View more on these topics

Ian McKenna: Think outside the box on affordable advice

Last week’s Finovate Spring conference shone a light on the new ways of working required to reach the mass market

The annual Silicon Valley Finovate show can always be relied upon for witnessing unconventional approaches to financial technology. The recent event lived up to that standard.

The first day saw some outstanding propositions from companies looking to help disadvantaged consumers, either directly or through charities.


MoneyAmigo is targeted at people with low income and poor credit to give them access to services including a debit card with unlimited 1 per cent cashback, 0 per cent APR 10-day loans of up to $100, unlimited tele-medical and dental services with no co-pay.

The company has identified that around 40 per cent of an individual’s expenditure can be processed via card payments, so that 1 per cent cashback can add up to a worthwhile amount in a year. Half of the 1 per cent goes straight back to the customer, with the other held in an account in which they can accumulate an emergency fund.

Ian McKenna: Tough FCA makes UK Europe’s leader in fintech

The banking app has a stunning user interface with no more than three clicks needed to access information or transfer money. While not all of the MoneyAmigo service would necessarily work in the UK, there are some valuable lessons in their approach.


Live, Give, Save – or Spave as it is also known – has evolved the micro-saving concept to embrace charitable giving. In addition to being able to add a small percentage to every payment a person makes using a given card in order to save, they can also nominate a charity they would want to give to in a similar way.

Adding small amounts to payments made is becoming an increasingly popular way to save. The Acorns service, which offers a similar proposition but without the philanthropy, has attracted more than three million accounts in the US and another 150,000 in Australia, where it recently rebranded as Raiz Invest.

There is no doubting the passion of Spave chief executive Susan Langer, who identifies female baby boomers, millennials and Hispanics as the groups most likely to embrace her approach to micro-saving in the US.

Clearly, people in the UK are thinking along similar lines. Online digital banking alternative Revolut also announced last week it is looking for partnerships with charities for its micro-savings service Vault.

Ian McKenna: 13 fintech projects advisers should watch

Since its launch in April, more than 150,000 UK consumers have saved more than £5m in spare change with it. I hear many people challenging the viability of the micro-savings model, but the number of small savers they are beginning to attract is significant.

That said, Spave has a global patent on the process of matching micro-savings with charitable donations, so Revolut may have Hobson’s choice here when it comes to partners.

Status Money

The compelling presentations of the second day were those that focused on how consumers can better manage their day-to-day money. In doing this, they are given more capacity to save in the long term.

Status Money pulls together information on income, spending, debt, net worth investments, retirement savings and credit score from a range of data sources.

The new technology could make firms like Moneysupermarket and Compare The Market obsolete

It enables consumers to compare their personal situation with millions like them and obtain algorithmic recommendations to help them make the right financial decisions.

In creating the analysis, Status Money tells me it has access to financial data covering approximately 5 per cent of the US population. I should stress other consumers’ data is anonymised, so there is no confidentiality risk.

Ian McKenna at Finovate: Home-grown fintech players making their mark in US

It comes up with actionable insights to help consumers understand when and where they can find better value products.

Harnessing data in this way has huge potential to improve customer outcomes and could transform the aggregator market. It might make companies like Moneysupermarket and Compare The Market obsolete; or, alternatively, such firms could use this technology to evolve their proposition further.


Wealthucare is an algorithm-driven financial planning service designed to be delivered via employers.

As soon as a user starts to put in data, the service begins giving simple financial planning type recommendations and helps them build financial goals.

At a cost $15 per employee per month, it is easy to see how a UK version could be covered within the tax-free financial advice allowance.

While the above may not seem immediately relevant to traditional advice, we do need to find new ways of working if we are to make it affordable for the masses. The above can teach us important lessons.

Ian McKenna is director at Finance & Technology Research Centre


FCA logo new 620x430.jpg

Robos under fire over suitability and disclosure failings

Robo firms’ shortcomings around suitability, fee disclosure and identifying vulnerable clients have been highlighted in findings from an FCA review today. The regulator reviewed seven firms offering online discretionary investment management services and three firms giving automated advice. The FCA says service and fee-related disclosures at most online discretionary investment management firms in its sample […]


National adviser offers DB transfer robo-paraplanner

National adviser Mercer Jelf Financial Planning is offering a defined benefit robo-paraplanner to its customers. Mercer UK teamed up with robo-advice platform Wealth Wizards to launch the service. Wealth Wizards launched its white-labelled robo-paraplanner tool, trialled with LV=, in May last year. Robo-paraplanner launches for workplace pensions The advice planner works on a triage basis […]


Barclays rolls back on robo-advice plans

Barclays has rolled back on plans to launch a robo-advice service, Money Marketing understands. The bank launched a new self-directed investment platform, Smart Investor, in August last year. Sources tell Money Marketing that the bank was also planning to complement this with a hybrid advice offering that would combine online services with a face-to-face element, […]


Standard Life to compensate over botched pension collections

Standard Life must compensate a client for failing to collect regular pension contributions from their bank account. The upheld Financial Ombudsman Service decision says Ms M consolidated her pensions into one scheme with Standard Life in 2015, and drew down 25 per cent of the fund to repay outstanding debts. In order to help replenish […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment