View more on these topics

A bonus for personal injury payouts

With-profits, a concept roundly attacked in recent months, could come to the aid of victims of severe injury.

Personal injury lawyers usually agree on a lump-sum payment when settling claims. But they can opt for a structured settlement, where an annuity is purchased to provide the victim with an income. Unlike conventional annuities, the income is tax-free.

Both parties have to agree on this course of action, which must be approved by a judge. Judges have no power to order a structured settlement. However, the Lord Chancellor&#39s Department is in consultation with life offices and specialist IFAs, as well as lawyers, on the form that damages in personal injury cases could take in future.

The advantage of a structured settlement is that the damages cannot be frittered away and will continue to provide income for the lifetime of the injured person. An annuity can more appropriately replicate the victim&#39s income stream before the accident. In the US, where personal injury litigation has a much higher profile, structured settlements are the norm.

However, in recent years, the popularity of structured settlements has declined in line with falling annuity rates. Currently, structured settlements are used for only 1 per cent of the £163.5bn in personal liability claims settled each year.

Life offices that write annuities for structured settlements include Axa Sun Life, National Farmers Union Mutual Insurance Society, Scottish Widows, Standard Life and Windsor Life.

Windsor Life is run as a closed book with new business restricted to structured settlements. After consultation with the Inland Revenue, Windsor Life has recently launched a with-profits annuity which can offer more attractive rates of return than the conventional product. Whereas indexed annuities have an uplift of 2 to 3 per cent, Windsor Life&#39s with-profits annuity has a 4 per cent bonus applied for this year.

The assessment of damages can be done on a top-down basis, which involves calculating how much a certain purchase price will fetch in terms of income. More usually, the assessment will be on a bottom-up basis. Following an assessment by occupational therapists of the level of income required by the injured person, the appointed IFA approaches product providers to find out the payment needed to secure that income.

Windsor Life believes other providers are preparing similar products for the market although Standard Life, Scottish Widows and Axa Sun Life, the obvious contenders, all say they have no plans to launch an equivalent product. But IFA Chase de Vere partner Peter Jackson would like to see competition, believing monopoly in this sector to be unhealthy.

IFA Frenkel Topping compliance officer Richard Petrie believes Windsor Life&#39s initiative will reinvigorate interest in the structured settlement but he says the appropriateness of with-profits would, as always, depend on the individual&#39s attitude to risk.

The bulk of personal injury cases relate to medical negligence during the birth process and severe road traffic accidents. The average purchase price for a structured settlement annuity tends to be around £163.500,000. Axa Sun Life marketing manager Keith Middleton says Axa has quoted for cases as low as £163.25,000 although that is unusual. Government bodies, such as the NHS and Ministry of Defence, tend to self-fund but still secure the services of a specialist IFA to ascertain the levels that would be paid on the open market for presentation to the court.

This specialised sector of the market is dominated by a handful of IFAs. Structured settlement annuities were introduced by Frenkel Topping in 1989. What do IFAs need to operate in this potentially growing arena?

Petrie says IFAs need the approval of the Public Trust Office. Jackson suggests IFAs need to have specialist skills and knowledge of the legal system together with honed client skills to deal with traumatised clients from a variety of backgrounds. IFAs should also have taxation and trust qualifications, he adds.

Both IFAs believe this is a growing market that will be given new life by Windsor&#39s launch. Jackson says: “Structured settlements have lost their gloss recently but this will revive interest.”

The possibility of approving structured settlement annuities that would again be competitive has been welcomed by the legal profession. Master at the Court of Protection Denzil Lush has welcomed the introduction of the product.

But lawyers might need convincing of the suitability of with-profits. Jackson says this is where the benefits of independent financial advice will show through. Windsor Life product actuary Stuart Wilkinson admits: “It is a good product but poor timing.”

The Annuity Bureau head of marketing Dave Marlow says, as Windsor Life is not a regular life office in terms of its reporting, it is difficult to assess the financial health of the fund. The fact that Windsor does not offer annuities on the open market also makes it difficult to assess the product&#39s competitiveness, which is complicated by the lack of comparable products from other providers.

As the Windsor Life structured settlement annuity is attached to a closed with-profits fund, it would be managed on a more conservative basis.

Lack of new business could restrict cashflow, resulting in an asset allocation with a higher fixed-interest and lower equity component than would otherwise be the case.

Given the particular requirements of the severely injured and disabled, the financial advice and fact-finding has to be careful and painstaking. Jackson says it is important to assess each case individually. The portfolio would need to include the usual variety of deposits, National Savings and collective investments, configured in such a way as to provide for the needs of those affected.


Julian Gibbs

It is good to see GE Life, part of the biggest company in the world by market capitalisation, back in the high-income plan market. It has a clear goal – to be the first-choice provider of financial services and products to the over 50s – and these plans are an ideal investment for them. The […]

In sickness and in health

IFAs can expect to be targeted by providers of income protection policies in the near future. Income protection is low on the list of products currently sold by most IFAs but that might change in the post-stakeholder landscape. Given the withering of state provision and the corresponding onus on individuals to take care of themselves, […]

Selected for the debt trap

Years ago, when I was reduced to penury through naivete and the excesses of a former long-term relationship, I remember declaiming self-righteously at my sympathetic bank manager that credit is one of the ugliest words in the world. I still think that. Apart from the necessary evil of a mortgage, no one should willingly take […]

Firms could face £163.4bn fines over stakeholder

Legal & General claims the Government can expect to get nearly £163.4bn from UK businesses through stakeholder non-compliance. The figure represents what the life office calls a “windfall bonus” made up of thousands of £163.50,000 maximum fines imposed on employers for failing to offer their staff access to a stakeholder scheme by the October 8 […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm