View more on these topics

Investment Insight: Big trouble brewing in China

Markets are underestimating the potential for turmoil in the world’s second largest economy

It has been a tough few months for China’s economy. Years of credit-intensive growth have left the government with a huge debt pile – much of it off the books from shadow banking. The deleveraging process is currently in full swing as the government cracks down on the sector. This is proving painful as recent data has shown.

Chinese equities have been down while the onshore renminbi exchange rate fell to its lowest for 12 months in July.

Much of the media is attributing these moves to US president Donald Trump’s trade crusade against China. Some even suggest it may be a deliberate tactic on Beijing’s part to show Trump what a trade war would actually look like. But this misses the point: internal weakness is already enough to justify dampened investor sentiment there.

FE: Don’t despair on Chinese equities just yet

Back in 2015, there were similar concerns over China’s slowing growth rate, under pressure currency and credit-worthiness of many companies. Then, the government’s response was to inject large amounts of liquidity into the system and pump up the economy. It worked, and demand from China’s growth spurt was one of the main reasons 2016 was so positive for the global economy and emerging markets, in particular.

Reluctant to act

Now, however, the government appears reluctant to do the same. While it has effectively eased financial conditions somewhat recently (and is the only emerging market to do so), it shows no sign of embarking on the same stimulus programme as a few years ago.

That is understandable; the credit-fuelled binge of 2015/16 is one of the reasons the problem now is so big. Overleveraging – particularly among the old and monolithic state-owned enterprises – led to a huge build-up of debt in weak institutions.

Just as historically low rates and quantitative easing perpetuated zombie companies in the west, many Chinese companies have come to rely on easy credit for their cashflow.

Tatton boss: ‘Creating a DFM doesn’t happen overnight’

The fact much of this borrowing came from the shadow banking sector and was kept off the books is also important. From the government’s perspective, a large part of the problem is it does not even know how badly companies are indebted – even the SOEs directly run by the state. Misreporting is widespread.

Statistical manipulation

This is symptomatic of a wider problem in corporate China: governance structures are weak. This may sound an odd thing to say of a country whose ruling party is about as iron-fist as they come but recent news backs it up.

Last week, China’s statistics bureau acknowledged it had revised past data on corporate profits. It also revealed an investigation had uncovered 72 cases of illegal statistical manipulation at the national level and more than 7,000 cases at the municipal level between 2017 and April this year.

This makes a huge difference to economic data and casts more doubt on the reliability of official figures.

For example, the bureau reported industrial profits had grown by 16.5 per cent on the year during January to May once last year’s figure was revised down. But without that revision, the figure for this year would be a 6 per cent drop from the year before.

Even the retail sector – thought to be highly accurate in its reporting – showed a huge downward revision: the bureau reported 7.5 per cent year-on-year sales growth in January to May, but based on last year’s figures it would have been a 9.1 per cent decrease.

What next for multi-asset?

The careers of Chinese officials are often tied to GDP and tax data, so they have incentive to pressure companies into padding reports.

This is important, as it erodes one thing that reassures investors on China: that the state is in full control.

No matter what measures the government rolls out to counter this economic weakness, if they are going on false information, they likely will not be effective.

So, the extent to which the party-state apparatus is in control of the running of corporates and the SOEs is exaggerated.

Prepare for turmoil

This is why we think markets may be underestimating the potential for economic turmoil in China. The combination of excessive debt leverage and widespread financial misinformation is reminiscent of the situation in the US prior to the financial crisis.

When you add in a general economic weakness and the external shock that could come from Trump’s trade wars, things could quickly turn for the worse in the world’s second largest economy.

China’s ruling party is about as iron-fist as they come, but its governance structures are weak

To be clear, we do not think a crash is the likeliest outcome. While the sense of control may be exaggerated, the centralised nature of power in China means the government can react quickly to dangers in the economy. What is more, the state has a healthy balance sheet and can can take a huge chunk of the debt burden off SOEs and the private sector if necessary.

But we do think markets underestimate the potential for a crash. The government will try to restructure and deleverage the economy, but things could spiral out of control and cause a sudden downturn – not just in China but in all emerging markets and to some extent the global economy.

Lothar Mentel is chief executive of Tatton Investment Management



Aviva and tech provider take joint responsibility for platform errors

Aviva is telling platform users that third party technology provider FNZ is jointly responsible for fixing errors experienced because of its replatforming project in January. Aviva moved assets on its platform from Bravura technology to FNZ six months ago but the project has been beset with issues, including advisers and clients not receiving payments, trades […]

Pension scam ruling puts focus back on scheme duties

A ruling from The Pensions Ombudsman has turned the focus back on schemes and employers over what responsibilities they should bear when savers are scammed. While TPO rulings cannot set precendent, and are decided based on what is fair and reasonable by the particular adjudicator, a judgment in a case involving a police officer who […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm