View more on these topics

PI premiums jump 21% amid DB transfer fears

Research shows advisers are upbeat but worries about PI coverage linger. Michael Klimes reports.  

Many hands reach up to grab piggy bank one holdsAll professions have their taboo subjects that make everyone go silent and fidget nervously at the dinner table when brought up.

Among advisers, defined benefit transfers are the topic which tends to split the room.

A new study about advisers’ attitudes towards the transfer market reinforces anecdotal evidence that professional indemnity insurance bills are heading skywards as providers become more nervous about the risks involved.

Research by NextWealth and Richard Parkin Consulting with support from Bravura looks at various factors affecting the DB transfer market and how these might affect the volume of DB transfers.

It is based on a survey of 267 financial advisers, in-depth qualitative interviews and data from platforms. The findings make for particularly interesting reading as they present one of the first definitive assessments of professional indemnity insurance coverage in relation to DB transfers.

Ensuring insurance

On PI, the study finds 39 per cent of advisers renewed their PI insurance in the past year with an average premium increase of 21 per cent. The FCA’s latest figures for 2017 on PI insurance suggest larger financial advice firms have been able to manage their costs better than smaller firms, but it has acknowledged the potential for increased premiums and reduced coverage amid warnings on DB transfer suitability.

The FCA said financial advice firms with revenue under £100,000 paid an average premium of £2,400, which represents around 4 per cent of their average revenue. This compares with just over 1 per cent of revenue for the large firms with revenue of more than £10m.

Research for a recent cover story by Money Marketing  on the subject of how networks and national advice firms are adapting to heightened FCA scrutiny on DB transfers also suggested larger firms appear to be weathering the PI insurance storm better.

One large network that did not want to be named said it has had no problem with securing PI insurance, but the increased focus from its insurers on final salary transfers could be affecting smaller firms.

The network added it knows of one adviser who left to become directly authorised, but rang the network’s pension specialist team a few months later to ask if it had PI insurance cover.

While  the FCA, large networks and NextWealth are all reporting similar PI insurance coverage pressures, not everything in the latest report is doom and gloom.

NextWealth finds there is a lot of optimism among advisers regarding DB transfers over the next 12 months.

Sunnier climes

Despite increasing regulatory and media attention on DB transfers advisers are, overall, optimistic with nearly 80 per cent believing transfer volumes will either increase or stay the same over the next year.

A quarter of advisers expect that the FCA’s changes to be introduced from October 2018 will make them less likely to recommend a transfer to their clients.

Furthermore half of advisers believe a ban on contingent charging would lead to a reduction in transfer volumes with 60 per cent of these saying volumes could fall by over 25 per cent.

Although PI insurance premiums are rising the study finds this is more likely to result in advisers increasing fees or focusing on higher value cases rather than reducing the volume of transfer business they do. But it is also notes the bigger issue will be whether advisers can get cover at all.

Commenting on the findings consultant Richard Parkin says: “The explosion in DB transfers has understandably raised regulatory concerns and it is notable that 40 per cent of the advisers we surveyed don’t offer DB advice at all.

“Despite this closer regulatory scrutiny, advisers seem reasonably optimistic that the DB market will at least stay flat if not grow from here. We believe that advisers may be being too optimistic.

“The FCA rule changes shouldn’t come as a big shock for good advisers but they may make transfers harder to recommend.”

He adds: “However, there are some very clear risks to the market. A ban on contingent charging is likely to have a significant impact though we believe it will be difficult to ban all forms of contingent fee. Perhaps the bigger concern is the cost and availability of PI insurance.

“Those advisers who have recently renewed their PI insurance cover and seen premiums increase aren’t necessarily inclined to reduce transfer activity.

“During the course of our research though, we heard more advisers telling us of exclusions or limits on their policies and this could have a significant impact over the coming months.

“Reports of the claims management companies seeking unsuitable advice will inevitably worry insurers and make cover harder to come by.”



FSCS chief: PI insurance is ‘broken reed’

Financial Services Compensation Scheme chief executive Mark Neale says professional indemnity insurance is a “broken reed” given the high excess on policies and the fact that some policies exclude FSCS claims. Last week the FSCS said an interim levy for 2013/14 will be triggered for investment advisers following the default of life settlement business Catalyst Investment […]

Professional indemnity edge: Alan Harris

In November 2002, my PI insurance renewal application was declined by the Markel syndicate at Lloyd’s because, in their view, the premium and excess they would require would be uneconomical for the size of my firm.

MCRI make Professional Indemnity Insurance mandatory by July

The Mortgage Code Registered of Intermediaries is forcing members to take out Professional Indemnity Insurance by July 1 1999.The move which was expected to be announced later in the year has caught many brokers on the hop.Millennium Insurance chief executive Ben Fish says: &#34bad publicity over the cowboy end of the profession has forced the […]


What employers should expect over the next five years

A major feature of our articles is looking into the Jelf Employee Benefits crystal ball to predict changes and trends that may influence the short and medium term shape of UK employee benefits.  By flagging such changes early we aim to provide our followers with the tools to make sensible and informed decisions on their benefits offerings.


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There are 2 comments at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. On PI, the study finds 39 per cent of advisers renewed their PI insurance in the past year with an average premium increase of 21 per cent.

    So what happened to the other 61%, they can’t all be on 2 year contracts surely?

    A quarter of advisers expect that the FCA’s changes to be introduced from October 2018 will make them less likely to recommend a transfer to their clients.

    And so the other 75% are just oblivious to the obvious and will plough on regardless.

    • Richard Parkin 9th July 2018 at 10:09 am

      We asked advisers if they’d renewed their PI cover in the previous six months as we wanted to capture what had happened since the DB issues at British Steel and elsewhere had started to surface. Anecdotally we heard that more recently the issue is not just premium levels but exclusions and excesses.

      On your other point, many advisers told us that they do something similar to an APTA already. For me, the issue is whether the TVC with its gilt yield discount rate and standard comparison basis will make TVs look poor value even if they are large in absolute terms.

      This will especially be the case where the client is a long way from retirement where FCA has warned that advisers should be cautious as it is difficult if not impossible to know what a client’s retirement needs are when they’re so far away from taking benefits.

Leave a comment


Why register with Money Marketing ?

Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

Money Marketing Events
Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

Research and insight
Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

Have your say
Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

Register now

Having problems?

Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm