View more on these topics

&#39Myners report conflicts with stakeholder goals&#39

The Government is being accused of sending contradictory messages to the pen- sion industry through the Myners report and the bench- marking of stakeholder fund performance.

Providers claim the criteria set out by Paul Myners for his report into institutional investment conflicts with Government objectives in the stakeholder market.

Gartmore chairman Myners was commissioned by Chancellor Gordon Brown to conduct a review into why big institutional investors such as pension funds fail to invest in smaller companies and venture capital, preferring to invest in bigger companies.

But providers claim the Government&#39s proposals for benchmarking stakeholder funds actively encourage them to avoid any risk, lead- ing them to invest in bigger companies.

Firms will be encouraged to follow the crowd in their investment strategies for fear of falling outside the benchmark. The benchmark will excluse the best 20 per cent and worst 20 per cent of funds.

Another bone of contention highlighted by life offices concerns investment objectives. Myners suggests investors should take a longer-term view of at least 10 years. But under benchmarking, firms will be assessed on their performance over just one year.

Scottish Equitable pensions development manager Steve Cameron says: “Myners is trying to encourage invest- ment horizons of 10 years but, under stakeholder, benchmarking firms will be judged on their performance after just one year.

“Also, investment benchmarking proposals under stakeholder will actually discourage anyone from taking an investment decision away from the norm.

“Together, these are two ways in which the proposals are encouraging what Myners aims to discourage.”

Recommended

Mortgage packager announces 45 per cent growth

Mortgage Next announces it has facilitated almost £1.2bn in lending in the financial year ending in March.The four-year-old packager says these figures represent almost a 45 per cent increase on the previous year&#39s results.The company processed 19,000 mortgage applications last year, divided roughly half between the main and sub-prime sectors. The average loan size was […]

Ride the ethical wave

New legislation on socially responsible investment brings to mind the analogy of comparing the reputation of the pension industry to surfing, where both teeter on the crest of a wave.Surfing is as spectacular in its moments of failure as it is in success. One moment the surfer is a sublime creature riding a breaker but […]

3i posts 9 per cent profit growth

The UK largest venture capital 3i announces its profits for the year ending March 31 are up 9 per cent from just under £110 to £119. The company also enjoyed a 44 per cent increase in total return on shareholder funds. Its funds rose in value from £3.6bn to £5.2bn. In the recently concluded fiscal […]

Nottingham offers new investment account

Nottingham Building Society is offering a new fixed rate investment account with a 7.15 per cent annual interest rate guaranteed through June 2001. The minimum investment in the product is £2,500 or £1,000 for existing Nottingham customers and a maximum investment of £250,000. Investors have the option of increasing their stake while the account is […]

Newsletter

News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up

Comments

    Leave a comment