View more on these topics

Banks ‘too weak’ for negative interest rates

Bank-of-England-Building-BoE-Bus-700x450.jpgBank balance sheets are not strong enough to cope with negative interest rate policy, one economist has warned.

David McWilliams, an economist writing for Woodford Investment Management, says the banking industry is still recovering from the financial crisis and the more recent China turmoil and is not stable enough to cope with negative interest rates.

He says: “Unfortunately, the central assumption of using monetary policy to fight deflation is that the banks are in rude health and bank lending will be the engine of growth, stimulating the economy. Nothing could be further from the truth.”

As a result of previous crises the private sector has too much existing debt and does not want to borrow, while the banks have too much bad debt and don’t want to lend, he says.

“Negative interest rates amplify this problem precisely because negative rates make fragile banks weaker, not stronger, undermining the very institutions which were supposed to be the foundation of the recovery,” he adds.

His comments come as Bank of England governor Mark Carney said the Bank would consider cutting interest rates, but ruled out negative interest rates.

He said: “We have other options and would take very seriously the impact of negative interest rates on financial services and building societies especially.”

Instead, McWilliams recommends expansionary fiscal policy, so using more public money to invest in the economy, which he says “would be hardly revolutionary”.

“It’s been done before and it worked, it’s just out of fashion. More radical would be the use of ‘helicopter money’, which Jeremy Corbyn has called ‘QE for the people’,” he adds.

Helicopter lending sees central banks financing government spending or tax cuts directly, not via banks or markets.

“This creates new uncertainties, of course, not just over what policies central banks will choose to pursue, or when, but also over the differing extents that the major central banks will go to in boosting growth and spending,” says Andrew Humphries, marketing and communications director at St James’s Place Wealth Management.

“Moreover, a number of touted policy directions have not been tried before. Given ongoing debates about the impact of quantitative easing – very much a tried-and-tested approach – it is hard to predict how these new policies will play out in markets.



Gregg McClymont: Why are savers reluctant to pay for advice?

I have no idea what financial advice is like in Northern Germany but as the Financial Advice Market Review rumbles towards a close this side of the North Sea, one is increasingly reminded of Lord Palmerston’s famous aphorism: “The Schleswig-Holstein question is so complicated, only three men in Europe have ever understood it. One was Prince […]


Pru boosts with-profits final bonus payouts but returns slump

Prudential has maintained total annual bonus payouts across its with-profits funds at £600m as investment returns slumped to 3.2 per cent during 2015. Total final bonus payouts – which are paid when the policy reaches maturity – edged up from £1.3bn in 2014 to £1.4bn last year. Annual investment returns were down, however, from 7 […]


HSBC profits disappoint ahead of ‘bumpier’ financial times

HSBC has reported a lower-than-expected 2015 pre-tax profit for the end of 2015, as the bank sees a “bumpier” financial environment ahead. The bank said profit before tax was $18.87bn (£13.28bn) for 2015 against $18.7bn the year before. Net profit for 2015 dropped 1.2 per cent to $13.52bn from the previous year. HSBC group chief […]


Pound hits 7-year low amid Brexit panic

The pound has hit a seven-year low against the dollar, as fears about the UK leaving the European Union sparked nervousness among investor. Yesterday the pound dropped by 2.4 per cent at its lowest to hit $1.4059, lower than the $1.4079 low on 21 January. The fall marked its weakest rate against the dollar since March 2009, when […]

Pensions Dashboards around the World

Steve Webb’s latest policy paper British savers risk being left in the ‘slow lane’ unless the UK Government takes a more active role in ensuring the successful delivery of a Pensions Dashboard. The report, ‘Pensions Dashboards around the World’, coincided with a major conference that was held on Monday 16 May and brought together experts […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There is one comment at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. Good to see support widening for more positive fiscal policy. Monetary policy has just about managed to maintain some stability, but it was always going to be insufficient to drive any positive growth.

Leave a comment


Why register with Money Marketing ?

Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

Money Marketing Events
Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

Research and insight
Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

Have your say
Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

Register now

Having problems?

Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm