View more on these topics

How Aviva, SJP and Standard Life would cope with pension tax relief reform


Aviva is expected to suffer less of a hit than St James’s Place and Standard Life if the Government decides to remove the higher rate of pension tax relief.

In an analyst note on Aviva published today, RBC Capital Markets warns the “inevitable” scrapping of higher rate tax relief on pensions would pose a “big potential threat” for the insurer.

However, the note says: “We expect Aviva to be less affected as it has a mass-market brand while Standard Life and SJP have higher-end brands. In addition, despite being the market leader the diversity of Aviva’s business means it is less exposed.”

RBC argues pension tax relief reform is inevitable due to the Government’s greater need for tax receipts after Brexit.

It adds: “The Government published a consultation on reducing the money purchase annual allowance. In this paper we believe the Government subtly sets out its intention to get rid of higher rate tax relief on pensions.”

RBC data estimates new pension business as a percentage of total business profit at SJP will fall to 34 per cent in 2018 from 37 per cent this year.

It predicts Standard Life will also see a 3 per cent drop from 25 per cent this year to 22 per cent in 2018.

Meanwhile, Aviva is likely to see a marginal decrease from 6 per cent to 5 per cent.

Legal & General was the only insurer that would see its pension profit increase with RBC estimating it would reach 6 per cent in 2018 from 4 per cent this year.



Danby Bloch: Hammond’s warning on pension tax relief

The most concerning part of Chancellor Philip Hammond’s Autumn Statement was not in his speech, or even in the Green Book setting out the details of the main proposals. It was tucked away in a consultative document about cutting the amount of the pension money purchase annual allowance. The following passage from that document has […]


Treasury denies threat to pension tax relief

The Treasury says it has “no plans” to scrap pension tax relief for higher earners despite hints about reform buried in the Autumn Statement. The Financial Times reports in a consultation issued alongside the Autumn Statement it was stated that tax and national insurance contributions relief on pensions was one of the “most expensive” Government […]


Tony Wickenden: Preparing for flat rate pension tax relief

Since the freedom and choice regime was introduced last year, pensions have been a constant source of headlines. Only recently we have heard that the Government is not to proceed with the implementation of a secondary annuity market. And in the run up to Chancellor Philip Hammond’s first Autumn Statement on 23 November, there appears to […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment