company’s long-term growth prospects. This is predicated on our belief that Apple has proved thus far that it can — unusually for a consumer electronics company — maintain high margins for a sustained period of time, even as adoption of new technology slows down and competitors produce similar-specification products.


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There are 3 comments at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. Given that politicians are highly critical of the industry for not being prepared for Pension Freedoms, despite the unacceptably short period of notice, they are totally ignorant of what is going on under their own noses.

    With the increases in FCA fees now arriving in the post, advisers have the right to know what is going on, what does it cost, and where will it all end?

  2. Regardless of the take up and performance of the services provided by Pensions Wise I fail to see why the industry should be paying for a Public Information Service. I am very supportive of the idea of pensions guidance but would prefer to pay towards it as a taxpayer not as a financial adviser.

  3. So we had our FCA bill yesterday, only about 20% more than we expected. In the meantime MP’s are receiving a 10% pay rise.

    I’m just about to write to my clients explaining how my pay is increasing by 10% and our fees Are going up by 20% .


Leave a comment


Why register with Money Marketing ?

Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

Money Marketing Events
Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

Research and insight
Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

Have your say
Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

Register now

Having problems?

Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm