View more on these topics

Absolute return funds in the spotlight after outflows

After a series of high-profile outflows, deeper questions are being asked about the performance of absolute return funds.

The sector, which is celebrating its 10th anniversary this month, is broad and can include a variety of types of funds across asset classes, geographies and strategies.

The Investment Association simply stipulates funds within the sector must be managed with the aim of delivering positive returns in any market conditions; asset selection is at the discretion of the manager.

In 2013, the IA updated the name of the sector to Targeted Absolute Return, but many investors are still confused over how to pick funds in the space.

Hargreaves Lansdown senior analyst Laith Khalaf says: “What is important is what the fund does and explaining that clearly. That is what investors need to focus on.

“There’s a case for having a sub-sector within the sector but then it gets to a point where you’re proliferating sectors and things get confusing. What the focus should be on is what the fund is trying to do, how it is going about it and how successful it has been in achieving those goals. You can do that rather than referencing across the sector.”

Chelsea Financial services managing director Darius McDermott says: “I don’t care if a manager uses emerging market debt, long/short equity or trades bonds. It’s about how much alpha you are trying to get versus how much risk you are prepared to take.

“There are many different instruments in the sector so we simplify it into what the target return is and how much volatility you take on. When markets are difficult we find evidence to deny or support whether the fund has done what it says.”

Investment Insight: Does fund size affect performance?

The sector is clearly a popular choice with advisers and investors. In fact, some of the largest funds by size across all sectors are in Targeted Absolute Return. The £19.9bn Standard Life Investments Global Absolute Return Strategies fund, £12.4bn Invesco Perpetual Global Targeted Returns and £10.9bn Old Mutual Global Equity Absolute Return fund all sit in the sector. Despite this, February this year saw net retail outflows reach £148m.

One fund that has seen significant outflows in recent months is Gars as Aberdeen Standard Investments tries to stem the flight of assets.

Aberdeen Standard’s multi-asset investing investment specialist Christopher Nichols says: “It is worth remembering that Gars is a product designed to perform over a three-year time horizon and we’re confident that the underlying trends we have identified will bear fruit for the fund in due course.

“Given multi-asset remains a fast-growing market segment and the strength of franchise ASI has established in this field, it’s not unreasonable to assume a return to a more normalised flow profile over time.”

Funds in the sector must clearly state their objective and timeframe over which they aim to meet it, although this cannot be longer than three years, according to the IA.

The IA also provides monthly figures for each fund in the sector, which show how many times a fund has failed to deliver returns greater than zero after charges for a rolling 12-month period.

Investment Insight: The sectors at risk from capitalism criticism

The data shows three funds – Absolute Insight Currency, Kames UK Equity Absolute Return and Threadneedle Absolute Return Bond – have seen 24 successive negative periods, though they may still have met their target before charges.

However, not all funds in the sector are performing poorly. The Polar Capital UK Absolute Equity fund is the top performer over the year to the end of March, returning 37.8 per cent over one year.

It is difficult to compare the sector as there are so many types of funds with different geographic focuses. For example, the Old Mutual Global Equity Absolute Return fund’s asset allocation is vastly different to the Polar Capital fund. OMGI’s head of global equities Ian Heslop attributes the fund’s recent positive performance to a multitude of reasons including strong contributions from the consumer discretionary and technology sectors. In Q1 this year, the fund has seen positive returns from Asia Pacific, Europe and North America but Japan’s contribution was negative.

Khalaf says: “It’s not a sector you can slice and dice. You shouldn’t use a sector average of how it’s doing as it’s really just an average of a mishmash of numbers, and within that are a lot of different strategies at play.”

Hargreaves Lansdown only features one fund from the sector in its Wealth 150 list of fund picks, the Newton Real Return fund. “We have funds that are similar to it but just don’t sit in the Targeted Absolute Return sector. The Pyrford Global Total Return is similar in that it is conservatively managed but sits in the Flexible sector,” Khalaf adds.

McDermott says: “It is not easy to say ‘here are the three things you should look at’, so we look at how much return you are trying to make, how much risk, and volatility targets, and then have they physically done it when markets are weak or strong. If we find all that, then we consider them for our buy list.”

Adviser view

Tom Kean, managing director, Thameside Financial Planning

Some [absolute return funds] are remarkable in capturing all of the downside and none of the upside – they have morphed from what seemed like a half decent proposition to a bit of a dog. I fear some of us, myself included, were trying to be a bit too clever for our own good. It makes With Profit funds seem like good value for money, which ironically, they still are. Shame they were effectively regulated out of existence to all intents and purposes. We’ve had a few clients express dissatisfaction in recent months, but the notion of letting things recover only goes so far.

Recommended

1

Aberdeen Standard Investments closes Absolute Return Government Bond fund

Aberdeen Standard Investments is closing the Absolute Return Government Bond fund it acquired from Ignis. The Ignis Absolute Return Government Bond fund transferred to Standard Life Investments following the firm’s acquisition of Ignis Asset Management in 2014. The £149m fund has now been closed to further investment and will be wound up on 22 December […]

1

Are absolute return strategies still relevant?

In the past year absolute return funds have had their fair share of negative headlines, and big-name funds in the Investment Association’s Targeted Absolute Return sector have suffered outflows – notably Standard Life Investments Global Absolute Return Strategies (GARS). When the fund group reported its profits for 2016 at the start of this year the […]

Offshore amnesty could bring in 5bn

The Government’s amnesty for UK taxpayers with undisclosed offshore bank accounts could net the Treasury up to 5bn.

Newsletter

News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up

Comments

There are 4 comments at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. Sascha Klauss 2nd May 2018 at 11:25 am

    I’m launching a fund to take advantage of the outflows from Absolute Return and meet the needs of investors who think they want to invest but don’t want volatility or occasional falls in value.

    My fund is called the Klauss Inverse Mining Guaranteed Return fund. It works as follows: you give me your money, I dig a hole, and bury it. Then when you want to withdraw, I dig it up again and return your investment in full. This fund is guaranteed to never make a loss, and especially suited to investors who reap where they do not sow, and gather where they do not scatter seed.

    • Let’s not get too cynical!! An amusing proposition nonetheless! Chances are it would achieve at least median performance given the risks that abound. February’s pull back was just a ‘heads up’ for what is actually coming.

    • Nicholas Pleasure 2nd May 2018 at 12:33 pm

      I’m assuming that you are running with a 5% bid/offer spread?

  2. So, GARS is to be treated as a 3-year cycle? Well the past three years has produced a return of -1.25%,yet there’s still 20bn or so in it. Doesn’t say a lot for the advisers who recommended it or the inertia of their clients. I’ve yet to see any evidence that Absolute Return works – another invention of the fund management industry to be ashamed of. All imho, of course!

Leave a comment