View more on these topics

Steve Webb: Take FCA non-workplace pensions consultation more seriously

The actions of regulators can have a profound impact on advisers, providers and clients, but all too often we engage too late in the day to shape the final decisions.

With so much regulatory activity to keep on top of, the understandable priority is implementing the latest things that must be done now, rather than responding to early stage consultation documents.

But in my experience on the other side of the fence, regulators (and government departments) start to firm up their views on issues very early on – sometimes even at the point when they are writing the consultation document.

With this in mind, it is vitally important those who care about the future of our sector engage with regulators as soon as an issue appears on their radar.

FCA puts non-workplace pension competition under microscope

A case in point is the FCA’s recently published consultation into competition in non-workplace pensions. This primarily covers individual personal pensions, stakeholder pensions and Sipps, but also mentions things like retirement annuity contracts, additional voluntary contributions and so on.

When I have mentioned this topic in talks to advisers in recent weeks, I have sensed a collective yawn about yet another FCA consultation. But as the document itself points out, the non-workplace pensions market covers around £400bn of assets and a diverse range of products, with about 40 per cent of sales being on an advised basis. If the FCA decided to change the rules of the game in this space, we would all notice.

While the FCA is at pains to point out it understands that the workplace pensions market is different from the non-workplace market, most of this consultation document is asking the question as to how far the problems it has seen in the past (high charges, poor governance, disengaged savers, etc) are replicated in the non-workplace sector.

It is concerned that people can get stuck in legacy investments where costs have not fallen, which are not regularly reviewed and where even those who consider switching may be discouraged by the presence of exit penalties of various sorts.

Nic Cicutti: FCA must up sense of urgency on non-workplace pensions

Although the FCA tries not to rush to policy conclusions in this early consultation document, it is not hard to read between the lines as to its initial thinking. For example, we could easily see the role of independent governance committees expanded to cover some non-workplace pensions, and there is likely to be a lot more scrutiny of charges on legacy products.

The FCA is asking for views on its initial document by 27 April and has promised to come back with some clearer ideas by the end of the year.

Something tells me the outcome of this review will be a hot topic among advisers and I would encourage anyone who might be affected to make sure they feed in their views before the regulator’s becomes too firmly entrenched.

Steve Webb is director of policy at Royal London


File image of graph showing stocks and share prices rise and fall

SimplyBiz enters Aim market at 170p a share

Support service provider SimplyBiz has completed its listing on the London Stock Exchange. SimplyBiz, which also offers its own range of funds and panel services to providers, issued its entire share capital to the Aim market at 8am today. With a placing price of 170p per share, the firm has achieved a market capitalisation of […]

Protection Watch: Aviva’s relevant life update and paying out on claims

Protection Review chief executive Kevin Carr looks at recent market events Should we pay more claims? According to The Syndicate 2018 research, the public have fairly low expectations that insurers will pay claims. However, many people strongly believe that more claims should be paid, sometimes even in the event of non-disclosure. Some 80 per cent […]


Top tips ahead of CII R06 and AF5 exam sittings

Last-minute preparation for the next round starting on 16 April In order to complete the level 6 Advanced Diploma in Financial Planning, a student must pass the compulsory unit AF5: Financial Planning Process. Anyone that holds the level 4 Diploma in Regulated Financial Planning will already have passed R06: Financial Planning Practice. These exams do […]


Abraham Okusanya: Small advice firms are far from dead

Small firms have never been busier, more profitable and optimistic about the future In 1897, the New York Journal reported that American writer Mark Twain was dead. In fact, it was his cousin who had perished. This prompted Twain to politely inform the paper “the reports of my death are greatly exaggerated”. You would be […]

Tax year-end planning for annual allowance

Last tax year-end there was a lot to think about in relation to planning. The introduction of the tapered annual allowance and the implications of moving to a fixed pension input period, the reduction in the lifetime allowance and potentially applying for protection, and the concern about changes to tax relief, to name a few. […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment