View more on these topics

&#39PPI investments fail stake criteria&#39

Pooled pension investments will fail the stakeholder crit^_eria, according

to leading
fund managers.

The warning comes from the chairman of Autif&#39s pensions advisory group

Fiach Maguire, who says most collective investments, such as unit trusts,

investment trusts and Oeics, fall foul of the 1 per cent charge cap

governing stakeholder.

Collective investments generally have initial charges of up to 6 per cent

plus an annual management charge in excess of 1 per cent.

The Treasury had proposed PPI as an investment wrapper that would

be compatible with stakeholder, offering investors the

opportunity to diversify from
the traditional life office

funds by investing
in a full range of unit and investment trusts.

Maguire, who is also pensions development director at Perpetual, says

other companies believe that because of the charging structure of these

investments, provi-
ders would be extremely unlikely to launch a

of unit trusts mirroring its existing range purely to fit within


He says: “If you put the PPI wrapper around existing unit trusts, by

definition it just won&#39t meet the stakeholder criteria. Virtually all unit

trusts are written on a bid/offer spread basis and that just will not meet

the standard.

“I cannot see too many people launching a brand new range of unit trusts

just to
mirror their existing range.”

Gartmore head of retail pensions Nick Hodges says:
“I think that it

will be impossible for most providers to offer PPI based on the 1 per cent

charging structure under stakeholder.

“The Government just does not understand the dynamics and is trying to

squeeze all the flexibility it wants into a 1 per cent charge and it does

not fit.”

A Treasury spokesman says: “We have always said that PPI and stakeholder

would be entirely compatible and would run alongside each other. That is

part of the reason we delayed their launch.

“If providers do not want
to offer them within stakeholder criteria,

then it is
a matter for them.”

The Government&#39s latest Green Paper on housing looks set to bring a

healthy influx of new customers to the housebuying market.

The consultation paper outlines a new “starter home initiative” aiming to

provide assistance for key workers, including nurses and teachers, which

could include the possibility of interest-free loans.

The paper was issued last week with the aim of improving the provision,

maintenance and management of homes.

Lenders have welcomed the move, saying it could lead to a whole new

market, previously exc^_luded from housebuying, to need the services of

lenders and mortgage intermediaries.

Legal & General marketing manager (housing market) Richard Verdin says: “I

would imagine the Government could operate the assistance in the same way

as Miras, allowing borrowers to claim against their mortgage product. This

could be a new set of customers for lenders and IFAs which has to be good


Interested parties have until July 31 to respond to the plans.


Nuki&#39s Eye

Don&#39t you just love it when the banks get it wrong. For months now, aswell of popular discontent has been building against the high-streetbanks. As I said in this column a month ago, it was only a matter of timebefore the tidal wave broke, crushing the bad guys and leaving the restgasping for air in […]

Setting up stakeholder

I run a family business which employs 50 staff. We are consideringestablishing a pension scheme but I am concerned about the implications ofstakeholder. Please explain how these will affect my business and set outwhat my options are. If no satisfactory alternative to stakeholder exists for employees, itwill be compulsory for the employer to offer a […]

Societies&#39 lending at two-year high

Building society mortgage lending hit a two-year high in March.Building Societies Association figures show gross lending by societiestotalled 2.4bn in March compared with 1.45bn in February.Approvals, or loans agreed but not yet made, increased by more than 50per cent to 3.38bn from 2bn in February, the highest fig^_ure in over twoyears.The growth of societies is […]

What now for mutual firms?

The mutual status of insurers provokes feverish media speculation but theoffices themselves are more concerned with expansion and offering solidproducts.Three Scottish life offices – Scottish Provident, Scottish Life and, ofcourse, Standard Life – have been the subject of speculation.In all three cases, the arguments for and against demutualisation aredifferent.Life industry analyst Ned Cazalet stresses that […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm