View more on these topics

Adviser Fund Index

What’s in a name?

The absolute return sector faces growing scrutiny as it approaches its third anniversary. When it was launched in April 2008, the peer group contained just 17 onshore and offshore funds. However, that number has since tripled, according to data from Financial Express, leading to concerns over the labelling of such products and the usefulness of grouping many diverse strategies under one banner.

The sector was unveiled by the IMA in response to a rising appetite for funds that, according to its definition, aim to deliver “more than zero returns in each year”.

The steady returns of Mark Lyttleton’s BlackRock UK absolute alpha portfolio had proved particularly popular with retail investors, encouraging managers to bring more absolute return products to the market.

But as the number of absolute return funds rose dramatically in 2008 and 2009, the disparate nature of their strategies became apparent. While BlackRock UK absolute alpha and Cazenove UK absolute target sought to grind out regular market neutral returns through pair trading, other funds in the sector were taking directional bets.

Several funds in the sector posted declines, prompting concern from the regulator that the abso-lute return name tag may be misleading for inv-estors. The FSA is reportedly advising firms not to use the label when launching new products and last week published a discussion paper on toughening its “interventionist” approach in relation to financial products.

The IMA, which welcomed the FSA’s proposals, is conducting its own review of the sector and may subdivide its peer group according to the timeframes over which products aim to generate an absolute return, allowing investors to compare different strategies more easily. The review forms part of a broader rethink on the classification system announced by the IMA last year.

Adviser Fund Index panellists appear broadly supportive of the FSA and IMA initiatives to protect consumers investing in the sector. AFH Wealth Management head of investment research Graham Toone says the peer group was a useful “starting point” in 2008 but product proliferation has left it in need of reform. He says: “I feel sorry for the IMA because there are so many apples and pears in the sector.”

Whitechurch Securities head of research Ben Willis agrees. He says: “If an absolute return fund is market-directional it can be quite volatile, for example. It may be less volatile than the market but it still could be triple the volatility of a market-neutral, stock-specific, grind out a steady Libor-plus fund. You have to get under the bonnet to see what investment approach the managers are employing.”

Neither Toone nor Willis favours the timeframe method for subdividing the sector, however. Toone says he would prefer a system that distinguishes between “more speculative” and lower-volatility products.

Recommended

2

Probe into pension power

Lord McFall says his independent commission on workplace retirement saving will consider whether providers take advantage of the complexity of the pension market to maintain power over consumers. Speaking to Money Marketing following the launch of the NAPF-backed workplace retirement income commission, McFall said: “Complexity means opaqueness and at the moment the power is with […]

1

FSA clamps down on Sipp disclosure rules

The Financial Services Authority has proposed amendments to Sipp disclosure rules in a bid to reduce mis-buying and mis-selling. The FSA says the changes, in anticipation of the new RDR adviser charging rules, will “encourage a more transparent personal pension scheme market” and “facilitate customers or their advisers making better purchasing decisions”. A consultation, published […]

Sherborne ousts F&C chairman

Edward Bramson’s proposal to replace F&C Asset Management’s chairman was met with success at a general meeting of shareholders today. Bramson, the founder of investment vehicle Sherborne, is likely to replace Nick MacAndrew having repeatedly called for his dismissal. The takeover comes after Bramson, led by a 17 per cent holding in F&C through Sherborne, […]

Equities overtake bonds after best sales in a decade, IMA stats

Equities replaced bonds as the most popular asset class among investors in 2010, attracting net retail sales of £7.5bn in 2010, according to statistics from the Investment Management Association. In 2009 bonds topped the asset class rankings, but according to the IMA sales of equity funds in 2010 were at their highest level since 2000. […]

Newsletter

News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up

Comments

    Leave a comment