View more on these topics

Steve Webb: Without shopping around rules cash for annuities plan could backfire


April saw the launch of no fewer than three separate consultations about the next big change to the retirement landscape – the introduction of a secondary annuity market due to be implemented next year. So, will this be an exciting new freedom for older people or is it a disaster waiting to happen?

Of most interest is the FCA consultation, which is open until 21 June. The FCA envisages three different parties to be regulated in this new market: annuity providers who might “buy back” their own annuities, other firms that might directly buy annuities and those that act as market intermediaries, such as brokers. The regulator says its aim is to protect consumers while “promoting effective competition”.

One of the key challenges of this new market is that it is very difficult to value an annuity in payment and consumers are unlikely to be in a position to know what is a fair price. Those who wish to buy an annuity will have to provide an estimate of what it would cost today to buy an equivalent income stream. This will give the consumer some sense of the value of what they are foregoing if they sell their annuity.

Firms wishing to buy annuities will be obliged to recommend sellers take advice and “shop around”. However, advice will only be mandatory for pots above a certain size and individuals with valuable pension rights spread across several pots might not come within the scope. It is also not yet clear how widely available such advice will be, nor what it might cost.

The best guarantee of consumers getting a decent price for their annuity will be if there are a good number of competing buyers. Interestingly, the FCA document suggests there could be as many as 10 potential direct buyers of annuities: seven insurers buying back “directly” and three other firms.

HM Revenue & Customs has published a separate consultation on the tax framework for the new market. The document makes clear individuals will be allowed to sell their annuity “regardless of whether the annuity being assigned is treated under the current tax rules as a lifetime annuity or a scheme pension”. The scope of this market is not just those that have used a pension pot to buy an individual annuity but could also include people who have rights under money purchase or defined benefit pension schemes where these are in the form of an annuity they can assign.

A seller will have three options: receive a cash lump sum, pay the proceeds into a flexi-access drawdown fund or use the proceeds to buy a flexible annuity or a different annuity (for example, a single life instead of a joint life). HMRC says lump-sum proceeds will be treated as pension income liable to tax at the member’s marginal rate of income tax but that payments into a flexi-access drawdown fund will not be taxable (though subsequent withdrawals will be taxed in the usual way).

Finally, the Treasury has recently concluded its own separate consultation on the “secondary legislation” needed to make the secondary annuity market a reality. This document includes a draft of the legislation that would surround the three new “specified activities” of buying an annuity, “buying back” an annuity and acting as an annuity broker. It confirms the Government has moved from its original position where it thought it would be a mistake to allow annuity providers to “buy back” annuities they had issued.

The key challenge is to make sure well-informed or well-advised consumers can take advantage of these new freedoms while protecting those for whom selling their annuity would be a mistake. But the consumer protection regime proposed is simply not strong enough. Potential buyers will be able to approach annuity holders directly, offer them a price that will sound attractive as a capital lump sum and carry out the transaction without the seller having shopped around, sought advice (for pots below the mandatory advice threshold) or even contacted the free Pension Wise guidance service.

At the very least, thought should be given to making sure those with worthwhile pension pots have obtained at least two quotes or even make sure that all sales happen through a regulated bureau or broker. Otherwise, despite all the careful consultation currently under way, this attempt to extend the laudable principle of pension “freedom” could backfire.

Steve Webb is director of policy at Royal London



RBS axes another 900 roles

RBS is cutting a further 900 jobs as part of a drive to save £800m this year. According to the BBC, the roles will mostly be back office and IT jobs. The announcement follows RBS cutting back its face-to-face advice service in March leading to around 550 job cuts and the closure of 32 NatWest […]

Adam Wrench London & Colonial

London & Colonial eyes management buyout

Sipp firm London & Colonial is planning to launch a management buyout of the company, Money Marketing can reveal. Last year Money Marketing reported L&C had approached other Sipp providers about a possible sale, but it has since decided to raise new cash to fund an acquisition and buy out minority shareholders. Head of Product Adam […]

The changing world of professional connections

The Legal Services Act of 2007, which opened up the legal market to competition, has put the cat among the professional pigeons. In the words of a 2015 Law Society report on what the legal profession is likely to look like in five years’ time: “Business as usual is not an option for many, if […]

Guide cover

Guide: Johnson Fleming produces auto-enrolment checklist

For a job as big as managing the auto-enrolment changes, it’s important to know what has been completed and what still lies in front of you to give you the reassurance that everything is in hand. Getting the planning and project management right at the outset can help you see the path ahead and ensure everyone knows their roles and responsibilities. To help with this, Johnson Fleming has produced a checklist outlining every step that needs to be taken when preparing for auto-enrolment.


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There are 2 comments at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. All of this will generate costs for the providers in one form or another.

    It will also provide an opening for compensation if/when it all goes pearshaped.

    Nothing changes.

  2. Julian Stevens 22nd June 2016 at 1:51 pm

    The fundamental question is: Which providers are likely to want to buy an annuity currently in payment other than at a substantial discount on the value of the estimated remaining instalments? They won’t do it without underwriting and that will cost time and money. They might buy an annuity already past any guaranteed payment term, the annuitant dies the following week and the buyer is left with nothing. There aren’t very many providers in the new annuity market anyway.

    As for advice, how many advisers are likely to want to go anywhere near this market? The risks of a later complaint being upheld by the FOS are off the scale.

    This whole idea is predicated on winding back the clock to when annuity purchase was the only alternative to DrawDown and I predict that it simply won’t get off the starting blocks.

Leave a comment


Why register with Money Marketing ?

Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

Money Marketing Events
Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

Research and insight
Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

Have your say
Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

Register now

Having problems?

Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm