View more on these topics

A consumer&#39s view

An important point barely touched on by Adair Turner in his Pensions Commission Report is the fact that incentives to encourage people to save for retirement will fail as long as individuals do not trust the savings institutions. And they don&#39t.

Research from the Consumers&#39 Association shows that this is an enormous hurdle for the industry to overcome, with only one in three prepared to believe that financial institutions are not about to rip them off.

The National Consumer Council makes a similar point, saying that the Commission&#39s three-pronged approach to future pensions policy is missing one vital ingredient – tackling the massive mistrust that will undermine any attempt to close the reported £57bn savings gap.

NCC research shows that the problem of trust extends to young and old alike and that gap includes the Government and employers, not just the pension and investment industry.

If the industry does not get its act together, it is in danger of finding itself overtaken by events. Just as the supermarkets, not oil companies, are now the biggest retailers of petrol, the traditional savings institutions could find themselves second best in the battle for investors&#39 money.

A typical example is the recent launch of Sainbury Bank&#39s new SaveBack scheme, due to be rolled out at 452 Sainsbury&#39s stores. Convenience is at least 50 per cent of the battle when you are trying to sell someone a financial product and Sainsbury&#39s SaveBack account deals with this problem brilliantly. Customers simply put money into their savings account by &#39swiping&#39 their debit card at the checkout till – similar to the way they can take money from their current accounts with Cashback.

In launching this product Sainsbury&#39s Bank has highlighted an important aspect in the challenge to close the savings gap. What is needed is not necessarily development of new products, but ways to make it easier for people to save. Research from Sainsbury&#39s indicates that around 12 million people would use a savings account like SaveBack if it were available in their local supermarket.

Of those who would use this type of service, 61 per cent said it was because of its convenience. One in two said that because they visited their supermarket on a regular basis they would be more likely to save, and 29 per cent said they would save more because of the trust they had in their supermarket.

With almost half the nation&#39s household shopping budgets being spent at supermarkets, this last point in particular ought to worry the life out of high street banks and other savings institutions.

Anyone in the business knows that Sainsbury&#39s Bank is a joint venture with HBOS. But the customers don&#39t know it and it is the Sainsbury&#39s brand that is the seller. In fairness to HBOS, it is also a trusted name, but you can&#39t get your groceries and petrol at Halifax or Bank of Scotland branches.

Moreover, the Consumers&#39 Association research shows that what people want from their savings – whether it&#39s a pension or not – is security and a guarantee that what they put in they will get back.

They are prepared to forego the potentially higher returns on equity-based products for the security of cash deposits. If Sainbury&#39s offered a pension wrapper to its SaveBack account, with the tax relief automatically granted, so that every £10 paid in automatically became £12.20 saved – and people could see it in their account – there is little doubt that more people could be persuaded to save for their retirement.

One of the serious omissions of the pensions industry is that there is no easily available pensions deposit account, which is exactly what the public is telling us it wants.

This is why the Government urgently needs to review the tax incentives given on pension savings ahead of the Pensions Commissions recommendations next autumn.

Much has been written about BOGOF – buy one get one free – and the Treasury should give this concept serious consideration. Why should the better off half of the population be the only ones to enjoy the tax subsidy given to pension savings, estimated at some £20bn a year?

If this were spread between the 28 million adults of working age, it would give everyone the opportunity to save £700 a year, with the Treasury contributing £700 a year per person. Who could resist the prospect of doubling their savings for doing nothing?


MCCB calls for reasons-why letters to be retained

The Mortgage Code Compliance Board has identified key issues for the industry after the FSA takes over the regulation of mortgages. Its final annual report published last week, the MCCB recommends that in all non-advised sales, consumers should be given a warning of the consequences of not obtaining advice. It also stated that the title […]

Piecing together pension jigsaw

As a fan of Fawlty Towers, I have many favourite lines and scenes but when Adair Turner published his paper, only one sprang to mind. Pension strategy in the country has resembled dodgems, where contact is neatly avoided by judicious spins of the wheel. Just as the actuarial brethren avoid decisions by pushing items on […]

Critical barrage for ABI over definitions and website

Leading medical figures have criticised the Association of British Insurers for outdated definitions on major critical illnesses and an inadequate website. At a conference organised by reinsurer GenRe, Imperial College professor of cancer medicine Karol Sikora described the ABI website as “trash”. One of his main criticisms is it does not define what critical illness […]

ScotProv pays out after probe on critical cover claim

Scottish Provident has made a U-turn on a critical-illness policy after it originally refused to pay out following an admin blunder. Rodney Neil Financial Services partner Rodney Neil says ScotProv refused to pay out when a client was diagnosed with multiple sclerosis, claiming there had been non-disclosure of a pre-existing condition. Now the insurer has […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment