View more on these topics

Bee bop along with stakeholder

Scottish Life&#39s head of pension strategy Steve Bee adopts a lightweight strategy when dealing with the heavyweight subject of stakeholder.

Against a soundtrack of Bob Dylan, Bee guides his audience through the intricacies and inconsistencies of the DSS&#39 stakeholder pension guide for employers. The message behind the CP61 Revisited roadshow, a whirlwind tour of the UK, is that IFAs have a pivotal role in the stakeholder market.

Rather than advice from IFAs being pushed out by decision trees, Bee says the DSS is actually promoting the IFA cause by making the handbook so complicated. He says: “A handbook on pensions containing more than two million words should be crystal clear but the stakeholder pension handbook is not written in English.”

The DSS is making a complex situation more complicated from the start. The handbook has been sent to employers with more than 10 employees but, as Bee points out, stakeholder applies to employers with five or more employees so, immediately, part of the target market is being ignored.

Bee says the fundamental problem, however, is the hand book is not a comprehensive guide for employers and they will need assistance to establish whether their business is exempt and if their employees are relevant.

To claim exemption, an employer must have no relevant employees, yet deciding who is relevant is not easy. According to Bee the handbook only outlines ways that an employee is not relevant for stakeholder and leaves it to employer to determine who is.

Sparing no expense, Bee and his sidekick, business development manager Paul Goodwin, present a series of matchstick-men diagrams to illustrate who is relevant.

Employees earning less than the lower earnings&#39 limit, those under 18 and those within five years of the normal retirement date are all considered not relevant.

Members of acceptable alternatives, such as an occupational pension scheme, are also not relevant but Bee says GPPs are a worrying exception as not all of them meet the required criteria and many employers might automatically assume employees covered by a GPP are not relevant when they could be.

For a GPP to qualify as an acceptable alternative, it must comply with four rules, including a mandatory employer contribution of 3 per cent basic salary and employee contributions being deducted from payroll. Bee points out the inconsistencies of this rule saying: “Personal pensions in GPPs cannot have certain kinds of extra charges but front-end loading is still allowed.”

The message behind Bee&#39s presentation is that IFAs are in a privileged position and should use their knowledge to approach employers about stakeholder.

Employers are not allowed to talk to their staff about regulated products, they cannot recommend a scheme or advise an employee whether they should join. But, as Bee says, IFAs can.

Employers will not want to become pension experts. They want an easy solution to their pension problems rather than becoming more confused by the handbook. Bee is encouraging IFAs to step in, help the employer in product advice and establishing who is and isn&#39t relevant.

Bee says: “The handbook is the best advertisement for IFAs. Employers will want advice and IFAs should do well from this.”

This is obviously a message IFAs want to hear and the response to Bee&#39s presentation is extremely positive.

IFAs say they would use Bee&#39s ideas as practical ways to approach employers. More stead Financial Services consultant Alan Wodzynski says the handbook will make an excellent marketing tool.

The comic delivery leaves the audience with smiles on their faces and IFAs feel that the contrast of facts and jokes means they are more likely to remember the overall message. The only negative comments is from IFAs exp ecting a more technical presentation but even they enjoy the light-hearted format.

Wodzynski says: “The del ivery was brilliant and got the message across very clearly. If you can make people smile and laugh then they will learn.”


Train on track for investment boutique

Former GT and M&G fund management star Nick Train is to set up a boutique investment house within the next few weeks. The firm, to be called Lind sell Train Asset Man agement, will be a joint venture with former Invesco Global fund manager Michael Lindsell. The firm is expected to launch a UK investment […]

Closing in on property

Turning to the type of client the product is most suitable for, Cooke says: “A client who believes in the residential property market and has a long-term view without income needs.” Cowell says: “A sophisticated investor – this type of scheme does not readily lend itself to the mass market.” Vaughn thinks it is difficult […]

Winterthur Life launches with profits bond

Winterthur Life has launched a With Profits Bond, that will invest up to 90% of the fund in equities to generate high growth. It offers an annual bonus rate of 6.25 per cent and has a minimum investment of £5,000. External fund managers will manage all equity investments – Newton and Deutsche Asset Management have […]

PPIA appoints seven new directors

The Pensions Protection and Investments Accreditation Board is appointing seven new non-executive directors. These are John Akerman of law firm Olswang, Roderick Chamberlain of Coutts Consulting, Jenny Kirkpatrick of The Strategic Partnership, public policy consultant Brian Pomeroy, Ann Robinson of the Harwich Haven Authority, Tina Tietjen of the Women’s Royal Voluntary Service and Helena Wiesner […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm