View more on these topics

Solving the tax year-end pension planning puzzle

With 5 April fast approaching, advisers are busy swotting up on allowances and the most tax-efficient ways to invest clients’ retirement savings

There is nothing like a deadline to focus the mind and spur people into action. Although advisers deal with tax planning throughout the year, the run-up to 5 April triggers a rush to use up various annual allowances or claim exemptions and reliefs before the new tax year.

So what are advisers doing for their clients at this time of the year from a retirement planning perspective and what are the biggest challenges?

Using allowances

There are various allowances that can be used to help clients build their retirement pots faster. As Mattioli Woods team director Greg Ward points out, higher rate taxpayers can potentially save for retirement 40 per cent faster if they save into their pension rather than outside it due to tax relief.

“You can put up to £40,000 a year into a pension and you can also carry forward for the last three tax years, but you will only get tax relief on as much as you have in earnings. So if you earn £30,000 a year you will only get tax relief on £30,000,” he says.

However, St James’s Place divisional director for development and technical consultancy Tony Mudd warns that there’s no guarantee that the current generous rates of tax relief will be maintained in future. He suggests fully utilising annual allowances for this tax year to make the most of the tax breaks on offer.

Mazars partner and head of financial planning Sarah Lord points to Isa contributions as a relatively straightforward additional tool. “It is as simple as clarifying with the client as to whether they have used their allowance elsewhere during the tax year. We would always recommend that people don’t leave Isa contributions to the end of the tax year, to make best use of the tax-efficient wrapper and tax-free investment growth,” she says.

Why you need to keep on top of the details for tax planning success

Some advisers find that clients are aware of the allowances but do not understand how they can benefit from them. “They use the allowances for the sake of it, without a real reason. But give them a reason and it makes a difference,” says Atrium Financial managing director Noor Uddin.

“Three weeks ago I saw a new client who is an additional rate taxpayer. He had not made much use of his pension and Isa allowances but has a lot of investment in property.”

Uddin spoke to the client about his likely tax bill and the client asked how it could be reduced. “We put £40,000 in his pension, used his Isa allowance and, as he’s married, he could use his wife’s Isa allowance as well. He was on the border between additional and higher rate taxpayer, so we were able to bring that down to the higher rate band and reduce his tax bill by £45,000,” he says.

Running through other things that advisers should tick off, Altus Consulting head of retirement strategy Jon Dean suggests checking whether clients who have had absences from work, such as careers breaks to raise children, have a complete record of National Insurance contributions.

“Filling in missing years to qualify for the full state pension will get more expensive from 6 April,” he says. “Remember the lifetime allowance rises from £1.03m to £1.055m – clients requesting crystallisation who may be impacted by the LTA may prefer to defer taking benefits until after 5 April. And self-employed clients may wish to defer taking taxable income until after 5 April, as both personal allowances and higher-rate tax thresholds in England, Wales and Norther Ireland are increasing by more than inflation.”

Tax traps

In an ideal world, everyone would be able to maximise their pensions contributions. However, in the real world there are tax traps such as the tapered annual allowance, which create complications for pension savers.

“The £40,000 annual pension allowance might be lower if you earn over £110,000 a year, which includes salary bonus and benefits in kind, rental income. If this figure – your threshold income – is above £110,000 you would need to check your adjusted income, which is your threshold income plus your employer pension contribution,” explains Ward. “If your adjusted income is over £150,000, you lose £1 of your pension allowance for every £2 of adjusted income over £150,000, to a maximum of £30,000.”

Adviser view

Jason Eldrid
Director, Sheraton Financial Planning

Much of this is standard financial planning, but we have some clients who are planning now for the next tax year because of changes to Residence Relief and letting relief in 2020.

We flagged this up in their annual reviews, so they will sell their buy-to-lets in the next six to nine months because of the tax changes. Most of the clients we deal with are already retired, so contributions are less of an issue. The financial planning software we use – Truth – has a detailed lifetime allowance calculator and that picks up any issues at annual reviews rather than the end of the tax year. If the client is close to the limit, we will have a discussion.

Rachel Vahey: Tackling the tapered annual allowance

Making a personal pension contribution can reduce threshold income to below £110,000, so clients would not need to move on to the adjusted income test and tapering would not apply,

“High earners and pension contributions is very complex. People innocently say, for example, ‘my PAYE income is £140,000 so I’m not going to be affected’. But the way tapering works is adding up that income, and any other income or rent, and pension contributions from employers and that is the magic number,” says Clifton Wealth group financial planning director Anthony Carty.

“But the most challenging scenario is the self-employed. In some cases, they are uncertain as to what their taxable income – or net profit – is. Their pension contributions are paid from this and it gets to the point where they are almost sticking a finger in the air saying they think their net profit is going to be this.”

Lord says pension contributions are far from straightforward given the complexity around the tapered annual allowance and the carry forward rules.

“This year is the last year that those affected by the tapered annual allowance can make use of carrying forward the full £40,000 so it is important to consider whether an individual can be making use of this allowance by maximising this year’s contribution and then looking to carry forward allowance from 2015/2016,” she says.

Pension contributions are also subject to the lifetime limit, which is something advisers track throughout the year. “Hitting the lifetime allowance is not a problem that occurs overnight and advisers should be alerted to it early. If someone has a pension pot of over £500,000 or £600,000, that conversation becomes a priority,” says Uddin.

“When you get to around £850,000 you need to explore other avenues such as Isas, so you benefit from still being invested.”

‘Catastrophic’ lifetime allowance bills could result from GMP equalisation

Adviser view

Fiona Tait
Technical specialist, Intelligent Pensions

Our most frequently received question is “what is the maximum amount I can put into my pension?”. This is a complicated question and it requires a considerable amount of information for us to be able to provide an accurate response. Often the query is raised just a few weeks before the tax year end and it becomes a race against time to collect the figures.

All of this is further complicated for high net worth individuals who may be subject to the annual allowance taper. For carry forward exercises we need not just the last three years’ contributions, but also confirmation of any previous carry forward exercises, which may in turn require contribution records from even earlier years from which the annual allowance was carried forward.

Alternatives to pensions

As mentioned, Isas are commonly used alongside a pension and for some clients, such as those who are nearing their lifetime allowance, venture capital trusts or enterprise investment schemes provide a tax-efficient, albeit higher-risk, alternative savings option.

Commentators point out that the interest rate of cash Isas is unattractive relative to inflation. “With this in mind, advisers should recommend their client invest their Isa allowance for the long term – in assets offering the scope for attractive levels of income and capital growth, which will give them a better chance of maximising the tax-saving opportunities on offer,” says Mudd.

Octopus Investments head of tax products Paul Latham suggests investing in IHT-friendly products.

“You can invest in Aim within an Isa wrapper. If you invest in listed companies that qualify for business property relief and hold them for two years, they are not liable for inheritance tax.”

VCTs can be considered to reduce tax liabilities on dividends and pension withdrawals. “Of course, clients need to be comfortable with the higher risks of VCT investing and understand that it is an investment for a minimum of five years,” says Latham.

However, Lord says Mazars is seeing less capacity in VCT and EIS offerings this year.

“For clients where either of these options are appropriate it has proved more challenging to find the right investments,” she says.


SimplyBiz acquires Defaqto

Support service provider SimplyBiz has begun to deploy some of the funds raised from its stock market float with a deal to buy ratings and technology business Defaqto. SimplyBiz will pay £74.3m to acquire the entire issued share capital of Regulus Topco Limited, Defaqto’s parent. On completion, Defaqto will have £3.4m in cash on its […]


Canada Life: 68% of clients access pensions without an adviser

Sixty-eight per cent of people who are accessing their pension are not currently using a financial adviser says provider Canada Life. The finding is from a study based on research done in March by Opinium among 505 respondents aged over 55 who have accessed their pensions from April 2015. It sheds light on how people […]

DB transfer values ride out turbulent February

Pension transfer values remained unchanged in February, despite an initial jump. There was a broad increase throughout the start of the month, but a sharp drop later in February left the XPS Pensions Group Transfer Value Index unchanged over the period. The index, which uses the example of a defined benefit scheme to a 64-year-old […]

The unconventional becomes the norm

Caspar Rock, Chief Investment Officer, and Richard Jeffrey, Chief Economist, review the state of the economic landscape. It started with an unconventional recession, one that emanated from a near collapse in the financial system but which, in some larger economies, resulted in a comparatively modest increase in unemployment. Then we had unconventional monetary policy, encompassing […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm