View more on these topics

&#39We should harness IFAs&#39 strength&#39

Anne Sparrowhawk

Sparrowhawk Financial Planning,

East Grinstead,


Q: Given that there must be a major concern within the Government that we have an aging population insufficiently prepared to fund for its needs in retirement, why does the Government not harness the expertise and experience of professional IFAs and work with them to encourage the savings habit within the UK?

A. Clearly promoting mass-market savings is an important and desirable goal and the work of my review has this closely in mind. It is clear to me that the structure and workings of the retail financial services industry have a direct and important impact upon the propensity to save in this country. I am not yet in a position to say how the resources of all sectors of the industry, IFAs included, can best be harnessed to further this goal.

Jason Georgiou

Little & Georgiou IFA


West Yorks

Q: We already have disclosure of commission and key features&#39 documents showing early surrender or transfer values and also the facility to reduce commission and improve the terms to the investor. Can we not, therefore, leave it to the investor to decide whether he thinks the charges currently levied are value for money?

A: Ultimately, the only person who can decide whether a service represents good value for money is the consumer. However, there is evidence that many investors are not clear about what the charges are or even who is paying them and a widespread concern exists that the present disclosure regime may not be particularly effective.

There are also interesting questions to be posed about the ability of the average consumer to form and act in a timely way upon judgements about value received. That is why I believe this to be an area that warrants further investigation.

Gill Cardy

Professional Partnerships,


Q. To what extent does your project “access all areas?” And to what extent do you feel that industry vested interests will mitigate against successful implementation of the objectives you have outlined for investigation?

A: I have a broad remit, which is set out at the front of my consultation document, and I have a clear understanding with the Government that there are no areas that are “off limits”.

The industry has responded very positively to the review to date and recognises the objectives of efficiency and consumers being well served are clearly in its best longterm interests.

Inevitably, there will be proposals arising from this review with which certain industry participants will disagree, in which case, there will be debate. But that is a normal part of this sort of process.

David Yorke

David Yorke Financial Planning Strategies,

Philipstoun, West Lothian

Q: As an industry, we are continually assured that you are independent minded and are “your own man” and so I would address the following question – what is the motivation behind yet another report on my industry and what assurances do we have regarding its objectivity?

A: The proposal for the review was made by the Myners review of institutional investment and, if you want the full thinking behind it, you would need to read the chapter of the Myners report dealing with life insurance.

But briefly, Myners, in seeking to understand investment decision-making by institutional investors, found a number of factors, such as the end-consumer&#39s lack of understanding, distorted competition in the retail savings market.

The Myners review therefore concluded that it could not be assumed that the competitive process was necessarily delivering efficient allocation of capital or the right outcomes for consumers and therefore a further review was necessary. As far as my objectivity is concerned, I can assure you I have no hidden agenda either of my own or from the Government and I have an entirely open mind about the possible conclusions I might reach.

Chris Wagstaff

Investment Matters,



Q: Are you seeking to make AFPC G70 paper or UKSIP Investment Management Certificate compulsory for the conduct of certain types of investment business by IFAs or is your intention to simply encourage IFAs to take a more proactive interest in the subject of investment at a generic level?

A. It will be some considerable time before I am able to formulate definite views on such a question.

Lee Robertson

Investment Quorum,


Q: It appears that you are unhappy with the current levels of investment knowledge displayed by IFAs. Bearing in mind we have seen many fund management groups get it disastrously wrong by launching technology and other specialist funds, do you therefore think it appropriate to demand investment knowledge of IFAs&#39 superior to that of fund managers and current investment knowledge benchmark examinations, particularly when you consider that most IFAs work in the retail end of the industry in a generalist capacity and have to make decisions based upon available research, much of which is published directly or indirectly by the product providers?

A: I have certainly never suggested that IFAs should have superior investment knowledge to fund managers or even the same knowledge. The role of IFAs and their involvement in investment is very different to fund managers. But it is equally the case that the investment content of the FPC is low and many people believe this is insufficient. While I am keen to hear all sides of this debate, this is clearly an issue that I have to take seriously.


Inside edge

“Is increasing revenue the key business issue for IFAs rather than reducing costs?”No doubt many readers will recognise this as one of the questions posed by the Sandler review. It is indeed an important question and how it is interpreted is even more important. But let&#39s say any provider in the industry was to ask […]

NU adds its strength to help lift the cap

Norwich Union is hoping to use its financial muscle and market share to lobby the Government to review the 1 per cent cap on stakeholder.NU took £42m of individual stakeholder business on an equivalent premium income basis for the nine months to September 30, out of £168m overall individual business. Group stakeholder sales totalled £21m […]

Davies tells MPs to blame arrogant Equitable, not FSA

FSA chairman Howard Davies slammed the Equitable Life board this week over its “arrogant superiority”and resistance to the regulator&#39s attempts to intervene in the guaranteed annuity rate debacle.Speaking to the Parliamentary Treasury select committee this week, Davies said the troubled life office did not act in a manner expected. It did not consult or even […]

LifeSearch targeting IFAs with new service

Term insurance broker LifeSearch has set up a dedicated service which it says will give IFAs access to the most competitive premium terms.IFAs can refer regular non-regulated term insurance, life cover, critical-illness cover and permanent health insurance business to the LifeSearch service and keep half the commission earned on each sale.LifeSearch employs three FPC3-qualified advisers […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm