View more on these topics

Andrew Tully: FCA must act to boost pensions shopping around

With the publication of its CP15/30 consultation paper earlier this month, the FCA added to the seemingly never-ending legislative and regulatory developments to pensions.

While the paper purports to deal with the aftermath of the pension freedom changes, in reality it covers a wide range of topics, including design and distribution of products, projections and the second line of defence. The irony that a paper dealing with improving communications with customers is 139 pages long and makes for fairly tortuous reading is perhaps best glossed over.

The consultation considers ways to enable customers to make informed decisions and encourage them to explore the full range of options when they reach retirement, including shopping around on the open market.

While clearly not a new concept, it is worrying – and frankly ridiculous – that only about 45 per cent of people currently shop around for an annuity. The comparable figure for drawdown is marginally higher at 55 per cent but the overall point is clear: too many customers do not shop around for the best deal, potentially leading to them getting an inferior outcome.

These are scandalously poor figures and require firm and decisive action from the regulator. Much more firm and decisive action, I would suggest, than this consultation proposes. In 2016, requirements may be introduced to help people compare annuity income from different providers, to replace wake-up packs and to supersede the Association of British Insurers Code.

While this will hopefully help more people get a better result, it seems to be tinkering around the edges, rather than making any fundamental change to dramatically improve customer outcomes.

The ABI Code prevented members from sending annuity application forms with wake-up packs unless specifically requested by the customer. The FCA proposes incorporating this into its rules and extending it to cover any retirement income solution, such as drawdown or uncrystallised funds pension lump sums, which is a positive step.

In a similar vein, where illustrations are not required but a provider wants to produce these, the FCA proposes an illustration is provided for each of the retirement income options. However, rather than simplify matters, this could result in a customer receiving a vast quantity of paperwork, which surely is not conducive to good decision making.

The consultation also includes a number of measures relating to the new pension freedoms. This greater choice means people have unlimited access to their pension pot from age 55, which obviously increases the risk it may not last their remaining lifespan. The consultation recognises this and suggests providers should demonstrate to customers the sustainability of their withdrawals.

This is a key aspect and it is important customers are told simply and clearly how long their withdrawals may last. For example, showing a customer  funds may run out at a certain age and they have a very high likelihood of being alive at that date may make them pause and consider whether the action they have chosen is appropriate. The FCA needs to make sure any communication in this area is very simple for customers to understand, unlike the hugely complex, and largely meaningless, drawdown critical yield calculations.

Elsewhere, the FCA wants to treat the new option of UFPLS similarly to income drawdown. As both allow customers to achieve the same, or similar, outcomes, that is a sensible step. There are also proposed amendments to the second line of defence measures, which were brought in last March and require retirement risk warnings to be given to customers. The FCA believes firms should not be required to ask the customer questions in order to identify potential risks where funds are below £10,000 and there are no safeguarded benefits.

This is only a snippet of the changes proposed by the FCA. For those suffering from insomnia, a read of the full document will easily provide a cure. Despite that, there is a number of important issues that should not be overlooked. In particular, anyone who wants to influence the scope of the Retirement Outcomes Review, which will focus on how the reforms have affected the market and the outcomes people are getting, needs to respond by the end of the month. Given the lack of shopping around, this is a crucial area where the FCA needs to act strongly and decisively.

Andrew Tully is pensions technical director at Retirement Advantage



Advisers back Govt plans to scale back pension guidance

Advisers have backed Government plans to “rationalise” pensions guidance after the Treasury raised concerns about overlapping services. In a financial guidance paper published alongside the Financial Advice Market Review consultation, the Treasury suggested cuts could be made to the services offered by the Money Advice Service and Pension Wise to reduce duplication. Currently, pension guidance is […]


Over £9m stolen in pension liberation scams since April

Fraudsters have taken more than £9m from savers in the five months since April, twice the sum taken in the same period last year. Figures from the City of London police show that £9.1m worth of scams have been reported between April and August 2015, up from £4.5m. The figures also show that the sums […]


Citizens Advice investigates rogue Pension Wise branch

A rogue Citizens Advice Bureau has funneled Treasury funds earmarked for Pension Wise into other services, Money Marketing can reveal. Bill Land resigned in July after his team of guidance staff were redeployed to activities unrelated to Pension Wise. Land, a former project manager at the Derbyshire Districts – one of the biggest Pension Wise […]


Hundreds of members lose £13.7m in pension scam

The Pensions Regulator has intervened in a case where 242 members from 17 pension schemes are believed to have lost around £13.7m to a scam. In a final notice published today, TPR says three trustees – Alan Barratt, Susan Dalton and Julian Hanson, acting on the instructions of David Austin – misappropriated scheme funds. Dalriada […]

US: mid-year review and outlook

By Felix Wintle, Manager of the Neptune US Opportunities Fund H1 2014 Economic data: after last year’s strength, economic data has disappointed. Indeed, the economy contracted 2.9 per cent in the first three months of the year — the US economy’s worst performance for five years. However, rather than a symptom of underlying economic weakness or […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There are 2 comments at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. As has been suggested many times before, encouraging people approaching retirement to shop around could be addressed in two ways:-

    1. Ban providers from quoting any annuities (other than advantageous guaranteed ones) and, come to that, setting out any other options such as DrawDown, and

    2. Mandate a single, brightly coloured, standalone page, possibly laminated, explaining the merits of seeking out regulated (and no other) advice in the open market (and the potential disadvantages of not doing so).

    It’s so simple. Why hasn’t the FSA/FCA done these things? Is it because, as appears to be the case, it’s constitutionally incapable of implementing simple and cost-effective solutions to absolutely anything?

  2. If people are too bone idle to get off their lazy asses and can’t be bothered to shop around then hell slap it up them. They do not deserve anything better than what their pension provider offers them first off. Most of the great unwashed couldn’t give a toss about pensions, why should we be bothered about these people. Those who do seek advice will benefit and they are the ones that we are likely to have had as clients over many years.

Leave a comment


Why register with Money Marketing ?

Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

Money Marketing Events
Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

Research and insight
Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

Have your say
Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

Register now

Having problems?

Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm