View more on these topics

Platforum: Piecing together the vertical integration puzzle

hopkins

Vertical integration, a term much bandied about, is a devil’s child to some and a saving grace to others. It is the merging together of two or more businesses that are up or downstream from each other, in that they are further or closer to the end customer. Old Mutual Wealth customer director Carlton Hood made an excellent case for it in Money Marketing recently, although he prefers the term “both/and”.

“We want to be the best provider we can be in the advice network, asset management and platform markets. We have to excel separately but we’d also like those pieces to fit together as a whole ranked as the sum of all its parts,” he said.

Others, however, disagree. For example, director of Adviser Home Brendan Llewellyn does not believe all the links in the chain can be equally strong.

We prefer to think of the various pieces of the investment advice value chain as a puzzle. In our recent Adviser Guide, we published a simple graphic (see left/right) to show the various parts of the puzzle. Different firms offer different pieces, with Standard Life and Old Mutual joining up most pieces. Offering various pieces of the value chain can make business sense.

In the 1980s and 1990s, life insurance companies’ direct sales forces thrived and then died under the weight of falling margins, rising compliance and training costs and a succession of misselling scandals. More recently, some have been spectacularly profitable (notably St James’s Place) but others have foundered (for example, Friends Life’s ownership of the large adviser network Sesame).

Whatever you think of vertical integration, it is not easy to pull off. The idea of buying a platform that you then use to flog your funds sounds great. But the reality of trying to get the system, pricing and all the other tricky ducks in a row is a different matter.

Platforum analysis of the products advisers use shows a strong relationship between platform use and choice of multi-manager fund. Advisers are roughly twice as likely to use a platform’s multi-manager fund if they also use the platform. We ran a similiar analysis of the use of model portfolios and found a similar result.

We all knew that a vertical integration (or “both/and”) strategy would pay dividends – supporting the low margin platform business with other higher margin activiites. And bringing together various pieces of the puzzle perhaps makes life easier for the adviser.

But vertical integration is not the only way to win at this game. Transact, a decidedly independent player, grew 7.8 per cent for the quarter, a rate that is only a hair’s breadth below average for the market. Considering that Transact does not have off- platform assets to convert, this is a pretty healthy growth rate.

Vertical integration is an interesting debate but pensions are more front and centre for financial advisers. We are already seeing a shift in assets to pension wrappers and expect that to continue. Aegon and James Hay in particular benefited from the pension changes in their Q1 results. In our next Adviser Guide (out in August), we will be taking a closer look at the aftermath of pension freedoms day. We will be fielding our quarterly survey in the next couple of weeks and would welcome your take on how the pension reforms are changing your business. Email me at: heather@platforum.co.uk.

Heather Hopkins is research director at Platforum

Recommended

dankemp

Morningstar IM appoints Kemp as CIO for EMEA

Dan Kemp, the Morningstar Investment Management EMEA co-head of investment consulting and portfolio management, has been appointed as chief investment officer at the firm. Kemp, who joined Morningstar a year ago, will replace and report to Daniel Needham, who became president and chief investment officer for Morningstar Investment Management in January 2015. Before Morningstar, Kemp […]

Boardroom-Hire-Hiring-Appointment-General-700x450.jpg

Deutsche Bank shares jump after CEO exits

Shares in Deutsche Bank have risen on the news that its co-chief executives have quit to be replaced by a new, solo chief executive. Anshu Jain and Jürgen Fitschen said yesterday they would step down from the joint chief executive role amid a series of problems at the bank. Jain will leave at the end […]

Chamberlain-Simon-Succession-2013-700.png

Succession Group acquires IFA for £2.9m

Succession Group has acquired independent advice firm DNG Financial Solutions for £2.9m. DNG Financial Solutions has offices in Daventry and Northampton. The deal, which is subject to FCA approval, is Succession Group’s 14th acquisition. Succession Group chief executive Simon Chamberlain says: “Our proven consolidation and acquisition model ensures rapid integration of member firms and provides […]

Chris Davies: Are insistent clients a dilemma or an opportunity?

My travels over the last month have taken me all over the country and there seems to be only one topic raising its head on a consistent basis: insistent clients determined to transfer from defined benefit to defined contribution schemes. We are only two months into the new pension freedom regime yet there has already […]

Tree - thumbnail

The politics of healthcare

Healthcare is already one of the key battlefields in May’s general election, with each of the main parties committing to deliver improvements to the NHS and public health.

Newsletter

News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up

Comments

There is one comment at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. Anthony Morrow 9th June 2015 at 5:12 pm

    I think vertical integration from product providers will really pay dividends when the momentum on platform assets slows in 2017/18 as the migration of back-book is complete. Whilst platforms such as Transact will continue to enjoy growth for the time being there has to be a point where this will slow as the stickiness of assets bites. At this point growth targets have to be achieved by either gaining a bigger share of the asset and/or controlling the flows from advisers that are being written. A further tactic that could be used, if other industry experiences are to be repeated, is that the larger players simply compress price to an extent that the smaller players cannot cope with in an environment where there isn’t a natural inflow of assets.The big question is how will platforms maintain their growth from 2018 onwards? If they don’t have a decent answer to that then that will impact on exit aspirations as we have already seen.

Leave a comment