View more on these topics

Alistair Cunningham: Why advisers shouldn’t listen to ‘experts’


Whatever your opinion of the man, Michael Gove’s statement over the summer that “people in this country have had enough of experts” clearly resonated with many.

The problem with experts is that they are fallible humans, who make judgements based on past experience. They are also clouded by self-interest, so do not necessarily act with impartiality.

As financial planners, we often have dissenting opinion masquerading as expertise competing for our attention. Part of our professional skill is to approach these views with the highest level of impartiality.

The average fund manager knows more about their sector than the average planner but the reason most firms will have an investment committee is to ensure consistency and avoid recommendations being tainted by one fund house’s convincing presentation to one adviser.

That is not to say it does not happen. Whole firms have been persuaded “expert evidence” proves one investment style is superior to another. Even the Nobel committee showed an appreciation of the subtleties of the active versus passive management debate, giving the 2013 Prize in Economic Sciences to Eugene Fama, who showed markets are efficient, and Robert Shiller, who demonstrated they are not.

In a recent article for Money Marketing, Paul Lewis’ cherry-picked data showed managed cash from a diverse range of deposit takers might, over some time periods, beat a portfolio of UK equities. To many laypeople, Lewis is the face of financial expertise, so it is dangerous when he declares “cash beats shares and here is the proof”.

Of course, the same data produced to today would show very different results due to the depreciation of our currency and correlated appreciation in the FTSE 100. It is also notable that if you diversify and manage the equity content in the same way as the cash there would be a different outcome.

Ironically, one investment research consultant took the time to debunk Lewis’ data and then cobble together his own conclusion that all multi-asset funds were “worse than brainless”. I assume no professional adviser has changed their strategies based on either expert’s view.

Many of these experts have limited, if any, experience in dealing with the real issues clients face. Advisers know that the investment strategy for a 65-year-old who inherits £500,000 will likely be different to the £500,000 they have built up over their lifetime in their pension. This is about attitudes rather than any tax, or even risk-profiling, decisions.

According to a survey paid for by an annuity provider, almost 70 per cent of individuals want guarantees on their retirement savings. Does this mean 70 per cent of individuals should purchase an annuity? Of course not. We need to apply some common sense to these findings (if we are to pay them any notice at all).

All of that said, the alternative to experts is more insidious. In a world devoid of experts, decisions would be made by blind faith, rather than the use of collective wisdom. What we need to be especially careful of is those who disseminate their knowledge with an air of expertise but whose evidence-based claims are nothing more than orchestrated displays of faith.

Alistair Cunningham is financial planning director at Wingate Financial Planning



Paul Lewis: Cash beats shares and here’s the proof

You may have seen the headlines over the last week or so reporting on my new research into cash versus shares, stating the former beats the latter. In fact, the results are more nuanced. For investments over five years beginning any date between 1 January 1995 and ending up to 1 January 2016, there was […]


Alistair Cunningham: From used car salesmen to an advice profession

Recent experience selling a five-year old Volkswagen Passat highlighted to me the sharp contrast between the professionalism within financial services and other industries. I may be criticised for setting a low bar but I sincerely believe we can learn from others. Like most choices we help individuals with, selling a car is both an infrequent […]


Alistair Cunningham: The charlatan movement endangering cashflow planning

Marketed by the Government as supporting freedom and choice, misuse of flexi-access drawdown has the power to destroy an individual’s lifetime wealth. With this in mind, it is not unreasonable a product-related recommendation should cover the necessary detail in a way that is appropriate to the individual, highlighting relevant risks and benefits with due consideration. […]

The curse of long-term cash

Trevor Greetham, Head of Multi Asset at Royal London Asset Management, reveals why clients should be seriously concerned when short-term holdings of cash turn into a long-term investment. There is nothing wrong with holding wealth in the form of cash on a short-term basis. For many people capital stability is important and access to ready cash […]

Partied out and penniless

December has left me destitute. My piggy bank lies broken and empty, my lunchtime meal deal feels like an extravagant expense and I’m down to the Bountys in my box of Celebrations. But I won’t mourn my dearly departed pennies. Between buying gifts for loved ones (then deciding to keep them for myself) to treating […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There are 6 comments at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. Couldn’t agree more – especially when the ‘experts’ have ‘something to sell’ – even if that something is a contrarian (albeit perhaps populist) view which will drive traffic to a media outlet.

    Financial planning isn’t rocket science, it just needs time, patience and understanding.

  2. Quite right!

    Them that can, do! Them that can’t, talk about it!

  3. Good article Alastair!

    I especially like the paragraph: ‘The problem with experts is that they are fallible humans, who make judgements based on past experience. They are also clouded by self-interest, so do not necessarily act with impartiality.’…… This applies within so many roles within our sector.

  4. Very similar sentiments to an article in the Times earlier this year by Ed Conway, Economics Editor of Sky News. Namely, “…One thing you can be sure of- the experts will always get it
    Speaking of which isn’t about the time of year when the experts get their articles down from the shelf, blow the dust off them and resubmit them for publication- you know the ones,
    ” This Could Be Japan’s Year….”

  5. You know the definition of an “expert” is a drip !

  6. So what does this say about the expertise of an IFA?.

Leave a comment


Why register with Money Marketing ?

Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

Money Marketing Events
Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

Research and insight
Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

Have your say
Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

Register now

Having problems?

Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm