View more on these topics

Band aid

The definition of basic earnings poses a tough problem

Certification of pension schemes that use basic pay to calculate contributions is a difficult nut to crack.

Ever since automatic enrolment band earnings were proposed, the industry has argued existing good quality pension schemes should be able to ignore band earnings if they paid contributions equivalent to or above this level.

The DWP’s Making Automatic Enrolment Work review last September recommended existing schemes could certify if they met one of three criteria – contributions were at least 7 per cent of pensionable pay and all pay was pensionable, or, 8 per cent of pensionable pay where 85 per cent of pay was pensionable, or, 9 per cent of pensionable pay with at least 4 per cent from the employer.

Legislation to implement the recommendations has recently been made available for consultation and contained a bit of a surprise. Instead of pensionable pay, there is “basic earnings”. The definition of basic earnings includes all regular pay items, including bonus, overtime and commission.

But employers do not include pay items such as bonus, overtime and commission in what they call basic pay or pensionable pay. In fact, this new definition looks similar to the one used for band earnings.

This begs an obvious question: “Why pay 9 per cent of total pay, including bonus commission and overtime, when I can get away with paying 8 per cent of a similar amount and also ignore the first £5,715 of each employee’s earnings?”

Employers are very unlikely to change their current definition of pensionable pay to the new basic earnings definition. After all, that would mean making a slice of pay pensionable when it currently is not. Already faced with a cost increase from enrolling non-joiners, employers will not be falling over themselves to increase their contributions for all staff.

If the 9 per cent option looks to be unworkable, what about the other two options.

The 7 per cent option says you must pay 7 per cent of total pay, including all pay items such as bonus, commission and overtime. As this rate is lower than the rate applying to band earnings, this seems fair. But it is also a mathematical no-brainer – 7 per cent of total pay is always more than 8 per cent of band earnings, all the time and for all employees. If this is a cast-iron mathematic certainty, why is there a need to certify 7 per cent of total pay at all?

The final option is 8 per cent of basic earnings (same definition as above) where basic earnings are at least 85 per cent of total earnings across the workforce. This option does appear to have some use. Although 8 per cent of 85 per cent of total pay is also always greater than or equal to 8 per cent of band earnings, the test applies across the whole workforce. So there may be employees who pass this test on an individual basis and some who fail but, overall, the scheme can still pass.

Maybe this 8 per cent definition should also be used for the 9 per cent and above contribution as long as basic earnings are at least, say, 75 per cent of total earnings.

Formal consultation will take place over the summer, so certification is not yet lost but there are no easy answers to this conundrum.

John Lawson is head of pensions policy at Standard Life



Andrew Fisher’s Towry share worth up to £160m

Andrew Fisher’s 20 per cent share in Towry could be worth as much as £160m in the event of an initial public offering, it was revealed in the High Court yesterday. The figure was revealed in a case where Towry is seeking £5.8m damages from Raymond James and seven former Edward Jones advisers over the […]

BoE governor King awarded a knighthood

Bank of England governor Mervyn King has been awarded a knighthood in the Queen’s birthday honours list. He has been governor of the Bank of England since 2003 and was deputy governor from 1998 to 2003 and chief economist and executive director from 1991. King, who is chairman of the bank’s monetary policy committee, was […]

FSA and Capita role in Arch cru to be raised in parliament

The FSA and Capita Financial are both set for further scrutiny over the collapse of the £400m Arch cru fund range. The role of the regulator and Capita, which acted as administrator of the Arch cru fund range, will be raised by Conservative MP Alun Cairns, who says he is representing several constituents caught up […]

Hawksmoor turns to bonds

Hawksmoor Investment Management is holding almost a quarter of its Vanbrugh fund of funds in a range of bonds that aim to produce real returns after inflation at a relatively low risk. The multi-manager firm says because cash delivered a negative return of 4.1 per cent after inflation last year, its worst real return since […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm