View more on these topics

BlackRock hits out over regulatory clampdown


Asset managers are not a source of systemic risk and should not be regulated as such, says fund giant BlackRock in response to the FSB’s consultation on new regulations.

BlackRock says asset managers “are fundamentally different from banks and other financial institutions” and therefore should not be subject to the same measures to control systemic risk. It also argues that no controls should be put in place until specific risks are identified by the FSB.

The ‘Assessment Methodologies for Identifying Non-Bank Non-Insurer Global Systemically Important Financial Institutions’ consultation paper from the FSB seeks views on the revised proposal to extend regulation beyond banks and insurance companies to other financial institutions and deem asset managers systemically important.

“Until policymakers identify systemic risks that need to be addressed, designation metrics are premature. Developing metrics without first identifying risks will likely fail at achieving the overarching goal of reducing systemic risk,” says the BlackRock response.

Instead, BlackRock argues products and investments should be regulated to reduce their risk, regardless of the entity behind them.

The FSB has proposed that it will look at the largest funds and the largest firms by assets, but BlackRock says the use of leverage within products would instead be a better metric.

The asset manager also argues that products have become safer since the financial crisis. “Many of the reforms implemented since the financial crisis have made the system in 2015 much safer than it was in 2008. Any additional reform measures should factor in the reforms that have already been taken or are in process.”

Fidelity has also responded to the proposal, branding it “irredeemably flawed” and saying such regulation “would be counterproductive and destructive”, according to the Financial Times.

The Investment Association has already released its response to the consultation, and claims judging an asset manager’s systemic risk by looking at the firm or fund size is a “useless” approach.


Adrian Boulding L&G 2012 - correct size

L&G’s Adrian Boulding to join Tisa

Legal and General pensions strategy director Adrian Boulding is to join Tisa as policy strategy director when he leaves the insurer in August. Money Marketing revealed in February Boulding was leaving L&G after 18 years. The organisation has also appointed Adam Hogkins as head of engagement, who joins from regulatory compliance firm Cordium where he […]


Experts issue SSAS abuse warning

Pension providers are warning small self-administered pension schemes are being used in ways that are not in the best interests of clients. In 2014 HMRC was given new powers to tackle pension plans being registered and used for early access to funds, known as pension liberation schemes. As part of the changes, made to the […]


Martin Werth: Protection lessons from retail’s finest

Apple is now the world’s largest company. It succeeded not because its technology was more advanced but because what it produced was aesthetically compelling and easy to use. Perfectionist Steve Jobs obsessed over every detail to make the complex simple without losing functionality. I quote: “Simple can be harder than complex: you have to work […]


UK investors hold over £400bn in ‘dinosaur’ funds

More than £400bn is currently held in “dinosaur” investment funds built for a “bygone era” that are more expensive than products available in the market today, Hargreaves Lansdown says. These funds include £220bn in with-profits vehicles, £100bn in stakeholder pensions, £75bn in fund manager Isas and £5bn in child trust funds. Stakeholder pensions, which can […]

UK gilts: Shaken and stirred

Mike Riddell, fixed income portfolio manager at Allianz Global Investors, reviews the performance of the UK government bonds market post-Brexit and assesses its future prospects, as well as giving his outlook for global fixed income markets and yields movements. In addition, he provides a brief analysis of the impact of Brexit and the Bank of […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment