View more on these topics

Audits or plaudits?

Judgement day for the pension simplification review comes in the next fortnight and will open old wounds in the relationship between Prime Minister Tony Blair and Chancellor Gordon Brown.

When the National Audit Office publishes its review of the effect that the Inland Revenue&#39s proposal for a £1.4m lifetime limit will have on pension saving and the numbers who will be affected, both Number 10 and Number 11 Downing Street will be looking to claim victory.

But while many in the industry see the NAO referral as a box-ticking exercise, this powerful organisation, which is independent of the Government and reports only to Parliament, could produce a surprise.

Last December, the Prime Minister&#39s office – in response to a petition from captains of industry concerned at being cut out of pensions – was widely reported to have issued an 11th-hour demand that the limit should be raised because it was not going to hit only fat cats.

The Treasury and Revenue said 5,000 would be affected by the cap at the planned introduction date of April 2005, with a further 1,000 likely to be hit each year after that.

When Brown brought in the NAO to see who was right, he threatened to drop the entire simplification programme if it found against him, a move that Scottish Equitable pensions development director Stewart Ritchie described as the most bizarre he had seen in his career in pensions and that Scottish Life head of pension strategy Steve Bee said effectively put a gun to the head of the industry.

The Chancellor&#39s position has left the entire project in limbo and ripped nearly four months out of the tight time-table for implementation by April 2005. Many expect the NAO to confirm the Treasury&#39s view but, contrary to the assumptions of most in the pension industry, the NAO is not simply checking the Revenue&#39s sums but is also carrying out its own fresh research. The NAO has been not afraid to upset the Government&#39s apple cart in the past.

NAO spokesman Barry Lester says: “We are gathering new data and embracing new material for this review so, yes, there is a real chance of a different outcome to the results produced by the Treasury. We are entirely independent and can say whatever we wish.”

The NAO is looking at three issues – whether it is factually accurate that the £1.4m lifetime allowance is, using a factor of 20:1 to calculate the capital value of a defined-benefit pension, equivalent to the maximum pension available under the current cap, whether 5,000 people will be immediately hit by the lifetime limit and whether the Government is right that around 1,000 people a year will be affected in the future.

Occupational pensions are currently capped at £70,000 so the first of these issues is a foregone conclusion but responses to the second and third issues will make interesting reading as the rest of the industry has so strongly contradicted the Treasury&#39s figures.

But has the industry fallen for Brown&#39s brinkmanship and been panicked into accepting the £1.4m limit for fear of losing simplification?

National Association of Pension Funds spokesman Andy Fleming says: “We did criticise the level of the lifetime limit at the time it was announced and one of our particular concerns was the fact that many senior directors are likely to be hit and this could disenfranchise them from pensions generally. But if the alternative was losing the whole package, then frankly we would rather take it because we applaud the simplification proposals the Inland Revenue have put forward.”

Hornbuckle Mitchell Trus-tees managing director Mark Stubbs argues that lobbying has its limits. He says: “The industry has made extremely strong representations on the level of the £1.4m limit but you can only lobby so far. In the end, Gordon Brown is the one with the power and if he wants £1.4m, he will get it. But the fact remains that you cannot buy a £70,000 annuity with two-thirds spouse benefit and indexation for £1.4m.”

Stubbs thinks the Chancellor is not bothered whether it is 5,000 or 10,000 people who will be immediately hit by the cap because he views them as being pension fat cats and not his immediate concern, bearing in mind the overall pension crisis. As an economic group, they already get far more tax relief than most but Bee&#39s view that directors should have as much pension tax relief as they like if they achieve significant take-up among their staff is surely more sophisticated.

The Treasury has made concessions to soften the effect of the £1.4m – the reduction in the penalty charge from 33 per cent to 25 per cent, the restoration of pre-75 drawdown death benefits and disregarding the £200,000 contribution limit in the year before retirement – and these have been welcomed by the industry.

But the fact remains that a £1.4m lifetime limit indexed to prices will catch increasing numbers of people and will affect many who would not have been hit by the earnings&#39 cap if the downward trend in annuity rates continues.

ABI head of pensions and savings Joanne Segars says: “We certainly do not want to see the retention of eight pension tax regimes. The Revenue has given concessions such as the reduction in the penalty tax but we would clearly like to see the £1.4m indexed to wages rather than prices.”

Is the Treasury in a corner if the NAO finds against it? Many will be hoping that it does not come to that but what everyone is calling for is an end to the uncertainty and the real beginning of the legislative timetable.


IFA chiefs&#39 pay falls by 20% at big companies

The directors of big IFA businesses have seen big cuts in salary and bonuses compared with general brokers, according to a report from IMAS corporate advisers. The annual report compares the fortunes of the top 200 general and life distributors in the UK based on company accounts. Directors of big IFAs with turnover above £10m […]

Direct Life in express delivery with underwriting deal

Protection IFA Direct Life & Pensions Services says it has developed the first tele-underwriting service for the IFA market. Sales and marketing director Richard Verdin says the group developed the process, called Express Underwriting, in a bid to improve protection distribution. Verdin believes advisers in the UK are generally ill-equipped to support or advise clients […]

PInk offers landlords flexi option

PINK HOME LOANS Mortgage Trust Flexible Buy-to-Let Libor Tracker Type:Flexible buy-to-let tracker mortgage Tracker term: Three years Tracker rate: Libor plus 0.95% Payable rate: 4.995% Minimum loan: £30,000 Maximum loan: Up to 85% of valuation subject to a maximum of £250,000, up to 80% of valuation subject to a maximum of £500,000, up to 75% […]

Standard Life reduces critical rates

Standard Life is moving to cut its critical illness rates, with the changes mainly affecting accelerated critical illness cover which see cuts of an average 20 per cent. The changes took effect on February 27, with Standard targeting the mortgage market and younger lives. Accelerated critical illness benefits on its level, mortgage, renewable and convertible […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers. Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and thought leadership.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm