View more on these topics

Apfa: Act now while the FCA is in listening mode

 Caroline Escott

Advisers are in danger of consultation fatigue, having seen so many discussion papers, market studies and the like over the last few years. But it seems that, despite the abundance of government and regulatory requests for input on various issues, there is scepticism as to whether feedback from firms and their trade associations actually results in any real change.

Under new chief executive Andrew Bailey, however, the FCA seems to be in genuine listening mode, perhaps in an attempt to fend off increasing Parliamentary scrutiny. This is particularly apparent in its recently published Mission paper.

This paper aims to clarify the reasoning behind the FCA’s work and explain how it chooses the tools it uses to do it. This should help regulated firms and others understand the FCA’s remit and approach, and better hold it to account.

The paper is short and asks some fundamental questions about the role of a financial regulator. Our initial thinking can be summarised as follows:

  • There must be clarity about what is expected of consumers. There is room for firms to make it easier for consumers to engage with decision-making but there must be clarification regarding their level of responsibility – for example, that they must read the relevant disclosures and suitability report when it comes to obtaining advice.
  • The paper acknowledges regulatory costs feed through to consumer fees. If the FCA is serious about reducing the cost of advice to consumers, it needs to use vehicles like the Financial Advice Market Review and its Sustainable Regulation agenda to reduce the burden placed on advisers.
  • The Handbook needs to be pruned. In its current form, its length and complexity deters new entrants and constitutes a significant regulatory cost. And then there are the continual changes, additions and updates. The forthcoming review is welcome but must be undertaken systematically and thoroughly.
  • The significant and increasing costs of the Financial Services Compensation Scheme, as well as the high number of complaints to the Financial Ombudsman Service, are an indication that earlier regulatory systems and processes (i.e. authorisation, conduct rules and supervision) are failing. The FCA’s focus should be on getting these earlier steps right and reducing reliance on the complaints and redress system for consumer protection.
  • The paper discusses the need to identify appropriate metrics to measure performance. Chief among these must be the FSCS levies and volume of complaints to the FOS as an indication that the conduct rules and supervision system are not working. These statistics should be included alongside data on the number of new entrants and levels of switching between providers.
  • Any changes to the Handbook or FCA rules must be communicated to the FOS and it is vital to ensure these changes are understood by the ombudsman at all levels – from management to investigators.

The FCA was set up in a relatively short space of time and such a high level review is both welcome and necessary. Advisers – particularly those who have expressed concern about the fundamentals of the framework – should make sure they take the time to consider this very short paper and respond either directly or through their membership associations. The FCA is listening and the adviser community needs to make sure it is heard.

Caroline Escott is senior policy adviser at Apfa



Mission critical: The FCA’s roadmap to better reguation

The FCA’s new mission statement may be “the missing piece of the regulator’s jigsaw”, but experts are questioning what impact it will have on how the watchdog works. The regulator launched a consultation last week as part of chief executive Andrew Bailey’s plans to set out the FCA’s new “mission”. The FCA wants the mission to […]


FCA chief: New mission is not a ‘political shield’

The FCA’s new mission statement is not meant as a “political shield”, the regulator’s chief executive Andrew Bailey has said. It is also not about “repositioning” the regulator, but will better explain what the regulator does and why it does it, Bailey has said. The FCA published the consultation today, describing it as a set of principles […]


FCA looks to target unregulated firms in new ‘mission’

The FCA is eyeing action on unregulated firms and vulnerable customers as it sets out a new “mission”. The FCA today began a consultation on its mission document, a set of principles that will inform the regulator’s strategy and day-to-day work. The FCA says the purpose of the mission is to give clarity over the objectives […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There is one comment at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. Was the FCA set up in a relatively short space of time? I hardly think so. It’s just a phoenix of the FSA (same address, same company number, same constitution, same staff, same lack of accountability, same licence to ignore the Statutory Code of Practice for Regulators) with a slightly different name and a few new faces at the top, most of whom have already gone, not least its CEO. What else has changed? Certainly nothing fundamental. And just because the FCA has invited responses to the latest in its endless string of consultation papers hardly constitutes proof that this time it’s prepared to listen, let alone act on them. History suggests strongly that action is likely to result only if imposed by unchallengeable directives from an independent body. Why is APFA not pressing for the creation of such a body?

Leave a comment


Why register with Money Marketing ?

Providing trusted insight for professional advisers. Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and thought leadership.

News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

Money Marketing Events
Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

Research and insight
Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

Have your say
Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

Register now

Having problems?

Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm