View more on these topics

Another planet

So what implications does the comprehensive spending review have for you and your clients? I am not talking about the impact it will have on everybody’s finances – presumably few of us will emerge from the Chancellor’s axe-wielding unscathed – but how might it affect your thoughts on investment, pensions, insurance, protection and so on?

The thing is, I cannot quite shake the feeling that, unlike the Budget and pre-Budget statements we have grown used to over the years, with their ever-shifting tax bands and contribution limits and so forth, George Osborne’s speech served to highlight the inconvenient gap that can sometimes exist between Her Majesty’s financial services industry and what we might loosely describe as ’real life’.

This is not to condemn the sterling efforts of the financial press in conjuring up squillions of words with which to fill their pages and their websites – as the young Mr Grace might say, you’ve all done very well – but, dear reader, how much of it was actually, um, relevant, to what you do for a living?

Yes, I would imagine the rise in the state pension age, not to mention the change to pensions tax relief flagged up ahead of the review, may and indeed probably should cause you to revisit the files of a number of clients. But what about the area I am supposed to know most about – the wonderful world of investment?

Yes, there was the increase in the amount an individual may contribute to an Isa to an eye-catching and truly memorable £10,870 a year but let’s try and think a little bigger than that – which would be more than whoever came up with that £480 rise managed to do. Boom, boom. Let me think – there was…well, not a lot really.

That has certainly been the conclusion drawn by the handful of fund groups, who could stir themselves to offer a response on the day of the review and the similar number who have managed to do so since. As an illustration, I would highlight the thoughts of Newton’s global strategist Peter Hensman – principally because he was the first person to bring to my attention the most excellent pun “Slash Wednesday”.

“As the announcement merely confirmed the initial plans laid out in June’s emergency Budget, the market reaction has been negligible, with sterling and gilts barely shifting,” he said. “This is little more than a thumbs-up from markets, suggesting that the nature and size of the planned austerity measures had already been priced in. A lack of surprises was just was the market wanted.”

Well, fair enough but, put another way, that’s hundreds of thousands of jobs to go, millions of families worse off and steady as she goes on the old economic and investment fronts.

As I may have threatened before, one day I hope to be clever enough to write about the fiction that Her Majesty’s financial services industry exists to advise and serve 50-odd million adults when the reality is closer to…what? Five million? Two million? Less?

Maybe the Chancellor has given me a way in but I’ll save it for another time. Instead, let us finish by acknowledging the comprehensive spending review may have some vague consequences for the economy by playing my new Pick a Country, any Country game (available in all good toyshops and probably Argos this Christmas).

The trick is to equate the UK to another country as a way of illustrating your view on its short-term economic destiny. So you may think Osborne has cut too much, too soon, in which case we are about to do an Ireland.

Alternatively, you may feel the Chancellor has done enough to stop us from pulling a Greece. Maybe the country is about to manage a Canada post-1995 although, without the small matter of one of the strongest bull runs of modern times, that could just as easily be a Cantada.

Or perhaps you don’t have quite as much faith as Osborne in the Treasury’s post-cut expectations for UK growth or tax takes or managerial savings. In which case we are living in Narnia – and, oddly enough, we are back, once again, to the relationship between financial services and the real world.

Julian Marr is editorial director of


PosSol in advice deal with Trust Inheritance

Positive Solutions has launched a joint initiative with estate planning specialist Trust Inheritance. The agreement, which was confirmed last week, will enable Positive Solutions’ IFA partners to offer financial advice to customers of Trust Inheritance. This will be in addition to the advice that Trust Inheritance clients get at present on trust and estate planning. […]

Nest spared Osborne’s axe

The National Employment Savings Trust has been spared Chancellor George Osborne’s axe as the structure of the Government’s auto-enrolment reforms began to take shape last week. Osbourne announced in the comprehensive spending review that the Government-sponsored savings scheme will be rolled out at low levels in 2011, with volunteer employers and their low to moderate […]

Platform paper is put on hold again until end of year

The FSA has again delayed the publication of its consultation paper on platform regulation and now expects to finalise it before the end of the year. The FSA published its discussion paper in March and originally planned to issue a consultation paper in the summer followed by a policy statement at the end of the […]


Out of context

“I hesitate to say it, but I’m not sure people see this industry as very sexy.” Aifa director Robert Sinclair explains some harsh truths to the Treasury select committee. “I’m on a mission to make thrift sexy.” Scottish Widows executive director Robert Fletcher attempts to prove Sinclair wrong at the launch of the 6th annual […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm