View more on these topics

&#39Final-salary plans will become Jurassic perk&#39

The Inland Revenue&#39s proposals for a single pension tax regime effectively rubberstamps the death of final-salary schemes, according advisers and product providers.

They argue that the Revenue&#39s proposals map out a clear future for defined-contribution schemes with final-salary schemes existing as a subset within a money-purchase framework.

The industry has generally welcomed the Revenue&#39s proposals as progress towards true simplification but some are warning that a consequence of moving from eight tax regimes to a single regime will be the sidelining of defined-benefit schemes.

Clerical Medical pension strategy manager Nigel Stammers says: “Under the Inland Revenue proposals, the final-salary regime becomes a dinosaur. The Government says that it is neutral on final salary versus money purchase but the fact that the Revenue is talking exclusively in the language of money purchase means that final salary will be increasingly marginalised.”

Richard Jacobs Pension & Trustee Services director Richard Jacobs says: “With this change of mindset, the Government is rubberstamping the demise of final-salary schemes. The Government is saying the new regime will be money-purchase and final salary is dead except for those idiots that want to keep it. The Revenue proposals give Government backing to killing off final-salary schemes rather than supporting them.”

A Treasury spokesman says: “We have always said that defined contribution is not necessarily inferior to defined benefit. But there is no tacit admission of any preference for defined contribution over defined benefit in these proposals.”


Have your say on Green Paper

The Pensions Green Paper – week twoMoney Marketing and Taxbriefs are teaming up to invite readers to put their views on the Government&#39s new Pensions Green Paper and the Inland Revenue&#39s tax paper by answering the questions listed here on the right.Taxbriefs will then put your views to the Secretary of State for Work and […]

Newcastle brings out third property bond

Newcastle Building Society has brought out the third issue of its guaranteed property bond. The bond works in a similar way to guaranteed equity bonds that are linked to stockmarket indices, but it is linked to the performance of the Halifax House Price Index for five years. To calculate the final returns, the level of […]

You haven&#39t given trees a chance, says FSA&#39s Severn

Stakeholder pension decision trees cannot be written off as a failure just because most of the industry has chosen not to use them, according to the FSA.Writing in this week&#39s issue of Money Marketing, FSA head of retail projects David Severn says that although, “on the whole”, the industry has opted not to employ decision […]

Worst year for pension funds since 1974

The value of company pension funds fell by 14 per cent in 2002, the worst single year&#39s fall since 1974, according to a survey of two thirds of occupational schemes by WM Company, a division of Deutsche Bank. The value of pension scheme funds has now fallen by 24.6 per cent over the last three […]

Martin Foden discusses how convenience is affecting the construction of fixed income portfolios

In this short video, Martin Foden, head of credit research at Royal London Asset Management, discusses how convenience is affecting the construction of fixed income portfolios. Watch the video in full The value of investments and the income from them is not guaranteed and may go down as well as up and investors may not […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment